Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 11



Category:Fashion journalism

 * The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more categories. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the category's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.


 * The result of the discussion was:  at Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 26. ℯ xplicit  00:20, 26 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Propose renaming Category:Fashion journalism to Category:Fashion criticism
 * Propose renaming Category:Fashion journalists to Category:Fashion critics
 * Propose renaming Category:American fashion journalists to Category:American fashion critics
 * Propose renaming Category:Australian fashion journalists to Category:Australian fashion critics
 * Propose renaming Category:British fashion journalists to Category:British fashion critics
 * Propose renaming Category:English fashion journalists to Category:English fashion critics
 * Propose renaming Category:French fashion journalists to Category:French fashion critics
 * Nominator's rationale: The category currently is inaccurate. Fashion publications and writers mainly feature bloggers or columnists. Calling many of the people in this category "journalists" is misleading because they mostly publish opinion pieces (such as style trends, fashion show analysis, etc.) which is inherently biased. None of these people exclusively write factual information as a typical journalist would. Category:Fashion journalists is very different from Category:Business and financial journalists or Category:Crime journalists. I propose renaming to Category:Fashion criticism, like the categories for writers on similar topics like music, theatre, and art. Woebegone (talk) 21:42, 11 August 2018 (UTC)


 * Oppose -- These are (or should be) about people writing for newspapers and magazines about fashion. As such they are entitled to be called journalists.  Peterkingiron (talk) 15:25, 13 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Music critics and film critics also write for newspapers and magazines, but they are called critics because they analyze music and film. Most of the people in those categories do not report on music, film, theatre, artworks, and other types of art, which is why those categories are not called journalists. Can you explain why fashion critics/journalists are different? Woebegone (talk) 02:20, 14 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Because the function of fashion magazines, columns, etc is to report on fashion not to criticise it. Peterkingiron (talk) 15:52, 18 August 2018 (UTC)


 * The above is preserved as an archive of the discussion. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the category's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.

Category:Farhangian University

 * The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more categories. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the category's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.


 * The result of the discussion was: delete (non-admin closure) . Marcocapelle (talk) 05:22, 19 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Propose deleting farhangian university


 * Nominator's rationale: Only one eponymous article Rathfelder (talk) 20:59, 11 August 2018 (UTC)


 * Delete per nominator....William, is the complaint department really on the roof? 12:36, 12 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Delete for Now No objection to recreating if we ever get up to 5 or so articles. RevelationDirect (talk) 03:52, 13 August 2018 (UTC)
 * I agree -- This appears to be an umbrella body for all the teacher training colleges in Iran. In principle, each of the 100 branches is probably entitled to an article, so that there is ample scope for this category, but the Iran universities tree is a rather undeveloped one.  Peterkingiron (talk) 15:29, 13 August 2018 (UTC)


 * The above is preserved as an archive of the discussion. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the category's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.

Category:Teachers colleges

 * The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more categories. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the category's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.


 * The result of the discussion was:  at Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 26. ℯ xplicit  00:20, 26 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Propose merging Category:Teachers colleges to Category:Education schools
 * Nominator's rationale: Two names for the same thing. Education schools is better populated. Rathfelder (talk) 20:48, 11 August 2018 (UTC)


 * Merge both to Category:Colleges of Education. This needs a headnote explaining that it is about Category:Teacher training colleges, another potential name: all schools provide education (or should do).  These are about teaching the teachers, which is slightly different.  In UK, most of the teacher training colleges were amalgamated into Polytechnics, which have since been rebranded as universities.  In parallel with this, most universities had a School of Education where graduates could do a fourth year to achieve a post-graduate certificate of education.  The American usage of calling tertiary colleges "schools" is misleading in British English.  Peterkingiron (talk) 15:38, 13 August 2018 (UTC)
 * I think Peterkingiron's proposal is too heavily influenced by British usage. Rathfelder (talk) 17:52, 15 August 2018 (UTC)
 * And Education Schools is too heavily influenced by American usage. If you do not like my suggestion, please find something  you consider more NPOV between British and American usage.  I have already offered Category:Teacher training colleges as an alternative.  Peterkingiron (talk) 16:11, 18 August 2018 (UTC)
 * We agree there should be a merger, buut I'd like a wider discussion as to the most appropriate name for the merged category.Rathfelder (talk) 20:53, 24 August 2018 (UTC)


 * The above is preserved as an archive of the discussion. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the category's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.

Category:Wikipedians who consider themselves participants in all wikiprojects

 * The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more categories. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the category's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.


 * The result of the discussion was:  at Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 26. ℯ xplicit  00:20, 26 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Propose renaming Category:Wikipedians who consider themselves participants in all wikiprojects to Category:Wikipedians who participate in all WikiProjects or Category:Wikipedians who reject WikiProject membership, or delete
 * Nominator's rationale: This is not truly a WikiProject participation category but rather a quasi-wiki-philosophy category based on the rejection of WikiProject membership. I propose, at a minimum, moving it to a name that is shorter (Category:Wikipedians who participate in all WikiProjects) or, better yet, more descriptive (Category:Wikipedians who reject WikiProject membership). However, unlike most wiki-philosophy user categories, there is no established wiki-philosophy for rejecting WikiProject membership, and so my first preference is to delete the category and simply let users express this opinion via the userbox, without generating an opinion-based category grouping. -- Black Falcon (talk) 17:37, 11 August 2018 (UTC)


