User talk:VAReporter

Ian Ayres criticism and BD McCullough's review
I do not believe I "completely distorted" McCullough's review as you commented.

McCullough's view is there are several points in his review: "the passage you wrote ("In his review...")accurately represents a focus of my review. However, the passage favored by VAReporter ("Professors at other universities...") also accurately represents another focus of my review."

I feel the plagiarism controversy is adequately covered by citing Leonhardt whose work Ayres copied without proper acknowledgement, but when one of the leading experts on econometrics writes that SuperCrunchers is not about supercrunching, there is a bigger gorilla in the room. Naaman Brown (talk) 17:55, 29 January 2010 (UTC)