User talk:Uparat

I am concerned that there is no evidence to support the claim from the author, or even the supporters of the author in the keep or not keep article, accessible in the article on Maurice Frydman that he was born on 20 October 1901 and in Warsaw. Neither the date or the location are supported by the people who knew him well such as Barry Gordon and Apa B Pant in their published articles. The former, who lived with him for several years has that "Maurice was born in 1894 in the Jewish ghetto of Krakow, Poland, to a very poor family". He also has in the same source that "I first met Maurice when he was a feisty seventy-six-year-old, and instantly felt I had found a long lost friend and grandfather", which was in 1971/2, has that in 1926 Maurice first met Annie Besant and Jiddu Krishnamurti, a very close friendship for nearly 50 years, [death in 1976], and that he was aged around 30 years at the time of the first meeting. This give a less precise birth year of 'around' 1896, but certainly closer to 1894 than 1901. Several others who knew him in India also have the 1894 birth year but no one has the 1901 birth year and Warsaw as the location, it was Krakow. The rest of the Wikipedia article has a couple of errors and could be vastly improved as there is really nothing about his early life,with the article really only beginning in the 1930's. Uparat (talk) 05:56, 11 February 2022 (UTC)