User talk:Ubanteux

Regarding the review of Earth Maiden Arjuna Explaining why I think the link shouldn't stay
Hi. There is no limit per se on the amount of reviews for a particular film/tv-series. I am not however certain if the review you added should be kept, for two reasons: First, the website it's on is not particularly notable, and secondly because I'm assuming that you are the original author of that review (judging from your username), and linking to material you have created yourself is not usually accepted in Wikipedia, as WP should not be used for self-promotion. If the community sees it as a valid, notable and relevant review, someone else will likely add it. I have thus removed the link. If you'd still like to have the link added, I suggest you ask other editors' opinion on article's talk page, but please do not put it back without further discussion. If you have any questions I'd be glad to answer on my talk. --Twinzor Say hi! - Do I suck or rock? 21:06, 6 October 2008 (UTC)

I added the review because I felt the others did not present accurate descriptions of the anime. I felt if I added additional descriptions to the page itself they would not be verifiable as they present a different point of view, rather than any facts. Users looking for an in-depth review that does not cater to polities might find a different view beneficial. At least, that was my rationale.Ubanteux (talk) 23:12, 6 October 2008 (UTC)


 * I appreciate your point of view and have opened discussion on the matter on the article's talk page. You are most welcome to join the discussion there! --Twinzor Say hi! - Do I suck or rock? 23:35, 6 October 2008 (UTC)