Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nélida Nassar


 * The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the article below. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's talk page or in a deletion review).  No further edits should be made to this page.

The result was   delete.  Sandstein  11:34, 7 January 2012 (UTC)

Nélida Nassar

 * – ( View AfD View log )

I cannot find any significant coverage of this person in secondary sources, as required to meet WP:BIO. SmartSE (talk) 21:23, 30 December 2011 (UTC)
 * If I may add one more note -- this article was upheld against speedy deletion as the article concerns a teacher; however, I do not believe the subject of the article meets criteria to fit that category. From the one source provided in the article, it appears the Nassar was a one-time teacher who most likely does not fit any of the 9 criterion under notability policy. At best, Nassar could meet #5, but the source shows only one class, at one year. Just my two cents. Cheers, Lord Roem (talk) 21:49, 30 December 2011 (UTC)
 * Some publications which Nelida forwarded. I'm not sure why such an issue is being created out of this. Nelida is well known in the Boston area and teaches courses at Tufts. She just wants a Wikipedia page as a resource for people who might want to get in touch with her, or want to know more about her works. I read a comment about how this might be "publicity" of her firm; I think that claim is as baseless as it can be. Some of her work is through her design firm, and that is only mentioned in this article for people to know that works from Nassar Designs are also under her portfolio. Usman Masood
 * Here's why such an issue is being made: this isn't your friend Nelida's Facebook page or Linkedin listing. Since it's apparently penetrated your awareness that there is an apparent problem, have you bothered to look into why that might be?  Try WP:AUTO. EEng (talk) 23:51, 30 December 2011 (UTC)
 * "She just wants a Wikipedia page as a resource for people who might want to get in touch with her" means that the article exists to enable people to contact her: i.e. for promotion of her. That is contrary to Wikipedia's policy. JamesBWatson (talk) 10:16, 3 January 2012 (UTC)

PUBLICATIONS AIGA American Institute of Graphic Arts, 1999 Page 276: New Urbanity: The Entertainment District in Singapore (Fifty Books and Fifty Covers) Bone Show 2003, Best of New England Design Page 051: Hong Kong: Defining the Edge ART DIRECTORS CLUB OF BOSTON: The Design Show 1985 Page 445: Peabody Museum of Archeology and Ethnology Plant Migration

