Wikipedia:Featured article candidates/Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius/archive1

Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius
Created FAC from original nomination here.

About a famous short story by Jorge Luis Borges that makes an enormous number of references to non-fictional individuals, many not well known in the English-speaking world. I believe that this article is the first good English-language guide for the perplexed. I didn't write all of it, but at this point it is mostly my work. -- Jmabel 05:08, 27 Feb 2004 (UTC)
 * Lovely article (hence I'm moving this out of self-noms to uncontested). Jmabel, would you mind having a look at my copyedit?  In the spirit of being bold, I corrected what looked to me like obvious errors but given the subject matter I can't be entirely sure (especially inside quotes from the story). --Bth 10:08, 3 Mar 2004 (UTC)
 * I am not supporting or opposing this one yet. I think it has potential, but it needs a lot of copyedits. Kingturtle 04:50, 6 Mar 2004 (UTC)
 * Following some suggestions by Kingturtle, I've kept strengthening this. I'd appreciate a few more people weighing in, either to endorse as a Feature or to let me know how they'd like to see it improved. -- Jmabel 07:34, 14 Mar 2004 (UTC)
 * This article has gone through some substantial edits. The article is more clear (as clear as such a topic can be). I endorse it now. But it would be helpful for others to give it the once-over. Kingturtle 19:33, 14 Mar 2004 (UTC)
 * A lovely article indeed. When I compare it to still-unfeatured articles like Congo Free State, however, it falls short.  Could use better wikification, structure.  +sj+ 12:05, 2004 Mar 18 (UTC)
 * Reluctantly Object Support. I'd like to see a better organizing template (broken into historical background / context of author's other works / plot summary / analysis by others), rather than a combination of (historical bakground + analysis). However, there are precious few serious articles on fiction in WP right now, and this is a notable  exception.  Looking at other featured articles, I feel they should all set an example for other articles in the same genre -- having an elegant non-trivial format which helps highlight key pieces of information (useful for future authors of new articles of that type), treating some aspect of the subject, or a few of them, with special affection, &c. This article has excellent content, but is not a template model for others yet...  there is parenthetical information repeated in this article which might better be left to linked-to articles, and information from other writers' analyses of the work which could be extracted and paraphrased.  Despite the lengthy discussion of the book's publication process, there is a link to only one published version of the story.  There could be further and better-categorized links to external analyses of such an unusual work.   +sj+ 12:26, 2004 Mar 18 (UTC)
 * Replying to some of this in article's talk page. -- Jmabel 04:06, 22 Mar 2004 (UTC)
 * With +sj's change of view, I have moved this to Nominations without objections.
 * Support. Presents quite a bit of valuable context.  Smerdis of Tlön 03:26, 4 Apr 2004 (UTC)


 * Added to Literature category by Pcb21 09:13, 6 April 2004