Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/A Good Man (1941 film)


 * The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's talk page or in a deletion review).  No further edits should be made to this page.

The result was procedural close per WP:TRAINWRECK. In addition to being an unmanageable nomination, none of the articles other than A Good Man (1941 film) were tagged for deletion. I noticed that José María y María José: Una pareja de hoy was nominated for deletion with WP:PROD. In addition to the one "keep" !vote here, these are unlikely to go without controversy if they are deleted citing WP:CSD. I suggest going the standard route of using PROD where it can be applied and individual WP:AFD nominations where PROD has failed before. ✗ plicit  09:15, 19 November 2022 (UTC)

A Good Man (1941 film)

 * – ( View AfD View log | edits since nomination)

This and the following unsourced empty placeholder sub stubs were created by me in 2009 to remove redirects and were never expanded. It is making the cleanup job much more difficult and would make the task easier if they were deleted, I cleanup the other content and then create the missing articles by director with proper content using the director templates. The stubs aren't being expanded by anybody and wouldn't be much of a loss if we delete them until they are recreated properly when the time is right. ♦ Dr. Blofeld  18:12, 12 November 2022 (UTC)


 * A Journey to the Beyond
 * Becquer's Great Love
 * Bloody Pleasure
 * Blue Commandos
 * Bodas de cristal
 * Boy Who Goes Singing
 * Cacique Bandeira
 * Carlos Gardel, historia de un ídolo
 * Casi un sueño
 * Chão, amor
 * Cinco grandes y una chica
 * Cochengo Miranda
 * Compañeros de aventuras
 * Con el más puro amor
 * Con mi mujer no puedo
 * Contigo y aquí
 * Corazón de turco
 * Crimen en el hotel alojamiento
 * Crónica de una señora
 * Cuando florezca el naranjo
 * Dama de compañía
 * Daughter of the Minister
 * De turno con la muerte
 * Del brazo con la muerte
 * Derecho viejo
 * Deshojando margaritas
 * Después de la tormenta
 * Destino para dos
 * Diario (film)
 * Difunta Correa (film)
 * Disloque en el presidio
 * Don Bildigerno de Pago Milagro
 * Don Carmelo il capo
 * Don Frutos Gómez
 * Donde comienzan los pantanos
 * Dos en el mundo
 * El Buho
 * El Cabo Tijereta
 * El Cantor del circo
 * El Casamiento de Chichilo
 * El Complejo de Felipe
 * El Derecho a la felicidad
 * El Derecho de gozar
 * El Destino (1971 film)
 * El Día que me quieras (1969 film)
 * El Encanto del amor prohibido
 * El Encuentro (film)
 * El Fantástico mundo de María Montiel
 * El Gordo Villanueva
 * El Gordo de América
 * El Gran camarada
 * El Gran crucero
 * El Heroico Bonifacio
 * El Hijo de la calle
 * El Hombre de las sorpresas
 * El Hombre del año
 * El Hombre y su noche
 * El Infortunado Fortunato
 * El Inquisidor
 * El Ladrón canta boleros
 * El Millonario
 * El Mundo es de los jóvenes
 * El Mundo que inventamos
 * El Pecado más lindo del mundo
 * El Profesor Tirabombas
 * El Protegido
 * El Proyecto
 * El Que recibe las bofetadas
 * El Rey en Londres
 * El diablo metió la pata
 * El extraño caso de la mujer asesinada
 * El loro de la soledad
 * El profesor patagónico
 * Embrujo
 * Embrujo de amor
 * En mi casa mando yo
 * Escándalo nocturno
 * Especialista en señoras
 * Esquiú, una luz en el sendero
 * Este loco, loco, Buenos Aires
 * Familia unida que espera la llegada de Halloween
 * Favela (film)
 * Flor de piolas
 * Fortín alto
 * Fragata Sarmiento (film)
 * From the Abyss (film)
 * Fronteras de la ley
 * Fuiste mía un verano
 * Furia en la isla
 * Galería de esperanzas
 * Gente en Buenos Aires
 * Goleta austral
 * Growing Up Suddenly
 * Gypsy (1970 film)
 * Hasta siempre Carlos Gardel
 * Hay que casar a Ernesto
 * Hay que casar a Paulina
 * Hay que parar la delantera
 * He nacido en la ribera
 * Hombres a precio
 * Horas marcadas
 * Héroes de blanco
 * Héroes de hoy
 * I Need a Mother
 * Intriga de otros mundos
 * Jacinta Pichimauida se enamora
 * José María y María José: Una pareja de hoy
 * Kuma Ching
 * La Calle grita
 * La Chismosa
 * La Cigarra está que arde
 * La Colimba no es la guerra
 * La Cueva de Ali-Babá
 * La Cómplice
 * La Diosa virgen
 * La Familia Falcón
 * La Flor de la mafia
 * La Fuerza ciega
 * La Gorda
 * La Gran felicidad
 * La Gran tentación
 * La Guerra de los sostenes
 * La Isla de los dibujos
 * La Joven casada
 * La Mujer de tu prójimo
 * La Nueva cigarra
 * La Pandilla inolvidable
 * La Parda Flora
 * La Perra
 * La Pícara cenicienta
 * La Ronda de los Dientes Blancos
 * La Vida de una mujer
 * La Voz del tambor
 * La culpa la tuvo el otro
 * La fiaca
 * La honra de los hombres
 * La melodía perdida
 * La novia (film)
 * La nueva Francia
 * Las Dos culpas de Bettina
 * Las Modelos
 * Las Mujeres los prefieren tontos
 * Las Muñecas que hacen pum
 * Las Ratas (film)
 * Las Ruteras
 * Lejos del cielo
 * Let's Play in the World
 * Libertad bajo palabra
 * Life Goes On (1969 film)
 * Lindor Covas, el cimarrón
 * Los Chantas
 * Los Chiflados dan el golpe
 * Los Cuatro secretos
 * Los Doctores las prefieren desnudas
 * Los Días que me diste
 * Los Hijos de Fierro
 * Los Hijos del otro
 * Los Junqueros
 * Los Muchachos de mi barrio
 * Los Orilleros
 * Los Pequeños aventureros
 * Los Verdes paraísos
 * Los de la mesa 10
 * Los médicos
 * Los ojos más lindos del mundo
 * Los que verán a Dios
 * Lucecita (1976 film)
 * Luces de mis zapatos
 * Madre Alegría
 * Mala gente
 * Male and Female Since Adam and Eve
 * Mami (1971 film)
 * Mansedumbre
 * Margarito Tereré
 * Marido de ocasión
 * Martín pescador
 * Mary tuvo la culpa
 * Mate Cosido
 * Me casé con una estrella
 * Me enamoré sin darme cuenta
 * Mi hijo Ceferino Namuncurá
 * Mi mujer, la sueca y yo
 * Mi vida por la tuya
 * Millonario por un día
 * Minguito Tinguitela, papá
 * Mirad los lirios del campo
 * Mosaico
 * Mother of the Bride (1978 film)
 * Muchas gracias de nada (film)
 * Muerte civil
 * Mujeres perdidas
 * My Days with Veronica
 * My Husband Doesn't Do It
 * Máscaras en otoño
 * Nacha Regules
 * Newcomers to Love
 * No Slacking Off in Life
 * Olga, la hija de aquella princesa rusa
 * Operación Comando
 * Operación G
 * Pampa y cielo
 * Patrulla norte
 * Paula contra la mitad más uno
 * Pelota de cuero
 * Pepper and Red Pepper
 * Pesadilla
 * Piloto de pruebas
 * Plaza Huincul (Pozo Uno)
 * Pocholo, Pichuca y yo
 * Puntos suspensivos o Esperando a los bárbaros
 * Que me toquen las golondrinas
 * Quinto año nacional
 * Rebelde con causa
 * Rebelión en los llanos
 * Recuerdos de un ángel
 * Rescate de sangre
 * Rio turbio (film)
 * Ritmo, amor y juventud
 * Ritmo a todo color
 * Romance sin palabras
 * Rosa de América
 * Sacred Fire (film)
 * Sixteen (1943 film)
 * State of Reality
 * The Backpackers
 * The Beach of Love
 * The Campanelli's Summer
 * The Doctress Wants Tangos
 * The Lion's Share (1978 film)
 * The Man from Saturday
 * Today It's My Wife's Turn
 * Un Elefante color ilusión
 * Un Hombre solo no vale nada
 * Un Idilio de estación
 * Un Momento muy largo
 * Un viaje de locos
 * Una Cabaña en la pampa
 * Una Excursión a los indios ranqueles
 * Una Máscara para Ana
 * Una Noche cualquiera
 * Una Ventana a la vida
 * Una Ventana al éxito
 * Vacation in Argentina
 * Vallejos
 * Vampiros los prefieren gorditos
 * Vení conmigo
 * Vidalita
 * Villa Cariño
 * Vivir es formidable
 * Vivir un instante
 * Vuelva el primero
 * Vuelvo a vivir, vuelvo a cantar


