User talk:Tryptofish/RfCAdDraft

De-adminship proposal checklist

List of changes
I'm making a list here (for now, mostly for my own use) of changes to make in the CDA version, to create the new RfC/Ad version. --Tryptofish (talk) 19:18, 12 March 2010 (UTC)


 * 1) Change name from Community De-Adminship to Request for Comment/Administrator.
 * 2) All final decisions to be made by ArbCom, not by community.
 * 3) Nominated admin has 7 days before certification to make defense, which appears on main discussion page.
 * 4) Editor nominators are responsible for entire nomination, once certified; must document past dispute resolution, and must document canvassing.
 * 5) Eliminate all votes, !votes, and percentages. Discussion is numbered comments in 4 areas: support de-sysop, support alternative sanction, oppose sanction, and neutral.
 * 6) Nominators do not make numbered comments.
 * 7) Nominated admin can list challenges to nominators and commenting users.
 * 8) Two possible outcomes: referred to ArbCom, or no action.
 * 9) Referred to ArbCom is either consensus for de-sysop of admin, consensus for other sanction for admin, or consensus that editor nomination was bad-faith. Latter can occur with speedy closure, but never for failed nomination (not certified) or comments withdrawn before certification of nomination.
 * 10) Add CENT to publicity.