 * Don't rename to ".... participate in all wikiprojects" (as that changes the meaning). Delete unless someone provides a reasonable explanation of how the category could be useful. DexDor(talk) 18:01, 11 August 2018 (UTC)
 * That's a good point, I've struck that portion of my proposal. -- Black Falcon (talk) 18:11, 11 August 2018 (UTC)
 * I would also expect that a userbox is sufficient and a category is not needed, but let's check this also out with User:SMcCandlish who created the category. Marcocapelle (talk) 19:48, 11 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Thanks, I usually ping the category creator in the nomination, but forgot to do so this time. -- Black Falcon (talk) 17:32, 14 August 2018 (UTC)
 * It is a rather recent wiki-philosophical/wiki-political, userbox-related category, like many others we have (in particular, it's a pro-WP:CONLEVEL, anti-WP:OWNership one, and serves the specific purpose of deflating "your view doesn't count since you're not a member of this project" bullshit). So, Keep.  No actual  rationale has been provided; the above is a combination of WP:IDONTKNOWIT / WP:IDONTLIKEIT stuff (don't understand what it is, not interested in it, ergo it must be bad).  There is also no particular reason that such an internal category must have a short name; it has nothing to do with readers and article categorization, and it's name was chosen very carefully (including use of the word "participants" vs. "members" in paticular, persuant to a CfD years ago that moved a bunch of then-extant "WikiProject Foo members" categories to use the word "participants", shortly after the community nuked WP:Esperanza on the basis that everything on WP is open to everyone and there are no no membership organizations, no special clubs, no walled-garden cliques. Neither of the suggested renames get the entire point across: "who participate in" isn't true, unless you literally go project by project and participate in every single one of them. "who reject WikiProject membership" is confusingly misleading (implying refusal to participate in them, to most people who read it), and missing half of the point: it's not just rejection of membership, but of the notion that prior involvement is a requirement or confers privilege.  There's an important difference between considering oneself a de facto participant in every project, vs. actively working in all of them, or refusing to work in any of them.  Finally, WP:CONCISE applies to articles and by extension to article titles; it isn't really an argument for excessive shortening of project categories, particularly when doing so results in ambiguity or loss of context.  "Concise" doesn't just means "short", but short while conveying the same message.  — SMcCandlish ☏ ¢ 😼  12:37, 12 August 2018 (UTC)
 * While I might put the userbox on my user page (agreeing with the philosophy), I can't imagine how it can be useful to know who else has this userbox on their user page. Marcocapelle (talk) 14:17, 12 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Thanks for providing that clarification, and I agree with most everything you stated. On the matter of the category's name, a shorter name is not a must but, all else being equal, is generally preferred. However, based on your explanation above (and assuming the category is kept), I am content with Category:Wikipedians who consider themselves participants in all WikiProjects (fixing capitalization) or perhaps the slightly shorter Category:Wikipedians who claim participation in all WikiProjects. On the matter of the deletion rationale, it is essentially that the category appears to serve no useful function, i.e. I understand the userbox but do not see the value added by a category that groups users who use the userbox. As DexDor stated above, what's unclear is "how the category [itself] could be useful", distinguishing the function of a category (to group related pages) from a userbox (to express a view/sentiment). -- Black Falcon (talk) 17:32, 14 August 2018 (UTC)


 * The above is preserved as an archive of the discussion. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the category's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.

Category:Songs written by Greeeen

 * The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more categories. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the category's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.


 * The result of the discussion was:  at Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 26. ℯ xplicit  00:20, 26 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Propose deleting songs written by greeeen


 * Nominator's rationale: We do not do songwriters by band name - which is the marketing term used to sell records. Members of a band can change, but the songwriting credits do not. Richhoncho (talk) 15:50, 11 August 2018 (UTC)
 * PS Here is a sample previous discussion which also refers to other discussions. Discussion here --Richhoncho (talk) 08:57, 12 August 2018 (UTC)


 * Should Category:Songs written by The Warren Brothers be likewise split, even though there is no single song written by just one of the two, nor has there ever been a membership change? Ten Pound Hammer • (What did I screw up now?) 03:34, 14 August 2018 (UTC)
 * . I always thought they were a songwriting duo, and as such, although I am not in favour of conjoined songwriters in any event, decided others might disagree with me. Happy to leave the Warren Bros to your more specialist knowledge.I do think Peach Pickers (and others) should be demerged for the very reasons you state. (Why should a songwriter have 2 entries in the same cat?). --Richhoncho (talk) 09:21, 14 August 2018 (UTC)


 * The above is preserved as an archive of the discussion. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the category's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.

Palestine

 * The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more categories. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the category's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.


 * The result of the discussion was: Rename. Timrollpickering 23:00, 19 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Propose renaming Category:2013 in the Palestinian territories to Category:2013 in the State of Palestine
 * Propose renaming Category:2013 disestablishments in the Palestinian territories to Category:2013 disestablishments in the State of Palestine
 * Propose renaming Category:2013 establishments in the Palestinian territories to Category:2013 establishments in the State of Palestine
 * Propose renaming Category:2014 in the Palestinian territories to Category:2014 in the State of Palestine
 * Propose renaming Category:2014 disestablishments in the Palestinian territories to Category:2014 disestablishments in the State of Palestine
 * Propose renaming Category:2015 in the Palestinian territories to Category:2015 in the State of Palestine
 * Propose renaming Category:2016 in the Palestinian territories to Category:2016 in the State of Palestine
 * Propose renaming Category:2016 establishments in the Palestinian territories to Category:2016 establishments in the State of Palestine
 * Propose renaming Category:2017 in the Palestinian territories to Category:2017 in the State of Palestine
 * Propose renaming Category:2018 in the Palestinian territories to Category:2018 in the State of Palestine
 * Nominator's rationale: rename, this is follow-up on this earlier discussion in which there was consensus to rename Palestinian territories categories to State of Palestine starting in 2013. Marcocapelle (talk) 08:38, 11 August 2018 (UTC)


