Wikipedia:Dispute resolution noticeboard/Third Perso-Turkic War

Third Perso-Turkic War
26 July 2013

Have you discussed this on a talk page?

Yes, I have discussed this issue on a talk page already.

Location of dispute Users involved Dispute overview

A person suddenly removes information that have been listed for a long time and added it to Turkic victory, i have showed him sources that they withdrew and did not conquer anything, but he keeps removing my sources. He also accuses me of nationalism.

Have you tried to resolve this previously?

I have, but it is impossible to resolve anything with this guy.

How do you think we can help?

We could use some opinions.

Opening comments by BöriShad
He using iranian sources for perso-turkic war. his sources totally nationalists. for example numbers of armies shows as 300.000 Turks vs 12.000 persians. 280.000 Turks killed in battle. and I said you must add impartial sources. also, I added 2 non-Turkish and non-iranian sources but he keep removing my sources. so, what can I do?

Have you discussed this on a talk page?

Yes, I have. also, told him on discassion page. "lets leave this page to other wikipedia users" but he didn't say ok, and kept remove my sources.

How do you think we can help?

I've already shared my sources and he shared his sources. my suggestion is; block both of us to access that page and leave that page to other users. I believe other users will be more objective than him.

Discussion
Please do not use this for discussing the dispute prior to a volunteer opening the thread for comments - continue discussing the issues on the article talk page if necessary.

I don't know what he is talking about, i never added those sources where it said 300,000 Turks, and the source that says that is not even Iranian, and it don't matter what nationality it is, it matters if it is reliable or not, something this guy has not learned about, he haven't even read the Wikipedia rules and accuses me of many things i don't have done. --HistoryofIran (talk) 16:42, 26 July 2013 (UTC)
 * see first and second perso-Turkic wars. you added them, didn't you? also, in russian page they show Turkic army number 40.000 in third perso-Turkic war. but your source says 120.000. why? because your kinsmen love to exaggerate enemies' numbers.BöriShad (talk) 17:22, 26 July 2013 (UTC)
 * "accuses me of many things i don't have done." if this is true, name it.

Stop changing the subject to third Turko-persian war, and there is actually nothing wrong with that, sources are sources, it don't matter what nationality, and don't try to create a ethnic fighting by insulting my ethnicity, stop acting like a kid. And i only reverted the edits in the other Turko-Persian wars because some Pan-Turk had removed it. --HistoryofIran (talk) 17:49, 26 July 2013 (UTC)
 * Pan-Turk? lol I'm not even nationalist. I support freedom for all people. but this isn't our subject. you run out of your lies and come to defamation? BöriShad (talk) 18:27, 26 July 2013 (UTC)