Communications Art Award of Excellence 2002 Page Hong Kong: Defining the Edge DAVID CARTER PUBLISHER American Corporate Identity, 18; David Carter, 2003 Page 113: Freed Arnold Architecture Letterhead Page 114: The Stubbins Associates, Letterhead Page 115: Arz Travel Letterhead Page 116: Nassar Design Letterhead Page 116: Lotus Shipping Company Letterhead Page 118: AAA Letterhead Page 119: Coastal Leasing Letterhead Page 119: Quest Partners Letterhead Page 166: Jeffry Pond Letterhead Page 204: Gresham Palace Building Wrapping HARPER COLLINS PUBLISHERS American Corporate Identity 19, 2004 Page 99: Rocio Urrquijo Letterhead Page 117: Marcoz Letterhead Page 191: University of Utah Signage Page 211: Leers Weinzapfel Light and Measure Catalogue Page 225: The Stubbins Associates Hospitality Brochure HARPER COLLINS PUBLISHERS American Corporate Identity 20, 2005 Page 123: Ginsburg Hallowell Stationary Page 163: French Offsett Partners Stationary Page 169: TSA Nevada Stationary HARPER COLLINS PUBLISHERS American Corporate Identity 21, 2006 Page 253: NOK Foundation, Inc. Logo Page 202: Weidlinger Associates Capabilities Brochure HARPER DESIGN AND IMPRINT OF HARPER COLLINS PUBLISHERS Creativity 32, 2003 Page 238: Nassar Design Ribbon Holiday Card Page 298: Nassar Design Stationary Gold Medal HARPER DESIGN AND IMPRINT OF HARPER COLLINS PUBLISHERS Creativity 33 David Carter, 2004 Page 149: Mireille Honein Catalogue Page 207: The Stubbins Associates Award Series HARPER DESIGN AND IMPRINT OF HARPER COLLINS PUBLISHERS Creativity 34 David Carter, 2005 Page 177: Beirut City Center Book Jacket HARPER DESIGN AND IMPRINT OF HARPER COLLINS PUBLISHERS Creativity 35 David Carter, 2006 Page 65: Oh Ah World Day Design Poster Page 70: Unesco Literacy Poster Page 166: Japan Transfer Page 222: Act of Generosity Page 255: Nasar Holiday Card Star HARPER DESIGN AND IMPRINT OF HARPER COLLINS PUBLISHERS Creativity 36 David Carter, 2007 Page 164: Baalbeck International Festival Poster Page 214: Extending Modernism in the Monumental City HARPER DESIGN AND IMPRINT OF HARPER COLLINS PUBLISHERS Global Corporate Identity 2, 2005 Page 24: Lotus Shipping Company Logo Page 76: Fevzi gandur Denizcilik A.C Logo Page 115: AAA Atelier des Architectes Associés Stationary Page 200: Lotus Shipping Company Stationary Page 230: Nassar Design Stationary Page 239: Gresham Palace Page 304: Genoa: Making the Space of the City Booklet HARPER DESIGN AND IMPRINT OF HARPER COLLINS PUBLISHERS The Big Book of Business Cards, 2005 Page 268: Nassar Design, Marcoz antiques • decorations, Archives for historical Documentation, Westgate Biological Ltd., Page 269: Brave Heart Fund, NOK Foundation, Thomson French Matsumoto Page 270: Fevzi Gandur Denizcilik, The Stubbins Associates, N2 Consulting HARPER COLLINS PUBLISHERS The Book of Color, 2003 Page 15: Louise Wegmann Catalogue Page 338: Boston Public Library Mural HARPER DESIGN AND IMPRINT OF HARPER COLLINS PUBLISHERS The Little Book of Layouts, Good Design and Why They Work, 2003 Pages 177, 178, 179: Weidlinger Associates, Inc. Capabilities Brochure old HEARST BOOK INTERNATIONAL The Big Book of Logos, 1999 Page 72 #7: Coastal Leasing Logo Page 73 #14: Elizabeth Gibb Logo HARPER DESIGN AND IMPRINT OF HARPER COLLINS PUBLISHERS The Big Book New Design Ideas, 2003 Page 169: Harvard Pusey Library Page 249: Ginsburg Hallowell Stationary Page 283: Index GRAPHIC DESIGN: usa AMERICAN GRAPHIC DESIGN AWARDS 1998 Page 223: Projecting Beirut: Harvard Design School (Poster) AMERICAN GRAPHIC DESIGN AWARDS 1999 Page 91: Weidlinger Associates, Inc. (Announcements) Page 104: Singapore Entertainment (Book Covers) Page 150: AAA Stationary (Corporate Identity Program) Page 218: Cosentini (Packaging) AMERICAN GRAPHIC DESIGN AWARDS 2000 Page 87: Sea-Dar (Cards) Page 107: Norman Foster and Partners (Books) Page 170: Lotus Shipping Company (Letterhead Stationary Page 236: Nassar Design Millennium Card (Self-Promotion) AMERICAN GRAPHIC DESIGN AWARDS 2002 Page 84: Leers Weinzapfel Announcement 1st Page 139: Hong Kong Book (Editorial Book Design) Page 146: Louise Wegmann Catalogue (Editorial Design Publications) Page 164: Nassar Design Stationary (Identity Design) Page 165: Elizabeth Gibb (Identity Design) Page 165: Jeffry Pond (Identity Design) AMERICAN GRAPHIC DESIGN AWARDS 2004 Page 180: Theatre at the Pudding Page 225: Weidlinger Associates, Logo Page 301: Genoa Waterfront