 * Support Laurel Lodged (talk) 20:26, 12 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Support -- a logical follow up, but do not create any new parents. Pre-2013 Palestinian Territories categories and articles can be parented to State of Palestine categories, since it is the same place with the same boundaries; just a new name.  Peterkingiron (talk) 15:41, 13 August 2018 (UTC)
 * if no new parents are to be created then the parents Category:2010s in the Palestinian territories, Category:Years of the 21st century in the Palestinian territories etc should be added to this nomination and renamed to match the current name State of Palestine. This would be consistent with some precedents; however, I am not sure that it would recognise the sensitivities of this case. – Fayenatic  L ondon 07:20, 14 August 2018 (UTC)
 * on the contrary, where a polity changes name without a change of borders, precedent is that the parent "years in" category uses the current name of the polity, even though this is anachronistic. I think this applies the Democratic Republic of Congo/Zaire/Belgian Congo and Burkino Faso/Upper Volta.  Peterkingiron (talk) 16:07, 18 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Another example is that Category:17th century in the Dutch Republic has been parented to Category:Centuries in the Netherlands but this one is also parented to Category:Centuries in the Dutch Republic. Marcocapelle (talk) 09:00, 19 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Disagree, we cannot parent the State of Palestine (after 2013) with Palestinian territories (until 2012); if we are clear that those are separate phases of the Palestinian national project per UN and the Palestinians themselves, then we should be clear not to mix those up. As of other example, the State of Israel and the All-Palestine Protectorate were both created in 1948 out of Mandatory Palestine, but we have separately - category:1940s in Mandatory Palestine (until 1948) and new category:1940s in Israel and category:1940s in All-Palestine (Gaza) (1948 and after).GreyShark (dibra) 15:17, 17 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Support - rename per nom and create new parents Category:2010s establishments in the State of Palestine, Category:2010s in the State of Palestine and Category:Years of the 21st century in the State of Palestine.GreyShark (dibra) 15:14, 17 August 2018 (UTC)


 * The above is preserved as an archive of the discussion. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the category's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.

Implementation note: For the record, here are the diffs for my follow-up work on the parent categories. User:Spiderjerky and User:Place Clichy also helped. – Fayenatic  L ondon 11:44, 27 August 2018 (UTC)

Medieval politics

 * The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more categories. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the category's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.


 * The result of the discussion was: merge. <b style="color:#4B0082;">ℯ</b> xplicit  00:20, 26 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Propose merging Category:1000 in politics to Category:1000
 * Propose merging Category:1001 in politics to Category:1001
 * Propose merging Category:1002 in politics to Category:1002
 * Propose merging Category:1003 in politics to Category:1003


