Wikipedia:Deletion review/Userbox debates/Archived

Deletion reviews for userboxes should take place at Deletion review now. -

This process is about userboxes, not about people. If you feel that an administrator is routinely deleting userboxes prematurely, or otherwise abusing their powers, please discuss the matter on the user's talk page, or at Wikipedia talk:Administrators. If you nominate a page here, be sure to make a note on the administrator's user talk page regarding your nomination. A template is available to make this easier:

Similarly, if you are a administrator and a page you deleted is subsequently undeleted, please don't take it as an attack.

Please take general discussion to the talk page.

Archived discussions
See /Archive, /Archive 2, /Archive 3
 * Template:User Church of Christ (keep deleted)
 * Template:User atheist (result undelete)
 * Template:User scientology (result kd)
 * Template:User liberal (result keep deleted, WP:SNOW, massive endorsement)
 * Template:User Hell, Template:User Ideal Dictator, and Template:User Elitist Consensus was to keep User Hell (which has already survived TfD), and undelete and TfD the others. 15:37, 25 May 2006 (UTC) Review
 * Template:User liberty (result kd, unanimous, WP:SNOW)
 * Template:User chav & Template:User notchav (result kd, unanimous, WP:SNOW)
 * User:CharonX/Userboxes/User christian restored by 27-36 majority, will be relisted at TfD in pre-edit war form. 17:41, 20 May 2006 (UTC) Review
 * Template:User hate (result kept deleted. WP:SNOW.  Only nominator for review wanted it undeleted).
 * Template:User Wikicheese-ologist (result kept deleted)
 * Template:User ProIsrael: (result keep deleted, WP:SNOW)
 * Template:User varied sex: (result kept deleted, closed as frivolous challenge)
 * Template:User Triceratops Accident (result kept deleted)
 * Template:User antiuserboxdeletion (result kept deleted)
 * Template:User Darwinist(result kept deleted)
 * User:UBX/Communist (result kept deleted)
 * Template:User No Marxism (result kept deleted)
 * Template:User infidel undeleted.
 * Template:User Sock Puppet and Template:User Puppet Master ... it's complicated discussion
 * Template:User against Saud (result almost unanimous keep deleted)
 * Template:User_Unamerican and others (result nomination delisted early; template kept deleted)
 * Template:User transhumanist and Template:User anti-transhumanist (result kept deleted)
 * Template:User boylover and Template:User girllover (result kept deleted).
 * WikiProject Userboxes/Alerts (result kept deleted)
 * Template:User admins ignoring policy (result kept deleted)
 * Template:User Unamerican and others (result kept deleted)
 * Template:User vomit (result kept deleted)
 * Template:User Objectivism / Template:User No Objectivism (result: both kept deleted)
 * Template:User_Thermostat_Bicker (Archive: undeleted and relisted on TfD)
 * Template:User marriage man-woman (result: kept deleted)
 * Template:User Same Sex Marriage (result: kept deleted)
 * Template:User independent Iraq (result: kept deleted)
 * Template:User antiparty (result: kept deleted)
 * Template:User review (result: kept deleted)
 * Template:User Copyright Nazi (result: kept deleted)
 * User:nathanrdotcom/Userboxes/ABF (result: undeleted)
 * Template: User evol-X (result: kept deleted)
 * Template: User feminist (result: undeleted)
 * Template:User userbox insurgent (result: nomination delisted early without explanation; template kept deleted)
 * Template:User userbox revolution (result: nomination delisted early without explanation; template kept deleted)
 * Template:User marriage man-woman (result: no majority to endorse deletion, no supermajority to overturn; I'm re-creating and taking it to TFD)
 * Template:User opposes ubx screwing (result: kept deleted as protected page)
 * Template:User USA Police State (result)
 * Template:User No Meat (result: recreated as redirect)
 * George W. Bush templates
 * Pseudo-templates Userbox:Anti ACLU, Userbox:Anti UN (result)