Wikipedia:Mediation Cabal/Cases/2009-08-17/Chamar

Where is the dispute?
I request mediation at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Chamar. I would provided numerous sources showing that Ramdasia are Sikh Chamars but this has been rejected by the other user who has not provided any meaningful responses.

I would like some one independent to review the discussions and provide independent view if Ramdasia are Sikh Chamars.

Also, I would like someone to see the state by state demographic information I have provided and say that they Agree or Disagree with it.

Who is involved?
Just a list of the users involved. For example:


 * User:bal537
 * User:ravinder121

What is the dispute?
I have been saying that Ramdasia are Sikh Chamars and have provided numerous sources to show this. The other user outright rejects this without providing any other information.

What would you like to change about this?
I would like some one independent to review the discussions and provide independent view if Ramdasia are Sikh Chamars. Whether the sources provided is enough to conclude that Ramdasia are Sikh Chamars.

Also, I would like someone to see the state by state demographic information I have provided and say that they Agree or Disagree with it.

How do you think we can help?
Look at the source information provided and whether there is enough information to conclude that Ramdasia are Sikh Chamars.

Also, whether you agree/disagree that the state by state demographic information is valid enough to post on the main article.

Mediator notes
Hello, my name is Vicenarian, and I'm a mediator here. First, I'd like to note that at mediation, we don't decide what/who is right or wrong. We help those in disagreement come up with a compromise solution. We don't pass judgment on content and have no authority to impose any solution. With this in mind, do you believe the mediation process will help at this time? Vicenarian (Said · Done) 21:14, 19 August 2009 (UTC)
 * I haven't received a response to these concerns. I am closing this case at this time. If the dispute continues and all parties agree to mediation, please feel free to refile. Thank you. Vicenarian  (Said · Done) 04:37, 25 August 2009 (UTC)