 * Propose merging Category:1004 in politics to Category:1004
 * Propose merging Category:1005 in politics to Category:1005
 * Propose merging Category:1006 in politics to Category:1006
 * Propose merging Category:1007 in politics to Category:1007
 * Propose merging Category:1008 in politics to Category:1008
 * Propose merging Category:1009 in politics to Category:1009
 * Propose merging Category:1010 in politics to Category:1010
 * Propose merging Category:1011 in politics to Category:1011
 * Propose merging Category:1012 in politics to Category:1012
 * Propose merging Category:1013 in politics to Category:1013
 * Propose merging Category:1014 in politics to Category:1014
 * Propose merging Category:1015 in politics to Category:1015
 * Propose merging Category:1016 in politics to Category:1016
 * Propose merging Category:1017 in politics to Category:1017
 * Propose merging Category:1018 in politics to Category:1018
 * Propose merging Category:1019 in politics to Category:1019
 * Propose merging Category:1020 in politics to Category:1020
 * Propose merging Category:1021 in politics to Category:1021
 * Propose merging Category:1022 in politics to Category:1022
 * Propose merging Category:1023 in politics to Category:1023
 * Propose merging Category:1024 in politics to Category:1024
 * Propose merging Category:1025 in politics to Category:1025
 * Propose merging Category:1026 in politics to Category:1026
 * Propose merging Category:1027 in politics to Category:1027
 * Propose merging Category:1028 in politics to Category:1028
 * Propose merging Category:1029 in politics to Category:1029
 * Propose merging Category:1030 in politics to Category:1030
 * Propose merging Category:1031 in politics to Category:1031
 * Propose merging Category:1032 in politics to Category:1032
 * Propose merging Category:1033 in politics to Category:1033
 * Propose merging Category:1034 in politics to Category:1034
 * Propose merging Category:1035 in politics to Category:1035
 * Propose merging Category:1036 in politics to Category:1036
 * Propose merging Category:1037 in politics to Category:1037
 * Propose merging Category:1038 in politics to Category:1038
 * Propose merging Category:1039 in politics to Category:1039
 * Propose merging Category:1040 in politics to Category:1040
 * Propose merging Category:1041 in politics to Category:1041
 * Propose merging Category:1042 in politics to Category:1042
 * Propose merging Category:1043 in politics to Category:1043
 * Propose merging Category:1044 in politics to Category:1044
 * Propose merging Category:1045 in politics to Category:1045
 * Propose merging Category:1046 in politics to Category:1046
 * Propose merging Category:1047 in politics to Category:1047
 * Propose merging Category:1048 in politics to Category:1048
 * Propose merging Category:1049 in politics to Category:1049
 * Propose merging Category:1050 in politics to Category:1050
 * Propose merging Category:1051 in politics to Category:1051
 * Propose merging Category:1052 in politics to Category:1052
 * Propose merging Category:1053 in politics to Category:1053
 * Propose merging Category:1054 in politics to Category:1054
 * Propose merging Category:1055 in politics to Category:1055
 * Propose merging Category:1056 in politics to Category:1056
 * Propose merging Category:1057 in politics to Category:1057
 * Propose merging Category:1058 in politics to Category:1058
 * Propose merging Category:1059 in politics to Category:1059
 * Propose merging Category:1060 in politics to Category:1060
 * Propose merging Category:1061 in politics to Category:1061
 * Propose merging Category:1062 in politics to Category:1062
 * Propose merging Category:1063 in politics to Category:1063
 * Propose merging Category:1064 in politics to Category:1064
 * Propose merging Category:1065 in politics to Category:1065
 * Propose merging Category:1066 in politics to Category:1066
 * Propose merging Category:1067 in politics to Category:1067
 * Propose merging Category:1068 in politics to Category:1068
 * Propose merging Category:1069 in politics to Category:1069
 * Propose merging Category:1070 in politics to Category:1070
 * Propose merging Category:1071 in politics to Category:1071
 * Propose merging Category:1072 in politics to Category:1072
 * Propose merging Category:1073 in politics to Category:1073
 * Propose merging Category:1074 in politics to Category:1074
 * Propose merging Category:1075 in politics to Category:1075
 * Propose merging Category:1076 in politics to Category:1076
 * Propose merging Category:1077 in politics to Category:1077
 * Propose merging Category:1078 in politics to Category:1078
 * Propose merging Category:1079 in politics to Category:1079
 * Propose merging Category:1080 in politics to Category:1080
 * Propose merging Category:1081 in politics to Category:1081
 * Propose merging Category:1082 in politics to Category:1082
 * Propose merging Category:1083 in politics to Category:1083
 * Propose merging Category:1084 in politics to Category:1084
 * Propose merging Category:1085 in politics to Category:1085
 * Propose merging Category:1086 in politics to Category:1086
 * Propose merging Category:1087 in politics to Category:1087
 * Propose merging Category:1088 in politics to Category:1088
 * Propose merging Category:1089 in politics to Category:1089
 * Propose merging Category:1090 in politics to Category:1090
 * Propose merging Category:1091 in politics to Category:1091
 * Propose merging Category:1092 in politics to Category:1092
 * Propose merging Category:1093 in politics to Category:1093
 * Propose merging Category:1094 in politics to Category:1094
 * Propose merging Category:1095 in politics to Category:1095
 * Propose merging Category:1096 in politics to Category:1096
 * Propose merging Category:1097 in politics to Category:1097
 * Propose merging Category:1098 in politics to Category:1098
 * Propose merging Category:1099 in politics to Category:1099
 * Propose merging Category:1100 in politics to Category:1100
 * Propose merging Category:1101 in politics to Category:1101
 * Propose merging Category:1102 in politics to Category:1102
 * Propose merging Category:1103 in politics to Category:1103
 * Propose merging Category:1104 in politics to Category:1104
 * Propose merging Category:1105 in politics to Category:1105
 * Propose merging Category:1106 in politics to Category:1106
 * Propose merging Category:1107 in politics to Category:1107
 * Propose merging Category:1108 in politics to Category:1108
 * Propose merging Category:1109 in politics to Category:1109
 * Propose merging Category:1110 in politics to Category:1110
 * Propose merging Category:1111 in politics to Category:1111
 * Propose merging Category:1112 in politics to Category:1112
 * Propose merging Category:1113 in politics to Category:1113
 * Propose merging Category:1114 in politics to Category:1114
 * Propose merging Category:1115 in politics to Category:1115
 * Propose merging Category:1116 in politics to Category:1116
 * Propose merging Category:1117 in politics to Category:1117
 * Propose merging Category:1118 in politics to Category:1118
 * Propose merging Category:1119 in politics to Category:1119
 * Propose merging Category:1120 in politics to Category:1120
 * Propose merging Category:1121 in politics to Category:1121
 * Propose merging Category:1122 in politics to Category:1122
 * Propose merging Category:1123 in politics to Category:1123
 * Propose merging Category:1124 in politics to Category:1124
 * Propose merging Category:1125 in politics to Category:1125
 * Propose merging Category:1126 in politics to Category:1126
 * Propose merging Category:1127 in politics to Category:1127
 * Propose merging Category:1128 in politics to Category:1128
 * Propose merging Category:1129 in politics to Category:1129
 * Propose merging Category:1130 in politics to Category:1130
 * Propose merging Category:1131 in politics to Category:1131
 * Propose merging Category:1132 in politics to Category:1132
 * Propose merging Category:1133 in politics to Category:1133
 * Propose merging Category:1134 in politics to Category:1134
 * Propose merging Category:1135 in politics to Category:1135
 * Propose merging Category:1136 in politics to Category:1136
 * Propose merging Category:1137 in politics to Category:1137
 * Propose merging Category:1138 in politics to Category:1138
 * Propose merging Category:1139 in politics to Category:1139
 * Propose merging Category:1140 in politics to Category:1140
 * Propose merging Category:1141 in politics to Category:1141
 * Propose merging Category:1142 in politics to Category:1142
 * Propose merging Category:1143 in politics to Category:1143
 * Propose merging Category:1144 in politics to Category:1144
 * Propose merging Category:1145 in politics to Category:1145
 * Propose merging Category:1146 in politics to Category:1146
 * Propose merging Category:1147 in politics to Category:1147
 * Propose merging Category:1148 in politics to Category:1148
 * Propose merging Category:1149 in politics to Category:1149
 * Propose merging Category:1150 in politics to Category:1150
 * Propose merging Category:1151 in politics to Category:1151
 * Propose merging Category:1152 in politics to Category:1152
 * Propose merging Category:1153 in politics to Category:1153
 * Propose merging Category:1154 in politics to Category:1154
 * Propose merging Category:1155 in politics to Category:1155
 * Propose merging Category:1156 in politics to Category:1156
 * Propose merging Category:1157 in politics to Category:1157
 * Propose merging Category:1158 in politics to Category:1158
 * Propose merging Category:1159 in politics to Category:1159
 * Propose merging Category:1160 in politics to Category:1160
 * Propose merging Category:1161 in politics to Category:1161
 * Propose merging Category:1162 in politics to Category:1162
 * Propose merging Category:1163 in politics to Category:1163
 * Propose merging Category:1164 in politics to Category:1164
 * Propose merging Category:1165 in politics to Category:1165
 * Propose merging Category:1166 in politics to Category:1166
 * Propose merging Category:1167 in politics to Category:1167
