Wikipedia:Featured and good topic candidates/Battle of Masan/archive1

Battle of Masan

 * Contributor(s): Ed!

Good Topic nomination. A battle in the Korean War with three sub-battle articles contained therein. It's a self-contained narrative of a three-front engagement between UN and North Korean troops. --— Ed! (talk) 18:17, 25 July 2011 (UTC)


 * The article references two other battles. The Great Naktong Offensive (Start-Class) and the Battle of Inchon (C-Class). Why are these not included in the topic? Headbomb {talk / contribs / physics / books} 23:26, 7 August 2011 (UTC)
 * The topic features the battle around Masan, which took place in three adjacent axes; Battle Mountain, Haman and Nam River. Chronologically speaking Inchon took place after these battles and in a different area, and is generally considered to be the beginning of a different phase of the war. As for the Great Naktong Offensive, true it was an offensive of which two of the battles were a part, but the Pusan Perimeter was two months and comprised about 18 articles. I do plan on expanding this topic to include more eventually, but as for now, this just concerns what happened around Masan; those two articles aren't significant in that regard. — Ed! (talk) 02:12, 8 August 2011 (UTC)


 * Unfortunately I do think it is cherry picking not to include The Great Naktong Offensive (which even has its own sub-section in the main article). I suppose ditto with Inchon. ♫ Hurricanehink ( talk ) 14:39, 22 August 2011 (UTC)

This topic needs more input big time. Wizardman Operation Big Bear 03:43, 30 August 2011 (UTC)
 * Well for what it's worth, I tend to agree with Ed HurricaneHink. Headbomb {talk / contribs / physics / books} 05:32, 12 September 2011 (UTC)

Support - I agree with Ed's justification. -- Pres N  04:40, 15 September 2011 (UTC)


 * Closed with no consensus to promote. Too many users concerned about the other battles not being included despite above notes. Wizardman  Operation Big Bear 12:13, 20 September 2011 (UTC)