AMERICAN GRAPHIC DESIGN AWARDS 2005 Page 80: Leers Weinzapfel Recent University Work Page 147: Japan Transfer Page 180: Freed Arnold Stationary) Page 0: Leers Weinzapfel Recent Courthouse Work Page 147: SOLIDERE Page 0: Nassar Design Holiday Card 2005 Page 252: AIGA: World Day of Design Page 270: Nassar Design: Generosity Circles the World AMERICAN GRAPHIC DESIGN AWARDS 2006 1. Nabil Nahas Opium and Candy 2. OBEO Design Logo 3. Washington Modernism 4. NOK Foundation Corporate ID 5. SE FOR INTERIORS Logo 6. Nassar Design Holiday Card GRAPHIS POSTER ANNUAL 2004 Page 20, 21: Genoa Waterfront Posters GRAPHIS LOGO DESIGN 6 2004 Page 140 Coastal Leasing PIE BOOKS, Japan 2005 Progressive Direct Mail Page 64: Nassar Design Greetings Card 2000 (millennium) Page 65: Nassar Design Greetings Card 2001 (fortune cookie) Page 72: Nassar Design Greetings Card 2005 (star) Page 74: Nassar Design Greetings Card (Weidlinger San Fransisco-Oakland Bridge) Page 80: Nassar Design Greetings Card 1995 (stellar) Page 89: Nassar Design Greetings Card 2002 (ribbon) Page 93: Nassar Design Greetings Card 1990 (seasons) Page 109: Nassar Design Greetings Card (Weidlinger China card) PRINT Print Regional Design Annual, 2001 Page 287: Ecce Homo Print Regional Design Annual, 2002 Page 288 (187): Louise Wegmann Catalogue Page 288 (187): Hong Kong Book Print Regional Design Annual, 2003 Page 288: Mireille Honeïn Catalogue Print Regional Design Annual, 2006 Page 257: Nabil Nahas Opium and Candy ROCKPORT – QUAYSIDE PUBLISHING