 * Propose merging Category:1168 in politics to Category:1168
 * Propose merging Category:1169 in politics to Category:1169
 * Propose merging Category:1170 in politics to Category:1170
 * Propose merging Category:1171 in politics to Category:1171
 * Propose merging Category:1172 in politics to Category:1172
 * Propose merging Category:1173 in politics to Category:1173
 * Propose merging Category:1174 in politics to Category:1174
 * Propose merging Category:1175 in politics to Category:1175
 * Propose merging Category:1176 in politics to Category:1176
 * Propose merging Category:1177 in politics to Category:1177
 * Propose merging Category:1178 in politics to Category:1178
 * Propose merging Category:1179 in politics to Category:1179
 * Propose merging Category:1180 in politics to Category:1180
 * Propose merging Category:1181 in politics to Category:1181
 * Propose merging Category:1182 in politics to Category:1182
 * Propose merging Category:1183 in politics to Category:1183
 * Propose merging Category:1184 in politics to Category:1184
 * Propose merging Category:1185 in politics to Category:1185
 * Propose merging Category:1186 in politics to Category:1186
 * Propose merging Category:1187 in politics to Category:1187
 * Propose merging Category:1188 in politics to Category:1188
 * Propose merging Category:1189 in politics to Category:1189
 * Propose merging Category:1190 in politics to Category:1190
 * Propose merging Category:1191 in politics to Category:1191
 * Propose merging Category:1192 in politics to Category:1192
 * Propose merging Category:1193 in politics to Category:1193
 * Propose merging Category:1194 in politics to Category:1194
 * Propose merging Category:1195 in politics to Category:1195
 * Propose merging Category:1196 in politics to Category:1196
 * Propose merging Category:1197 in politics to Category:1197
 * Propose merging Category:1198 in politics to Category:1198
 * Propose merging Category:1199 in politics to Category:1199
 * Propose merging Category:1200 in politics to Category:1200
 * Propose merging Category:1201 in politics to Category:1201
 * Propose merging Category:1202 in politics to Category:1202
 * Propose merging Category:1203 in politics to Category:1203
 * Propose merging Category:1204 in politics to Category:1204
 * Propose merging Category:1205 in politics to Category:1205
 * Propose merging Category:1206 in politics to Category:1206
 * Propose merging Category:1207 in politics to Category:1207
 * Propose merging Category:1208 in politics to Category:1208
 * Propose merging Category:1209 in politics to Category:1209
 * Propose merging Category:1210 in politics to Category:1210
 * Propose merging Category:1211 in politics to Category:1211
 * Propose merging Category:1212 in politics to Category:1212
 * Propose merging Category:1213 in politics to Category:1213
 * Propose merging Category:1214 in politics to Category:1214
 * Propose merging Category:1215 in politics to Category:1215
 * Propose merging Category:1216 in politics to Category:1216
 * Propose merging Category:1217 in politics to Category:1217
 * Propose merging Category:1218 in politics to Category:1218
 * Propose merging Category:1219 in politics to Category:1219
 * Propose merging Category:1220 in politics to Category:1220
 * Propose merging Category:1221 in politics to Category:1221
 * Propose merging Category:1222 in politics to Category:1222
 * Propose merging Category:1223 in politics to Category:1223
 * Propose merging Category:1224 in politics to Category:1224
 * Propose merging Category:1225 in politics to Category:1225
 * Propose merging Category:1226 in politics to Category:1226
 * Propose merging Category:1227 in politics to Category:1227
 * Propose merging Category:1228 in politics to Category:1228
 * Propose merging Category:1229 in politics to Category:1229
 * Propose merging Category:1230 in politics to Category:1230
 * Propose merging Category:1231 in politics to Category:1231
 * Propose merging Category:1232 in politics to Category:1232
 * Propose merging Category:1233 in politics to Category:1233
 * Propose merging Category:1234 in politics to Category:1234
 * Propose merging Category:1235 in politics to Category:1235
 * Propose merging Category:1236 in politics to Category:1236
 * Propose merging Category:1237 in politics to Category:1237
 * Propose merging Category:1238 in politics to Category:1238
 * Propose merging Category:1239 in politics to Category:1239
 * Propose merging Category:1240 in politics to Category:1240
 * Propose merging Category:1241 in politics to Category:1241
 * Propose merging Category:1242 in politics to Category:1242
 * Propose merging Category:1243 in politics to Category:1243
 * Propose merging Category:1244 in politics to Category:1244
 * Propose merging Category:1245 in politics to Category:1245
 * Propose merging Category:1246 in politics to Category:1246
 * Propose merging Category:1247 in politics to Category:1247
 * Propose merging Category:1248 in politics to Category:1248
 * Propose merging Category:1249 in politics to Category:1249
 * Propose merging Category:1250 in politics to Category:1250
 * Propose merging Category:1251 in politics to Category:1251
 * Propose merging Category:1252 in politics to Category:1252
 * Propose merging Category:1253 in politics to Category:1253
 * Propose merging Category:1254 in politics to Category:1254
 * Propose merging Category:1255 in politics to Category:1255
 * Propose merging Category:1256 in politics to Category:1256
 * Propose merging Category:1257 in politics to Category:1257
 * Propose merging Category:1258 in politics to Category:1258
 * Propose merging Category:1259 in politics to Category:1259
 * Propose merging Category:1260 in politics to Category:1260
 * Propose merging Category:1261 in politics to Category:1261
 * Propose merging Category:1262 in politics to Category:1262
 * Propose merging Category:1263 in politics to Category:1263
 * Propose merging Category:1264 in politics to Category:1264
 * Propose merging Category:1265 in politics to Category:1265
 * Propose merging Category:1266 in politics to Category:1266
 * Propose merging Category:1267 in politics to Category:1267
 * Propose merging Category:1268 in politics to Category:1268
 * Propose merging Category:1269 in politics to Category:1269
 * Propose merging Category:1270 in politics to Category:1270
 * Propose merging Category:1271 in politics to Category:1271
 * Propose merging Category:1272 in politics to Category:1272
 * Propose merging Category:1273 in politics to Category:1273
 * Propose merging Category:1274 in politics to Category:1274
 * Propose merging Category:1275 in politics to Category:1275
 * Propose merging Category:1276 in politics to Category:1276
 * Propose merging Category:1277 in politics to Category:1277
 * Propose merging Category:1278 in politics to Category:1278
 * Propose merging Category:1279 in politics to Category:1279
 * Propose merging Category:1280 in politics to Category:1280
 * Propose merging Category:1281 in politics to Category:1281
 * Propose merging Category:1282 in politics to Category:1282
 * Propose merging Category:1283 in politics to Category:1283
 * Propose merging Category:1284 in politics to Category:1284
 * Propose merging Category:1285 in politics to Category:1285
 * Propose merging Category:1286 in politics to Category:1286
 * Propose merging Category:1287 in politics to Category:1287
 * Propose merging Category:1288 in politics to Category:1288
 * Propose merging Category:1289 in politics to Category:1289
 * Propose merging Category:1290 in politics to Category:1290
 * Propose merging Category:1291 in politics to Category:1291
 * Propose merging Category:1292 in politics to Category:1292
 * Propose merging Category:1293 in politics to Category:1293
 * Propose merging Category:1294 in politics to Category:1294
 * Propose merging Category:1295 in politics to Category:1295
 * Propose merging Category:1296 in politics to Category:1296
 * Propose merging Category:1297 in politics to Category:1297
 * Propose merging Category:1298 in politics to Category:1298
 * Propose merging Category:1299 in politics to Category:1299
 * Propose merging Category:1300 in politics to Category:1300
 * Propose merging Category:1301 in politics to Category:1301
 * Propose merging Category:1302 in politics to Category:1302
 * Propose merging Category:1303 in politics to Category:1303
 * Propose merging Category:1304 in politics to Category:1304
 * Propose merging Category:1305 in politics to Category:1305
 * Propose merging Category:1306 in politics to Category:1306
 * Propose merging Category:1307 in politics to Category:1307
 * Propose merging Category:1308 in politics to Category:1308
 * Propose merging Category:1309 in politics to Category:1309
 * Propose merging Category:1310 in politics to Category:1310
 * Propose merging Category:1311 in politics to Category:1311
 * Propose merging Category:1312 in politics to Category:1312
 * Propose merging Category:1313 in politics to Category:1313
 * Propose merging Category:1314 in politics to Category:1314
 * Propose merging Category:1315 in politics to Category:1315
 * Propose merging Category:1316 in politics to Category:1316
 * Propose merging Category:1317 in politics to Category:1317
 * Propose merging Category:1318 in politics to Category:1318
 * Propose merging Category:1319 in politics to Category:1319
 * Propose merging Category:1320 in politics to Category:1320
 * Propose merging Category:1321 in politics to Category:1321
 * Propose merging Category:1322 in politics to Category:1322
 * Propose merging Category:1323 in politics to Category:1323
 * Propose merging Category:1324 in politics to Category:1324
 * Propose merging Category:1325 in politics to Category:1325
 * Propose merging Category:1326 in politics to Category:1326
 * Propose merging Category:1327 in politics to Category:1327
 * Propose merging Category:1328 in politics to Category:1328
 * Propose merging Category:1329 in politics to Category:1329
 * Propose merging Category:1330 in politics to Category:1330
 * Propose merging Category:1331 in politics to Category:1331
