User talk:WardenWalk

Binomial Series
I would like to know the example I posted why it was removed for the Binomial Series page ?

Matyos1


 * Welcome to Wikipedia, Matyos1! The reason is explained at Talk:Binomial_series.  Wikipedia is supposed to display the standard treatment of a topic, as evidenced by well-respected books on the subject.  It is not supposed to be a showcase for new research.  I had never before seen any textbook that discusses the "2-ray ground reflect model" in the context of the binomial series, and it seemed out of place to me, so I questioned this on the Talk page above and waited eight days to see if anyone would provide a reference.  No one did, and no one objected to the removal, so after the eight days, I removed the link.  If you can suggest a published book that discusses the "2-ray ground reflect model" in the context of the binomial series, then I would be happy to reinstate your link.  Best wishes, WardenWalk (talk) 14:22, 15 August 2009 (UTC)


 * Thank you for the reply WardenWalk ,I understand that this was research and not from a well   respected book.

The reason for this was to show an example using Binomial Series to solve wireless propagation approximation problem in 2-Ray Ground reflection model which was asked for a solution to one of the problems in "Wireless Communications,Principles and Practice "book by Theodore S.Rappaport ISBN 0-13-375536-3,Chapter 3 .Problem 3.3

I solved this problem by using Binomial Series in the example I posted instead of Taylor Series Approximation ,which was stated in the book .It holds true and I welcome any corrections if errors or invalidity seen .This research was independently done by me and I welcome my work to be put into examination by me peers.

However I assure you the sole purpose of my posting is to contribute to the advancement of science by giving another way of visualizing approximating problems and I have no intention or desire to maliciously confound any well established science topics.

I am hoping that I hear from you again soon and wish you all the best.

(talk) 11:03, 17 August 2009 (EDT) —Preceding unsigned comment added by 64.187.30.34 (talk)

I confirm that above talk was Matyos1  the IP 64.187.30.34  address was me. I apologize I was not logged on then talk) 12:18, 17 August 2009 (EDT)]]


 * Thank you, Matyos1, for the explanation. I am not doubting the correctness of your research, and I understand now that you had the best of intentions.  My feeling is just that it is not appropriate for Wikipedia, at least not for the binomial series page. (By the way, when editing, you can automatically add a signature to your posts by typing four tildes, or clicking the four tildes a little bit below the "Edit Summary", where it says "Sign your posts on talk pages:".) WardenWalk (talk) 18:02, 17 August 2009 (UTC)

Thanks for the tip WardenWalk matyosMB 19:12, 17 August 2009 (UTC) matyosMB 19:12, 17 August 2009 (UTC) —Preceding unsigned comment added by Matyos1 (talk • contribs)