Wikipedia:AMA Requests for Assistance/Requests/December 2006/Akparker

Wikipedian filing request:



Other Wikipedians this pertains to:



Wikipedia pages this pertains to:



Questions:
Have you read the AMA FAQ?
 * Answer: Yes

'''How would you describe the nature of this dispute? (policy violation, content dispute, personal attack, other)'''
 * Answer: Content dispute

'''What methods of Dispute Resolution have you tried so far? If you can, please provide wikilinks so that the Advocate looking over this case can see what you have done.'''
 * Answer: I had reposted an article on Gene Stallings multiple times, and I have since apologized to user STS01; my actions in that regard were inappropriate. However, STS01 continues to post material on Gene Stallings (a living person) that is subjective and negative; STS01 also deletes my own edits, which he/she calls over-inflated.

What do you expect to get from Advocacy?
 * Answer: A way to mediate this dispute.

Summary:
Editor STS01 and I obviously have very different opinions of Gene Stallings. STS01 appears determined to post opinions of Gene Stallings that cast him in a negative light. Furthermore, STS01 has repeatedly deleted my own edits of Gene Stallings' accomplishments, which I feel are pertinent to the article. I apologized to STS01 for poorly handling this situation initially, hoping it would open a dialogue. That dialogue has not happened. From my perspective, STS01 has a poor opinion of Gene Stallings; I have a good opinion of Gene Stallings. Obviously there are two sides to this debate. I am willing to allow STS01's negative comments if STS01 would allow me to post my positive comments. I will, of course, cite sources.

Discussion:
Apparently AKparker is related to or has intimate feelings for this person. His only contribution here is to this one page and he is obsessively trying to remove facts about this mans life that are not to his liking. I was not the originator of the current statements about his involvement in NCAA sactions but they are factual and I agree that they are a significant chapter of his legacy and life and should be included on the page. What I do not think should be included are detailed narrations of every Alabama football season he coached in. If AKparker was not an obsessive Alabama football fan, he would spend a little time expanding the other parts of this page and not just the end of his career at the University of Alabama. - User:STS01 14:59, 6 December 2006

Questions for clarity
AKparker: Looking at the page as it stands right now, I am wondering if you can let me know exactly what is included that should not be and what isn't included that should be. If you could also let me know your reasoning for this.

STS01: If you are so inclined, please feel free to respond as well.

Thanks, Jord 19:04, 13 December 2006 (UTC)

AKparker's comments
Jord This issue has been resolved to my satisfaction. Thank you for your help.

STS01's comments
I think this dispute was resolved once AKparker made the statement that he would leave my contributions if I left his. This page has been stable for several days now.

Other comments

 * I've closed the request as the requestee has already resolved the issue with the other editor(s). - Jord 16:50, 14 December 2006 (UTC)

Followup:
When the case is finished, please take a minute to fill out the following survey:

Did you find the Advocacy process useful?
 * Answer:

Did your Advocate handle your case in an appropriate manner?
 * Answer:

On a scale of 1 (worst) to 5 (best), how polite was your Advocate?
 * Answer:

On a scale of 1 to 5, how effective do you feel your Advocate was in solving the problem?
 * Answer:

On a scale of 1 to 5, how effective do you feel the Advocacy process is altogether?
 * Answer:

If there were one thing that you would like to see different in the Advocacy process, what would it be?
 * Answer:

If you were to deal with this dispute again, what would you do differently, if anything?
 * Answer:

AMA Information
Case Status: closed

Advocate Status:
 * Jord 18:20, 13 December 2006 (UTC)