 * Propose merging Category:1332 in politics to Category:1332
 * Propose merging Category:1333 in politics to Category:1333
 * Propose merging Category:1334 in politics to Category:1334
 * Propose merging Category:1335 in politics to Category:1335
 * Propose merging Category:1336 in politics to Category:1336
 * Propose merging Category:1337 in politics to Category:1337
 * Propose merging Category:1338 in politics to Category:1338
 * Propose merging Category:1339 in politics to Category:1339
 * Propose merging Category:1340 in politics to Category:1340
 * Propose merging Category:1341 in politics to Category:1341
 * Propose merging Category:1342 in politics to Category:1342
 * Propose merging Category:1343 in politics to Category:1343
 * Propose merging Category:1344 in politics to Category:1344
 * Propose merging Category:1345 in politics to Category:1345
 * Propose merging Category:1346 in politics to Category:1346
 * Propose merging Category:1347 in politics to Category:1347
 * Propose merging Category:1348 in politics to Category:1348
 * Propose merging Category:1349 in politics to Category:1349
 * Propose merging Category:1350 in politics to Category:1350
 * Propose merging Category:1351 in politics to Category:1351
 * Propose merging Category:1352 in politics to Category:1352
 * Propose merging Category:1353 in politics to Category:1353
 * Propose merging Category:1354 in politics to Category:1354
 * Propose merging Category:1355 in politics to Category:1355
 * Propose merging Category:1356 in politics to Category:1356
 * Propose merging Category:1357 in politics to Category:1357
 * Propose merging Category:1358 in politics to Category:1358
 * Propose merging Category:1359 in politics to Category:1359
 * Propose merging Category:1360 in politics to Category:1360
 * Propose merging Category:1361 in politics to Category:1361
 * Propose merging Category:1362 in politics to Category:1362
 * Propose merging Category:1363 in politics to Category:1363
 * Propose merging Category:1364 in politics to Category:1364
 * Propose merging Category:1365 in politics to Category:1365
 * Propose merging Category:1366 in politics to Category:1366
 * Propose merging Category:1367 in politics to Category:1367
 * Propose merging Category:1368 in politics to Category:1368
 * Propose merging Category:1369 in politics to Category:1369
 * Propose merging Category:1370 in politics to Category:1370
 * Propose merging Category:1371 in politics to Category:1371
 * Propose merging Category:1372 in politics to Category:1372
 * Propose merging Category:1373 in politics to Category:1373
 * Propose merging Category:1374 in politics to Category:1374
 * Propose merging Category:1375 in politics to Category:1375
 * Propose merging Category:1376 in politics to Category:1376
 * Propose merging Category:1377 in politics to Category:1377
 * Propose merging Category:1378 in politics to Category:1378
 * Propose merging Category:1379 in politics to Category:1379
 * Propose merging Category:1380 in politics to Category:1380
 * Propose merging Category:1381 in politics to Category:1381
 * Propose merging Category:1382 in politics to Category:1382
 * Propose merging Category:1383 in politics to Category:1383
 * Propose merging Category:1384 in politics to Category:1384
 * Propose merging Category:1385 in politics to Category:1385
 * Propose merging Category:1386 in politics to Category:1386
 * Propose merging Category:1387 in politics to Category:1387
 * Propose merging Category:1388 in politics to Category:1388
 * Propose merging Category:1389 in politics to Category:1389
 * Propose merging Category:1390 in politics to Category:1390
 * Propose merging Category:1391 in politics to Category:1391
 * Propose merging Category:1392 in politics to Category:1392
 * Propose merging Category:1393 in politics to Category:1393
 * Propose merging Category:1394 in politics to Category:1394
 * Propose merging Category:1395 in politics to Category:1395
 * Propose merging Category:1396 in politics to Category:1396
 * Propose merging Category:1397 in politics to Category:1397
 * Propose merging Category:1398 in politics to Category:1398
 * Propose merging Category:1399 in politics to Category:1399
 * Propose merging Category:1400 in politics to Category:1400
 * Propose merging Category:1401 in politics to Category:1401
 * Propose merging Category:1402 in politics to Category:1402
 * Propose merging Category:1403 in politics to Category:1403
 * Propose merging Category:1404 in politics to Category:1404
 * Propose merging Category:1405 in politics to Category:1405
 * Propose merging Category:1406 in politics to Category:1406
 * Propose merging Category:1407 in politics to Category:1407
 * Propose merging Category:1408 in politics to Category:1408
 * Propose merging Category:1409 in politics to Category:1409
 * Propose merging Category:1410 in politics to Category:1410
 * Propose merging Category:1411 in politics to Category:1411
 * Propose merging Category:1412 in politics to Category:1412
 * Propose merging Category:1413 in politics to Category:1413
 * Propose merging Category:1414 in politics to Category:1414
 * Propose merging Category:1415 in politics to Category:1415
 * Propose merging Category:1416 in politics to Category:1416
 * Propose merging Category:1417 in politics to Category:1417
 * Propose merging Category:1418 in politics to Category:1418
 * Propose merging Category:1419 in politics to Category:1419
 * Propose merging Category:1420 in politics to Category:1420
 * Propose merging Category:1421 in politics to Category:1421
 * Propose merging Category:1422 in politics to Category:1422
 * Propose merging Category:1423 in politics to Category:1423
 * Propose merging Category:1424 in politics to Category:1424
 * Propose merging Category:1425 in politics to Category:1425
 * Propose merging Category:1426 in politics to Category:1426
 * Propose merging Category:1427 in politics to Category:1427
 * Propose merging Category:1428 in politics to Category:1428
 * Propose merging Category:1429 in politics to Category:1429
 * Propose merging Category:1430 in politics to Category:1430
 * Propose merging Category:1431 in politics to Category:1431
 * Propose merging Category:1432 in politics to Category:1432
 * Propose merging Category:1433 in politics to Category:1433
 * Propose merging Category:1434 in politics to Category:1434
 * Propose merging Category:1435 in politics to Category:1435
 * Propose merging Category:1436 in politics to Category:1436
 * Propose merging Category:1437 in politics to Category:1437
 * Propose merging Category:1438 in politics to Category:1438
 * Propose merging Category:1439 in politics to Category:1439
 * Propose merging Category:1440 in politics to Category:1440
 * Propose merging Category:1441 in politics to Category:1441
 * Propose merging Category:1442 in politics to Category:1442
 * Propose merging Category:1443 in politics to Category:1443
 * Propose merging Category:1444 in politics to Category:1444
 * Propose merging Category:1445 in politics to Category:1445
 * Propose merging Category:1446 in politics to Category:1446
 * Propose merging Category:1447 in politics to Category:1447
 * Propose merging Category:1448 in politics to Category:1448
 * Propose merging Category:1449 in politics to Category:1449
 * Propose merging Category:1450 in politics to Category:1450
 * Propose merging Category:1451 in politics to Category:1451
 * Propose merging Category:1452 in politics to Category:1452
 * Propose merging Category:1453 in politics to Category:1453
 * Propose merging Category:1454 in politics to Category:1454
 * Propose merging Category:1455 in politics to Category:1455
 * Propose merging Category:1456 in politics to Category:1456
 * Propose merging Category:1457 in politics to Category:1457
 * Propose merging Category:1458 in politics to Category:1458
 * Propose merging Category:1459 in politics to Category:1459
 * Propose merging Category:1460 in politics to Category:1460
 * Propose merging Category:1461 in politics to Category:1461
 * Propose merging Category:1462 in politics to Category:1462
 * Propose merging Category:1463 in politics to Category:1463
 * Propose merging Category:1464 in politics to Category:1464
 * Propose merging Category:1465 in politics to Category:1465
 * Propose merging Category:1466 in politics to Category:1466
 * Propose merging Category:1467 in politics to Category:1467
 * Propose merging Category:1468 in politics to Category:1468
 * Propose merging Category:1469 in politics to Category:1469
 * Propose merging Category:1470 in politics to Category:1470
 * Propose merging Category:1471 in politics to Category:1471
 * Propose merging Category:1472 in politics to Category:1472
 * Propose merging Category:1473 in politics to Category:1473
 * Propose merging Category:1474 in politics to Category:1474
 * Propose merging Category:1475 in politics to Category:1475
 * Propose merging Category:1476 in politics to Category:1476
 * Propose merging Category:1477 in politics to Category:1477
 * Propose merging Category:1478 in politics to Category:1478
 * Propose merging Category:1479 in politics to Category:1479
 * Propose merging Category:1480 in politics to Category:1480
 * Propose merging Category:1481 in politics to Category:1481
 * Propose merging Category:1482 in politics to Category:1482
 * Propose merging Category:1483 in politics to Category:1483
 * Propose merging Category:1484 in politics to Category:1484
 * Propose merging Category:1485 in politics to Category:1485
 * Propose merging Category:1486 in politics to Category:1486
 * Propose merging Category:1487 in politics to Category:1487
 * Propose merging Category:1488 in politics to Category:1488
 * Propose merging Category:1489 in politics to Category:1489
 * Propose merging Category:1490 in politics to Category:1490
 * Propose merging Category:1491 in politics to Category:1491
 * Propose merging Category:1492 in politics to Category:1492
 * Propose merging Category:1493 in politics to Category:1493
 * Propose merging Category:1494 in politics to Category:1494
 * Propose merging Category:1495 in politics to Category:1495


