User talk:Sitush

Caste promotion account
Hello, please look at this user he is editing majority particular caste related articles and is heavily using doubtful references. He is Rajput promoting account only. Check his contributions.

War article without any authentic source
Please once see this Battle of Mandan page. Not a single source looks credible. 2 out of 3 the sources are even low rated on Google books and one is by a caste historian.

References

1) Hooja, Rima (2006). A History of Rajasthan. Rupa and company.

2) Sinh, Ranbir (2001). History of Shekhawats. p. 280.

3) Meharda, B.L. Territory, Polity, and Status- A Study of Shekhawats.

Here 1st source is from some Rupa company, other 2 are from caste writers not credible historians.

This whole article is a propoganda against reality. Please User:Sitush check it.

Speedy deletion nomination of Category:Rajput clans of Haryana


A tag has been placed on Category:Rajput clans of Haryana indicating that it is currently empty, and is not a disambiguation category, a category redirect, a featured topics category, under discussion at Categories for discussion, or a project category that by its nature may become empty on occasion. If it remains empty for seven days or more, it may be deleted under section C1 of the criteria for speedy deletion.

If you think this page should not be deleted for this reason you may contest the nomination by visiting the page and removing the speedy deletion tag. Liz Read! Talk! 03:51, 29 May 2024 (UTC)

Earlier Pages Thiyya, Thiyyas are redirected now a new page by changing the spelling to Tiyyar
Hi @Sitush, I see that you have dealt with this issue multiple times.

Thiyya and Ezhava are considered as synonymous by Wikipedia and all admins and majority of editors, and this was already discussed multiple times and are included in the main page Ezhava, However a small group from both sides seems to claim that both are separate.

This has been overly discussed every year from 2012 ownwards(almost every year) and the final decision was or consensus was that both are synonymous from the WP:RAJ Sources. (Please see the links )

[] [] []

In addition to that multiple accounts in the name thiyya, thiyyas, tiyyas etc were created previously claiming that these are distinct from Ezhava, However in all cases the consensus was that all these pages in the names "thiyya,tiyyas,thiyyas were permanently redirected to the page Ezhava.

[] [] []

However now a new page Tiyyar is being created (or lifted redirect ), pointing to the same people Thiyya/Thiyyas simply by changing the spelling of the name Thiyya to "Tiyyar".

From the logs I can see that you have already given a warning to user -"HariNellatt" (see link) [] a month ago who was disruptively lifting the redirect without any further discussions.

Isn't this a mockery of the system that already such a consensus was made regarding this and the pages were permanently redirected to the main pageEzhava, but simply new pages are being created by changing the spellings pointing to the same group thiyya.

I think this also need to be either moved to a draftspace or need to be permanently redirected similar to thiyya and thiyyas as multiple people are simply lifting the redirect with different claims, just like what happended with older pages thiyya and thiyyas Lisa121996 (talk) 02:02, 2 July 2024 (UTC)


 * WP:GAMENAME Another one in the name "thiyar" is sent as draft.
 * An ongoing issue of randomly lifting the redirect (only temporarily solved ) is also happening in recent Tiyyar
 * The irony is that these groups have again submitted another draft in the name "Thiyar" making similar claims and pointing to similar people . link - [], that means 6 th duplicate copy "Thiyar" is being created after "thiyya,tiyyas,thiyyas,thiyyar and Tiyyar
 * My humble question is what is a permanent solution for this ?? They are simply changing the spelling and coming up with the same contents and talking about the same people. Ezhava, this is been discussed since a long time. Again is there any permanent solution to this ? I am amazed to see , How such a credible platform is being exploited by these groups simply by changing the spellings. Lisa121996 (talk) 15:10, 2 July 2024 (UTC)