Wikipedia:Featured article candidates/Music of Athens, Georgia

Music of Athens, Georgia
Old peer review and old FAC. This is the second try, and a self-nom. Most of the objections last time were on style, and the article has been significantly copyedited (see diff since last nom). No major expansion on content, but a few tidbits here and there were added. I've also put some sound samples in and removed the poorly-licensed image. Tuf-Kat 21:14, 13 January 2006 (UTC)
 * Neutral. I like it, but it feels kinda short. Everyking 05:47, 14 January 2006 (UTC)


 * Comment - I'm inclined to Support. It's well written, structured and illustrated. It's concise but still seems to cover the major points sufficiently. Rossrs 00:36, 15 January 2006 (UTC) My only concern is the excessive number of red links which create the appearance of an article "under construction" rather than a "finished product". I think a featured article ideally should have zero redlinks.  I think these should either be "delinked" until there are articles, or stub articles should be created for them.   I won't object on that basis but I hope you'll look at it. Rossrs 05:57, 14 January 2006 (UTC)
 * I've delinked/removed a few, filled in a bunch with stubs (mostly). There's still a couple (14, specifically), but I think this helps (I will try to fill in the remainder in the next few days). Tuf-Kat 07:43, 14 January 2006 (UTC)
 * Yes I think it helps. It'll be good when there are no red links, but it's definitely improved it already. Rossrs
 * Support, well-written and thorough. Andrew Levine 18:24, 14 January 2006 (UTC)

Comment The opening section left me wondering..."Only two bands made this the Liverpool of the south? (REM and B52s)". I'd like to see this fleshed out more with more famous bands upfront. Rlevse 21:30, 14 January 2006 (UTC)
 * The lead does not claim or imply that two bands made Athens the Liverpool of the South. There are no other bands anywhere's near as famous as those two -- I guess Matthew Sweet comes closest, but he's from Nebraska anyway.  The source for "Liverpool of the south" only mentions REM in connection to that quote, and I think that mentioning any specific bands in the first paragraph is placing a lot of focus and should not be done lightly.  Every source (or at least most) used in the writing of this article mentions those two, so they should be in the first paragraph, but no one else is such a standard reference point. And there are five other bands mentioned in the second paragraph of the lead as well. Tuf-Kat 00:02, 15 January 2006 (UTC)
 * Hang on, y'all! Ok, bands "from Athens" (remember that the "Seattle bands" weren't actually from Seattle; a "scene" is a critical more than geographical term) include Indigo Girls, Guadalcanal Diary, as well as the B's and REM.  Additionally, for underground music, Pylon is very important (nationally very, very well known among the college rock folk of the 80s).  Another very famous band "from Athens" was Drivin' n' Cryin'.  Ummm, there were many more.  Ok, Mitch Easter's band...forgotten their name, but they were MTV stars in 81-82, were from Charlotte but "from Athens" in the scene terminology.  Compare to the grunge "scene," where, other than Nirvana, there is really only Soundgarden that everyone can remember.  The point being that local scenes generate big buzz, produce 4-5 nationally famous bands, and then, when the dust settles, have 2-3 long term national bands.  Geogre 14:54, 19 January 2006 (UTC)
 * Note that Pylon is already in the lead, and I'll replace the very obscure Side Effects with the Indigo Girls, who are much more well-known. I stand by the claim about "Liverpool of the south", which is an opinion cited appropriately and without putting specific examples in the author's mouth. Tuf-Kat 18:33, 19 January 2006 (UTC)
 * Comment. Support. Quite good, but I'm concerned about comprehensiveness.  Is there an opera house in the city?  A hip-hop scene?  A music school?  The article seems to be focused on the twentieth century and on popular music.  Jkelly 18:19, 18 January 2006 (UTC)
 * If there's an opera house, I can't find any evidence of it on google. The article has a paragraph on the University of Georgia's music school, and various other mentions of University-related music stuff.  The article also mentions Bubba Sparxx, the only notable rapper from the area (AFAIK), and I haven't found any evidence of a particuarly notable hip hop scene in the area.  I agree that the article is focused on modern popular music, but then that's the only reason this article exists, IMO -- the average 100,000 person American city probably doesn't need a "music of", but Athens' modern rock scene is exceptionally notable.  That doesn't mean some more info on music history and folk music wouldn't be nice, but I think what's there is adequate (though any folk music from Athens is part of the regional tradition, and thus would be more appropriate elsewhere).  Also, since the only book published on the subject AFAICT is on rock, and there's no evidence of any other resources, I don't think it's possible to expand significantly. Tuf-Kat 23:13, 18 January 2006 (UTC)
 * Further note that this article mentions a historical opera house, but this presumably no longer exists, and if it was all that notable, surely I'd be able to find at least a name somewhere on the web. Tuf-Kat 23:15, 18 January 2006 (UTC)
 * Well, there is the Morton Theater, but it was closed during the scene. When the scene was happening, there was very little urban music, and musicians used to say that the reason Athens happened was that there was nothing to do in the town.  You went to class, and then you went to parties.  At the parties, the artsy folks would get into camp and strange music, and the people in the town with money to pay bands didn't have the redneck bias against "weird" music, so the "New Wave" and "Punk" bands could play fraternities and get decent pay (which was not the case most places).  What else?  At the time, UGA wasn't an awfully, awfully difficult undergraduate institution compared to the brains of the people going there.  Nowadays, the school has upped its standards a great deal, but the point is that people had more brains and time than they could occupy, so they started bands, and art movements, and creative writing communes, etc.  This was helped along by certain professors in the Studio Art Department, as well (e.g. many early REM videos were directed by Prof. James Herbert, an art professor there who was a focal point for a lot of the musicians).  Geogre 14:59, 19 January 2006 (UTC)
 * Ah-ha! The Morton Theater is apparently the same as the "historical opera house in the Morton Building" I alluded to above. I hadn't been able to find the name, but since I now have, I've found this, which Ishould be able to use to expand the history section of this article a little later today (or maybe tomorrow). Tuf-Kat 18:33, 19 January 2006 (UTC)
 * Expanded a bit on this topic. Tuf-Kat 20:31, 19 January 2006 (UTC)
 * Looks good to me. I've changed my comment to support.  Jkelly 17:21, 24 January 2006 (UTC)


 * Support. Very nice job! *Exeunt* Ganymead | Dialogue? 20:07, 25 January 2006 (UTC)
 * How did this get through as a FA? What's next Decatur, Arkansas? The discussion here seems a bit skinny. Who is the person who makes these decisions???? Albatross2147 (talk) 04:05, 30 January 2009 (UTC)