Wikipedia:Mediation Cabal/Cases/2008-08-27 Banu Nadir


 * Note: Please limit posts to this page to brief statements about the nature of the dispute until a volunteer adopts the case. Keep ongoing discussions about the topic to the appropriate talk page(s), but feel free to provide links to the talk page(s) where discussion has happened (and may be ongoing) for the convenience of the informal mediator and other parties. This will help keep discussion from fragmenting out across more pages and make it easier for a volunteer to review the case. Thanks!

What's going on?

 * 1) Whether addition of "the Banu Nadir, along with the other Jews living in Khaybar, understood that Muhammad might attack them again" is justified per Wikipedia policies (i.e. does it violate WP:OR, WP:RS, and others)
 * 2) What the sources say about the involvement of Banu Nadir in the seige of Medina; and who participated.
 * 3) Other material found in only one of the following diffs (summarizing the dispute):

What would you like to change about that?
The issues have been discussed extensively on the talk page for months(see for example ). There is a consensus on the talk page that we should bring this case to mediation. We hope discussing it under the supervision of an expert editor of Wikipedia can help us move forward.