 * Note: This discussion has been included in the deletion sorting lists for the following topics: Film and Argentina.  Spiderone (Talk to Spider) 18:32, 12 November 2022 (UTC)
 * Comment That's a bit many for one deletion request. Mixed opinion, suppose we can blank them and recreate later if needed. Oaktree b (talk) 21:30, 12 November 2022 (UTC)
 * Delete All of these films have no citations supporting notability and were created by one editor back in the day. That editor is now requesting deletion and I concur. Wikipedia is not an IMdB mirror, and just existing as a film does not guarantee inclusion here. If at some point another editor wishes to re-create one or more of these films on Wikipedia there would be no prejudice against that, as long as notability is established at that time. But as they stand now they have been perma-stubs for over a dozen years and they are not encyclopedic at this point. Donald D23   talk to me  03:05, 13 November 2022 (UTC)
 * Keep and expand. Did you do a WP:Before? Doing it for this many articles could take weeks. Anyhow, taking a look at the Spanish version of the articles (Vivir es formidable), it looks like notable critics reviewed the film, so the films must be notable. Leaning towards keep. This is not just for one of the articles -- see this. DareshMohan (talk) 03:07, 15 November 2022 (UTC)
 * Did you not read why I want them deleted. Many of them can be expanded but the task is so big it's putting me off wanting to work on any article to do with this subject. It's a mess. So long term we lose out having these stubs because they deter me from wanting to bother with this. They will be recreated when the time is right, and I would keep a list of what would be deleted.♦ Dr. Blofeld  17:07, 15 November 2022 (UTC)
 * Speedy Delete, G7 - As the nom. has indicated, they created these as stubs themself. WP:BEFORE is irrelevant in this case as these all meet speedy deletion criterion WP:G7. Author requests deletion. They are stubs. No one else has added anything in 13 years. If anyone wanted to expand them, recreation is trivial and nothing is lost by the deletion. Credit must be given to the creator for both intending to expand the project but also seeking to clean up where expansion has not yielded benefits. Sirfurboy🏄 (talk) 16:11, 15 November 2022 (UTC)


 * The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this page.