Wikipedia:Featured picture candidates/USS Shaw explodes 2

USS Shaw explodes

 * Reason:Actually, this is a nomination for transferring the Featured Picture status from Image:USS Shaw Exploding.jpg (see nomination, promoted in May 2007) to Image:USS SHAW exploding Pearl Harbor Nara 80-G-16871 2.png. The PNG file seems to come independently from the JPEG (rather than having been converted), so is presumably of higher quality. In addition, the PNG does not have blemishes that the JPEG has.
 * Proposed caption:The destroyer USS Shaw explodes at her berth as a result of combat damage during the air raid at Pearl Harbor 7 December 1941.
 * Articles this image appears in:USS Shaw (DD-373), Attack on Pearl Harbor
 * Creator:United States Navy


 * Support as nominator Conscious 17:36, 24 September 2007 (UTC)
 * Comment I believe a better version of this image is already an FP. Debivort 18:18, 24 September 2007 (UTC)
 * This the same picture, equal resolution, but with the blemishes photo-shopped out, and in PNG format (converted or re-scanned, the blemishes are not from the original scan, but are a part of the photograph). I Oppose this one, as JPEG is the preferred format for pictures, and the blemishes come along with a picture that is almost 66 years old. Debate ensues... Puddyglum 20:23, 24 September 2007 (UTC)


 * Neutral; PNG is better than JPEG because it's lossless. However, I'm concerned if editing out the flaws of the original JPEG image and darkening the entire image in general is a good thing. I don't see much reason to edit a historical image. -- Altiris   Helios   Exeunt  09:19, 25 September 2007 (UTC)


 * Withdrawing, discussion already taking place at Featured picture candidates/delist/USS Shaw exploding. Conscious 09:18, 25 September 2007 (UTC)