Wikipedia:Mediation Cabal/Cases/2010-01-30/Lucy Tuning

Where is the dispute?
Lucy Tuning, which has been scheduled for deletion.

Who is involved?
Just a list of the users involved. For example:

Charles Lucy - researcher, author of book, websites and articles on this subject.
 * Gwalla
 * Cazort
 * beefman

What is the dispute?
The entry for Lucy Tuning has been repeatedly vandalised, and a link added to book by Haluska (2003). Hyacinth (talk), which contains erroneous information on this subject. Original sources should include Music Teacher Magazine London 1988, and Concerning Such Mechanism ..... by John Harrison (1770), which have been misunderstood or misinterpreted in the publication "^ a b c Jan Haluska (2003). The Mathematical Theory of Tone Systems, p.157-58. ISBN 0824747143. Gives a few Lucy tunings. Also gives a few related Harrison comma meantone tunings, each of which contains a ratio." Someone has incorrectly attributed a 21-tone tuning to Charles Lucy, and repeatedly reposted it when it has been removed as erroneous.

What would you like to change about this?
Erroneous information should be removed.

How do you think we can help?
Consider whether the article should be rewritten with corrections made to ensure that it fairly presents the tuning system as described in the 1770's by John Harrison.