Wikipedia:List of village pump proposals in 2004

This page summarizes and presents in chronological order all sections created at the page Village pump (proposals) in 2004, even if they are not actual proposals. Links are to the last version of the page before the section was archived or moved. The order of sections follows the date when they were created, not archived. The dates considered for how long the discussions lasted refer to the first post and last post on the thread.

Summary items are:


 * Name of the user who made the proposal.
 * The proposal
 * Discussion and result.
 * Duration of discussion.

Wikidebate

 * Wonderfool
 * "A wiki-based confrontation site."
 * No one made any comment.
 * November 5.

Associative Wiktionary [[Image:Symbol question.svg|20px]]

 * wikigs
 * "Add multilingual associations to every word entry of Wiktionary."
 * No discussion on the page, as the section was moved to Wiktionary on the same day it was created.
 * October 5.

I suggest...

 * Ilyanep
 * "Make a 'Questions' section of the village pump".
 * The proposal was unsuccesful because there was the Help Desk already.
 * September 23 - September 26.

Interlinking with Wiki Travel

 * Golbez
 * That pages about places be linked to Wiki Travel.
 * Result was "Go for it, I'm sure virtually everyone will see this as a plus."
 * September 23.

==Wikipedia:Requests for image manipulation --- Good or bad idea? ==
 * Neutrality
 * "A place to handle requests to modify images."
 * People liked the idea, but the page wasn't created.
 * September 15 - October 23.

Template:Notstub

 * Benc
 * A template to tag "articles in existence that are stub-length, never likely to be significantly expanded, but certainly worthy of inclusion."
 * Idea abandoned by the author "in favor of increased visibility for Stub categories".
 * September 15 - September 17.

Splitting up the village pump

 * Angela
 * Split the 200kb long village pump into five.
 * The proposal was successful.
 * September 14 - September 25.