User talk:Triona/Proposal for bureaucrat mediated administrator review

rarity
This approach seems to be under the misapprehension that desysopping has in the past been rare. In fact there have been 79 admins desysopped or who have resigned but can't have the tools back without an RFA. There has also been at least one temporary desyopping that has subsequently been reversed. For a group that has existed for less than a decade, has only briefly numbered more than a thousand and on average been far fewer, this is actually quite a high rate of desysopping, probably in the order of 10 per thousand per annum. IMHO we should be worried as to why we have such a high rate of desyopping, rather than thinking it is low and assuming that something is wrong with Arbcom.  Ϣere Spiel  Chequers 12:02, 11 August 2010 (UTC)