Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Carl Whitney


 * The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's talk page or in a deletion review).  No further edits should be made to this page.  

The result was no consensus - keep. There are also some important questions raised here which should be answered. Best to err on side of caution. --JodyByak, yak, yak 21:08, 10 August 2007 (UTC)

Carl Whitney

 * – (View AfD) (View log)

Non-notable player, per WikiProject Baseball. Kinston eagle 00:53, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
 * Note: This debate has been included in the list of baseball-related deletions.   —Kinston eagle 01:06, 3 August 2007 (UTC)

"Carl Whitney Carl Whitney (born September 7, 1913 - died July, 1986) was a Negro League baseball Player.
 * Delete Never played in the majors as per WikiProject Baseball. Never was a "Baseball executives, coaches, or manager" as per WikiProject Baseball. Never played in the "top professional league in his country" as per WikiProject Baseball. On the whole, a non-notable "reserve outfielder" with no sources. Kinston eagle 01:05, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
 * Keep Negro League Player.. the Negro Leaguers were the top professional league for African American players at the time. Spanneraol 01:17, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
 * Reply: This is not what the WikiProject Baseball guidelines say. In fact, the guidelines do not address the Negro Leagues at all. What you're saying is that every "reserve outfielder" who ever put on a uniform for a Negro League team is more notable than AAA players who are on the major league 40 man roster - who have been specifically barred from Wikipedia by the guidelines.
 * Reply Well my opinion is that the AAA players on the 40 man roster are NOT barred from Wiki by the guidelines.
 * Keep. I would love to see more info about him, and am of the opinion that anyone in the Negro leagues belongs in wikipedia as much as anyone in the majors.Ravenmasterq 01:58, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
 * Reply. To quote Ravenmasterq: "No stats in major league baseball' seems to clear this up" Kinston eagle 02:15, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
 * Reply. Yet, I think we have to treat the Negro leagues differently; remember there was prejudice, discrimination and a separation of black and white.  He played five years before Jackie Robinson, so there was no precedent for integration.  Therefore, for his 'kind', as might have been said in the day, he reached the highest level.Ravenmasterq 02:26, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
 * Weak delete: I really hate to say this, especially being a baseball fan, but I can't find anything on the guy - no stats, nothing. All I found was a bio at a site called whitneygen.org, which may or may not be a family site. Either way, it's not notable. It's not even reachable; all I could find was the cache file that said this:

In 1942, Whitney played as a reserve outfielder for the Bill "Bojangles" Robinson.

He is interred in the Calvary Cemetery in St. Louis, Missouri."

There just doesn't seem like enough to justify an article. It does, however, raise a good question best discussed elsewhere: What is the notability of the Negro League? — Preceding unsigned comment added by Sidatio (talk • contribs)
 * Thanks for catching the sig, Jaranda! Sidatio 03:21, 3 August 2007 (UTC)


 * Then, if we want to follow that train of thought, I will agree with a delete under the logic that we cannot verify he ever existed; not under the logic that he was a Negro League baseball player.Ravenmasterq 03:04, 3 August 2007 (UTC)


 * Delete I personally not convinced that a backup Negro League baseball player is notable. If there is some good sources out there, (can't find none online, or in the New York Times archives) than maybe it could be kept, other than that it fails WP:V Jaranda wat's sup 03:03, 3 August 2007 (UTC)


 * Dunno. Please don't accuse me of being hypocritical, but I am not sure what to do with Negro Leaguers. Per Ravenmasterq and Spanneraol, in a certain way they were the "top professional league in his country". They were in the top professional league for African-Americans. Plenty of Negro Leaguers could have played in the majors at that time, but they were held back because of racism. The Negro Leaguers were screwed then. Should they be screwed again on Wikipedia?--Truest blue 03:08, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
 * Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Baseball/Archive 39
 * I've taken the liberty of opening that discussion at WP Baseball - it seemed the most appropriate place. Perhaps we can reach a consensus on the issue there? (It's at the bottom of the page - I can't seem to get the link to work properly. :-p) We should probably leave the AfD to the specific subject of Mr. Whitney if it can be helped. Sidatio 03:19, 3 August 2007 (UTC)


 * Delete There is no third party sites saying anything about this guy. If someone could find anything reliable then he would definitely be notable. He played in the top level of his sport at the time(the Negro League was as far as an African American could get at the time.) as for people who say a back-up is not notable, as long as you were in a professional team and played in at least one game you are notable. Gorky  malorki  03:27, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
 * Comment: "as long as you were in a professional team and played in at least one game you are notable" Interesting. The same argument many of us use for minor leaguers.Kinston eagle 03:29, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
 * Negro League players are a complicated case. Before MLB integration, the level of competition in the Negro Leagues was pretty much equivalent to that of MLB, but after integration it quickly deteriorated. Record keeping was spotty (and often contradictory) in the early days, and schedules included numerous exhibitions against local teams of uneven quality, which is a hinderance to the establishment of one centralized listing of statistics. Personally, I would consider almost all pre-integration Negro League players for whom a sufficient documentary trail can be established to be notable. Once we're solidly into the post-integration period, I would tend to treat them as minor league players and only create/keep articles for those who received exceptional recognition of one sort or another. -Hit bull, win steak(Moo!) 03:30, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
 * As for Mr. Whitney himself: I don't have my copy handy right now, but the GBooks version of The Biographical Encyclopedia of the Negro Baseball Leagues (by James A. Riley) does in fact indicate that there was a Carl Whitney who was a Negro League ballplayer. As such, I would be inclined to Keep this article and encourage sourcing/expansion of it. -Hit bull, win steak(Moo!) 03:34, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
 * Comment Hit bull, win steak if you could cite that it would really help out in keeping this article. As of right now I think the main thing hurting this article is any kind of third party citation. I think the argument of negro league players is better dealt with in Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Baseball/Archive 39, not in WP:AFD.  Gorky  malorki  03:47, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
 * Like I said, I don't have the book with me; I loaned my copy to a guy who's out of town right now. If you want to track one down, the ISBN is 0786709596. It's fairly easy to find in libraries/bookstores. -Hit bull, win steak(Moo!) 03:56, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
 * If you do, Whitney's entry is on page 837 of the current edition. -Hit bull, win steak(Moo!) 04:00, 3 August 2007 (UTC)
 * Keep He played in a fully professional league so he meets WP:BIO. LukeHoC 02:22, 4 August 2007 (UTC)
 * Delete, can't see how this meets WP:V, among others. Stifle (talk) 14:06, 6 August 2007 (UTC)
 * The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this page.