Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/David Keane

 This page is an archive of the proposed deletion of the article below. Further comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's talk page or on a Votes for Undeletion nomination). No further edits should be made to this page.

The result of the debate was delete. This decision is without prejudice against the re-creation of an article at this title about the other David Keane mentioned below. Rossami (talk) 23:30, 14 July 2005 (UTC)

David Keane
Vanity page of a non-notable film editor, didn't even bother to link to his IMDB entry. Delete. Eliot 5 July 2005 18:24 (UTC) (In Production) (2000s)
 * Delete - NN JoJan 5 July 2005 19:04 (UTC)
 * Keep - he is notable. Look!: Producer - filmography

1. Guests of the Ayatollah (2005) (TV) (filming) (executive producer) 2. The Interrogators (2005) (TV) (filming) (executive producer) 3. Untitled Afghanistan Project (2005) (TV) (filming) (executive producer)

4. Targeted: Baby Faced Psycho (2004) (TV) (executive producer) 5. Targeted: Pineapple Face (2004) (TV) (executive producer) 6. Targeted: The Evil Genius (2004) (TV) (executive producer) 7. "Targeted: Osama Bin Laden" (2004) TV Series (executive producer) 8. "True Warriors" (2004) TV Series (executive producer) 9. The True Story of Blackhawk Down (2003) (TV) (executive producer) (producer) ... aka The True Story of Black Hawk Down (USA: DVD title) 10. The True Story of Killing Pablo (2002) (TV) (executive producer) 11. "On the Inside: Convict Air" (2001) TV Series (producer) 12. "Beach Watch: Newport Lifeguards" (2000) TV Series (producer)

Filmography as: Producer, Director, Writer, Miscellaneous Crew, Sound Department, Actor

Director - filmography (In Production) (2000s)

1. Guests of the Ayatollah (2005) (TV) (filming) 2. The Interrogators (2005) (TV) (filming) 3. Untitled Afghanistan Project (2005) (TV) (filming)

4. Targeted: Baby Faced Psycho (2004) (TV) 5. Targeted: Pineapple Face (2004) (TV) 6. Targeted: The Evil Genius (2004) (TV) 7. "Targeted: Osama Bin Laden" (2004) TV Series 8. "True Warriors" (2004) TV Series 9. The True Story of Blackhawk Down (2003) (TV) ... aka The True Story of Black Hawk Down (USA: DVD title) 10. The True Story of Killing Pablo (2002) (TV)

Filmography as: Producer, Director, Writer, Miscellaneous Crew, Sound Department, Actor

Writer - filmography

1. Targeted: Baby Faced Psycho (2004) (TV) 2. Targeted: Pineapple Face (2004) (TV) 3. Targeted: The Evil Genius (2004) (TV) 4. The True Story of Blackhawk Down (2003) (TV) ... aka The True Story of Black Hawk Down (USA: DVD title) 5. The True Story of Killing Pablo (2002) (TV) 6. "On the Inside: Convict Air" (2001) TV Series (writer) 7. "Beach Watch: Newport Lifeguards" (2000) TV Series (writer) 8. 'On the Inside: Catching Bank Robbers' (2000)

Filmography as: Producer, Director, Writer, Miscellaneous Crew, Sound Department, Actor

Miscellaneous Crew - filmography (2000s) (1990s)

1. The True Story of Blackhawk Down (2003) (TV) (somalia crew) ... aka The True Story of Black Hawk Down (USA: DVD title)

2. City Slickers (1991) (production assistant)

Filmography as: Producer, Director, Writer, Miscellaneous Crew, Sound Department, Actor

Sound Department - filmography

1. The Scroll (1992) (TV) (sound)

Filmography as: Producer, Director, Writer, Miscellaneous Crew, Sound Department, Actor

Actor - filmography

1. Final Run (1988) (TV) .... Dean


 * Weak keep - the above is verifiable but the article needs cleanup Cutler July 5, 2005 21:39 (UTC)
 * Delete, not notable. Wikipedia is not IMDb.  IMO, only notable TV writers (e.g. J.J. Abrams) or producers (e.g. Mark Burnett) need to be included.  I follow the entertainment industry closely and have never heard of ANY of the shows Mr. Keane produced or wrote.  Dcarrano July 5, 2005 22:43 (UTC)
 * Keep per IMDB entry. Kappa 5 July 2005 23:27 (UTC)
 * Delete. The article is not about the David Keane whose filmography is given above (Guests of the Ayatollah, etc.).  It's about Daithi Keane, whose filmography is much shorter:


 * Editor - filmography


 * 1) "Turas Teanga" (2004) TV Series
 * 2) Red Roses and Petrol (2003)
 * 3) Eireville (2002)
 * 4) "Fear an Phoist" (2002) TV Series
 * Miscellaneous Crew - filmography

I am not convinced that David is notable per User:Dcarrano, and Daithi has fewer credits than David. --Metropolitan90 July 5, 2005 23:45 (UTC)
 * 1) The Longest Day (2003) (script supervisor)
 * Annnnd, excellent point, the filmography provided by the unsigned user should be ignored. Dcarrano July 5, 2005 23:49 (UTC)
 * Comment. There are four options here. One is to rewrite the article to refer to the better known David Keane who IMDB shows when you search it for a David Keane. Another is to create a disambiguation article if David (Daithi) Keane is deemed worthy of an article. Another option is to have the main article about the better known David Keane with a reference stating For information on David (Daithi) Keane, please see our article on David (Daithi) Keane. Another is to delete this article with no articles on either man. My preference is to have an article on the better known David Keane. Capitalistroadster 6 July 2005 00:45 (UTC)
 * Keep if made into article on the other Keane, otherwise Delete, nn. --Etacar11 6 July 2005 00:48 (UTC)
 * Delete non notable. JamesBurns 6 July 2005 01:42 (UTC)
 * Delete following the hard notability criteria listed for film producers. Fifelfoo 6 July 2005 04:02 (UTC)
 * Delete, WP:VAIN. Radiant_ &gt;|&lt; July 6, 2005 13:43 (UTC)
 * Delete. Vanity, nn, etc. Gamaliel 7 July 2005 01:21 (UTC)


 * The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's talk page or in an undeletion request). No further edits should be made to this page.