Fantastic Folders and Exceptional Envelopes Patricia Belyea and Jenny Sullivan, 2005 Pages 41: Leers Weinzapfel Folder Page 48: Nassar Folder Page 133: Nassar Design 2004 Holiday Card (feather) Page 149: Baalbeck Book Mark Page 150: Japan Transfer Envelope Letterhead and Logo Design 7, 2001 Sayles Graphic Design Page 83: Nassar Design Stationary Letterhead and Logo Design, 2003 Top Design Studio Page 19: Hybrid Letterhead Page 58: Leers Weinzapfel Letterhead Mastering Materials, Bindings, & Finishes Art of Creative Production by Catharine Fishel 2007 Page 56: Nabil Nahas Catalogue Page 143: Louise Wegmann Fundraising Brochure One-Color Graphics, The Power of Contrast, 2002 Chen Design Associates Page 18: Arnold Freed Architecture (Origins The Core Identity) Page 21: Jorge Silvetti Stationary Page 84: Harvard School of Government Card (Scion Collateral Offspring) Page 140: Nassar Design Millennium Card (Micro An Intimate Impression) Page 155: Hong Kong Book (the Third Dimension). 1000 Graphic Elements Details for Distinctive Design 2004 Wilson Harvey: London Page 69 # 0195: Louise Wegmann Fund-raising brochure Page 149 #0437: Weidlinger Associates, Inc 50th promotional package Page 187 #0573: Nassar Design Peace Ribbon 1000 Greetings Creative Correspondence Designed for all Occasions 2004 Peter King & Company Page 32: Nassar Design Peace Ribbon Page 41: Nassar Design Stationary Page 63: Hybrid Moving Card Page 73: Weidlinger Holiday Card (Structure) Page 76: Sea Dar Holiday Card Page 94: Nassar Design: The Edge of New Beginning Page 115: The Stubbins Associates Holiday Card Page 136: The Stubbins Associates Moving Announcement Page 175: Moustapha Khalidy Exhibition Announcement Page 193: Women in Practice: Landscape in Architecture Announcement Page 245: Contemporary European Landscape Design Announcement Page 260: Hart-Weidlinger Announcement Page 265: L’Habitation au Liban Postcard Page 270: Baalbeck Bookmark Page 276: Leers Weinzapfel College Awards Announcement 1000 Bags, Tags & Labels by Kiki Eldridge 2006 Page 171 entry 0602: Leers Weinzpfel Associates Label Page 251 entry 0859 TSA label Page 251 entry 0860 The Stubbins Associates, Inc. Label Page 259 entry 0889 Nassar Design Label Page 311 Index 1000 Retail Graphics by JGA 2006 Page 123 entry 0404: SE Merchandising Tag Page 203 entry 0690: The Chinese Porcelain Company Bag Page 268: entry 0911: Gresham Palace Construction Banner The Art of Promotion: Creating Distinction Through Innovative Production Techniques 2005 By Lisa L. Cyr Pages 176, 177: Genoa: Posters series The Art of Promotion: Creating Distinction Through Innovative Production Techniques 2003 Lisa L. Cyr Page 76-77: Weidlinger 50th promotional (Unique Construction, Folds, and Die-Cuts) Page 44-45: Hong Kong (Unconventional Surfaces and Printing Techniques) The Best of Brochure Design, 2008 Perry Chua Page 129: Louise Wegmann Brochure The Best of Brochure Design, 2005 Willoughby Design Group Page 42: Louise Wegmann Brochure The Best of Brochure Design 10, 2009 Perry Chua Page: Harvard Graduate School of Design The Best of Business Cards Design 5, 2002 Cheryl Dangel Cullen Page 122: Nassar Design Business card Vellum Page 144: Marcoz The Best of Business Cards Design 6, 2004 Blackcoffee Page 118: Nassar Design Page 130: N-2 Consulting Page 137: Thirty Things Page 165: Joumana Ghandour Page 201: Freed Arnold Architecture The Best of Business Cards Design 6, 2006 Loewy-London Page 156 #283: Nassar Design Business Card Page 162 #295: Rania Matar Photography The Best of Business Cards Design 8, 2008 Sibley Peteet Page 119 #3: Nassar Design Business Card The Little Book of Big Promotions, 2007 By Cheryl Dangel Cullen, Lisa L. Cyr and Lisa Hickey Page 44/45: Defining The Edge Hong Kong Book Page76/77: Weidlinger Origami

— Preceding unsigned comment added by Usman Masood (talk • contribs) 22:56, 30 December 2011 (UTC)


 * Delete It always amazes me when people who claim to sell their market sophistication to others blunder onto the scene here without making the slightest attempt  to learn the rules and culture, even after being warned they're making a faux pas.  Why do people insist on embarrassing themselves like this? EEng (talk) 23:45, 30 December 2011 (UTC)
 * Note: This debate has been included in the list of Visual arts-related deletion discussions.  • Gene93k (talk) 01:11, 31 December 2011 (UTC)
 * Note: This debate has been included in the list of Businesspeople-related deletion discussions.  • Gene93k (talk) 01:11, 31 December 2011 (UTC)
 * Note: This debate has been included in the list of Academics and educators-related deletion discussions.  • Gene93k (talk) 01:11, 31 December 2011 (UTC)


 * Delete per WP:BIO, WP:COI (most of the edits were made by User:Nelida Nassar) and WP:NOTFACEBOOK. Clarityfiend (talk) 01:33, 31 December 2011 (UTC)
 * Delete for lack of evidence of passing WP:PROF, WP:GNG, or any other notability standard. —David Eppstein (talk) 02:17, 1 January 2012 (UTC)
 * Delete per all of above. No establishment of significance in her field. 76.248.147.199 (talk) 03:11, 1 January 2012 (UTC)
 * Delete. Article is WP:PROMOTION. Agricola44 (talk) 16:14, 6 January 2012 (UTC).
 * The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the article's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this page.