User talk:Volunteer Marek/Archives/2008/September

Lies
As I don't have any 'sock-puppets' (whatever that is meant to mean) this personal attack on me is a lie: "You and your sock puppets seem to be the only objectors." Please withdraw it and apologise or I shall report you to admins forthwith. Colin4C (talk) 22:36, 10 September 2008 (UTC)

Lenin and the Jews
By the way, most of the material was copied into other articles from the Lenin article, not vice versa. This is a common practice amongst lazy editors and should not be used as an excuse to delete the original material. If you look at the edit history you will see that the Lenin and the Jews section grew incrementally over a period of years, it was not copied en bloc from another article. Lenin and the Bolsheviks policy towards the Jews was a radical departure from the previous history of Russia and the whole subject has a bearing on Lenin's harsh attitude towards the church mentioned elsewhere in the article. Lenin saw the Orthodox church as the prime mover behind the Black Hundreds who initiated pogroms against the Jews. The whole issue of anti-Semitic pogroms was a live issue during the Revolution, with the Reds warning that they were a manifestation of right-wing White terror and the Whites using them as an instrument of policy in actual pogroms and also vis-a-vis their proposed bloody mass pogrom of what they saw as a Jewish/Bolshevik government if they had ever captured Moscow (as per the reaction after the Paris Commune in 1871). White Anti-Semitism was a popular rallying standard for right-wing opponents of the Bolsheviks. Basically the Civil War was a stand off between the extreme right and the extreme left. The liberals didn't figure either in numbers or military strength. Ant-Semitism and anti-anti-Semitism it is an issue of a fundamental importance to the history of the time. Just out of interest do the deletionists think that in articles dealing with the history of the Third Reich that 'Hitler's attitude to the Jews' is an unimportant matter which should be relegated to a peripheral article. The Whites practised the same genocide against the Jews as Hitler. Lenin's attitude towards the Jews was therefore as important in historical terms as Hitler's attitude. Colin4C (talk) 19:10, 11 September 2008 (UTC)

Monetary inflation
Would you mind taking a look at Monetary inflation. Same general problems as with Inflation, but with the side issue that some editors claim that this should be a venue for presentation of the Austrian view. At some point, administrative intervention is likely to be needed to end an edit war, but it would be good to check that there is a general consensus among mainstream editors.JQ (talk) 00:13, 20 September 2008 (UTC)

This user is a suspected sockpuppet of Gregalton
This user is a suspected sockpuppet of Gregalton

PennySeven (talk) 05:57, 26 September 2008 (UTC)

Is this meant seriously? If so, I'm confident you're way offbeam and should be much more careful before making such allegations. If not, you should read WP:AGF and WP:POINT. I know some of your contributions have been edited pretty sharply, but that's part of the project. I've had whole articles deleted quite a few times. JQ (talk) 06:05, 26 September 2008 (UTC)


 * Hehe. That's pretty funny. Click on my contributions and then do the same for Gregalton. Also I'm much less inclined than he is to put up with your nonsense.radek (talk) 06:08, 26 September 2008 (UTC)

Please stop deleting paragraphs from the Inflation article with references.
Please stop deleting paragraphs from the Inflation article with referencesPennySeven (talk) 11:35, 26 September 2008 (UTC)