 * Propose merging Category:1496 in politics to Category:1496
 * Propose merging Category:1497 in politics to Category:1497
 * Propose merging Category:1498 in politics to Category:1498
 * Propose merging Category:1499 in politics to Category:1499
 * Nominator's rationale: merge per WP:SMALLCAT, most of these categories consist of a single list article and two subcategories with (dis)establishments of states and territories. Note for implementation: those two (dis)establishments subcats should not be included in the merger, since they are already part of Category:YYYY establishments and Category:YYYY disestablishments. Marcocapelle (talk) 06:22, 11 August 2018 (UTC)


 * Strong support -- Most seem to have a list of rulers in YYYY and a category for states established in YYYY. My sampling did not produce any disestablishments, but I do not doubt they are there.  This "in politics" level is a wholly unnecessary one.  It may be this nom can be carried rather further towards the present.  Peterkingiron (talk) 15:47, 13 August 2018 (UTC)
 * The latter is an interesting point. I wonder how other editors think about this. Marcocapelle (talk) 21:09, 13 August 2018 (UTC)


 * Support early years are much easier to navigate - much fewer sub cats; thus this extra layer impedes rather than helps the navigation. Carlossuarez46 (talk) 18:09, 13 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Keep part of a large established tree of politics by year Tim! (talk) 08:17, 19 August 2018 (UTC)
 * The question is where to start the tree. The 16th century is a much better start than the 11th century, for example because in the 16th century the English parliament begins to play an increasingly important role. Marcocapelle (talk) 09:11, 19 August 2018 (UTC)


 * The above is preserved as an archive of the discussion. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the category's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.

Category:Jewish mathematicians who died in the Holocaust
<div class="boilerplate cfd vfd xfd-closed" style="background:#bff9fc; margin:0 auto; padding:0 10px 0 10px; border:1px solid #AAAAAA;">
 * The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more categories. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the category's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.


 * The result of the discussion was:  at Categories for discussion/Log/2018 August 26. <b style="color:#4B0082;">ℯ</b> xplicit  00:20, 26 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Propose deleting jewish mathematicians who died in the holocaust


 * Nominator's rationale: Having both Category:Mathematicians who died in the Holocaust and Category:Jewish mathematicians who died in the Holocaust seems redundant, seeing as nearly all members off the former would also be in the latter. Kyuko (talk) 01:45, 11 August 2018 (UTC)


 * Question why do we subcategorize people who died in the Holocaust by occupation at all? It seems quite unrelated. Marcocapelle (talk) 06:27, 11 August 2018 (UTC)
 * A fair question. That hierarchy is currently quite well developed, see Category:People who died in the Holocaust by occupation. For that matter, Category:Jewish people who died in the Holocaust by occupation has several sub-categories, so why is this one singled out for deletion? – Fayenatic  L ondon 20:50, 11 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Very true. The issue has been discussed before, in 2011 where consensus was lacking (also) because of an incomplete nomination. Marcocapelle (talk) 12:02, 12 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Note: all the current member pages are currently also in Category:Mathematicians who died in the Holocaust and in one of the sub-cats of Category:Jewish people who died in the Holocaust by nationality, so if there is consensus to delete this then there will be no need to merge it. – Fayenatic  L ondon 20:55, 11 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Keep but I would prefer to see it as a child (not grandchild) of Category:Jewish people who died in the Holocaust by occupation as Mathematics is sibling subject to science, not a science to which scientific methods (of experiment, etc) are applicable. Having 9 articles, it is big enough to be kept.  Peterkingiron (talk) 16:47, 13 August 2018 (UTC)
 * Comment is this an overlap that's necessary (indeed, the query applies to all the occupations). As I understand the Holocaust, the Jewish victims were not generally selected/targeted by occupation. Carlossuarez46 (talk) 18:12, 13 August 2018 (UTC)


 * The above is preserved as an archive of the discussion. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the category's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.