Wikipedia:Miscellany for deletion/User:MusikBot/StaleDrafts/Report

 __NOINDEX__
 * The following discussion is an archived debate of the proposed deletion of the miscellaneous page below. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the page's talk page or in a deletion review).  No further edits should be made to this page.

The result of the discussion was: Not an appropriate method. Individual pages may be re-nominated individually at will but this was not an appropriate way to try to mass delete. &spades;PMC&spades; (talk) 02:59, 1 July 2017 (UTC)

User:MusikBot/StaleDrafts/Report


This is a mass nomination of every page on this report up to 150 in size. None of these drafts have been edited in 6 months. They are either completely blank, contain only a repeat of the title, some nonsense, or at very best a little bit of info that is not enough to consider a proper start to an article. I cite WP:G2 test pages, either of the Blank Speedy criteria, and G13 (although they lack the AfCtemplate). Putting an AfC template on these pages is just a waste of time and process for process. To be clear I'm not seeking deletion of the report, only the pages up to 150 in size. Legacypac (talk) 18:04, 22 June 2017 (UTC)
 * Delete I think you meant AfC :) But anyway I'm all for deletion of the really small drafts. People have been working off of this report for about a year and a half, and I've seen a lot of time wasted through MfD'ing them. There might have been some that were kept but not to my recollection, and surely a low percentage. Overall, in my opinion we need a new speedy criterion for old, useless drafts. We're not worried about conserving disk space or anything, rather these are cluttering up the Draft namespace, obscuring those that actually have a chance at becoming articles &mdash;  MusikAnimal  talk  21:18, 22 June 2017 (UTC)
 * Yes AfC. Thank-you. I've CSD G2 a few and then got the bright idea to batch nominate them. 150 seemed like a reasonable cutoff but I could go higher. You can't say anything meaningful in terms of starting an article in 150 characters. Legacypac (talk) 21:37, 22 June 2017 (UTC)


 * Comment -


 * 1) Draft:Dooa El Adl
 * 2) Draft:Christopher Thomas Healy
 * 3) Draft:Gele Seckstein
 * 4) Draft:Andrew Chow
 * 5) Draft:Cody Veith
 * 6) Draft:Jaiteg Singh Anant
 * 7) Draft:Paloma Arellano
 * 8) Draft:Benyamin Jahromi
 * 9) Draft:The Gubb
 * 10) Draft:Bullet Transport
 * 11) Draft:Ciaran McFadden
 * 12) Draft:Aniket gawali
 * 13) Draft:Blake Gray
 * 14) Draft:Tanglewood (Clinton, Mississippi)
 * 15) Draft:Glioln
 * 16) Draft:Deklan Hill
 * 17) Draft:SneaK it
 * 18) Draft:TheDaRkSider360
 * 19) Draft:Yabra
 * 20) Draft:Cameron Jack (Actor)
 * 21) Draft:C. W. Snedden
 * 22) Draft:Robert Kobbe
 * 23) Draft:Onion boi
 * 24) Draft:Kallippati
 * 25) Draft:Ginelkla Massa
 * 26) Draft:Nicki Grasso
 * 27) Draft:Nordic psytrance
 * 28) Draft:Constable Hawwwy
 * 29) Draft:Yellow Dress(album)
 * 30) Draft:Charie Stratton
 * 31) Draft:Leather Spa
 * 32) Draft:Darcy Compton
 * 33) Draft:Iain Parkinson
 * 34) Draft:Feel free to be it!
 * 35) Draft:Angelo Maristela
 * 36) Draft:Sophie Gonzalez
 * 37) Draft:Clayton baker
 * 38) Draft:Midleton College
 * 39) Draft:The PG Hood: Northfield 7th
 * 40) Draft:Climax Radiology Education Foundation (CREF)
 * 41) Draft:Hakko Densho Ryu Jujutsu
 * 42) Draft:Piratebrown
 * 43) Draft:Los Angeles Flex
 * 44) Draft:Fr.Gregory Augustine
 * 45) Draft:Cobra Nation
 * 46) Draft:Crotchy the clown
 * 47) Draft:Amino (app)
 * 48) Draft:Alban Berisha
 * 49) Draft:2 (Tamil Number)
 * 50) Draft:C.Bavoo
 * 51) Draft:Harivin Ramadass
 * 52) Draft:Angelique Michaels
 * 53) Draft:Leslie Wardrep
 * 54) Draft:Sabina Kondich
 * 55) Draft:S.M.O.S
 * 56) Draft:Kelli-Leigh
 * 57) Draft:Codemazk Inc.
 * 58) Draft:Aetrya
 * 59) Draft:Nakano's vanishing theorem
 * 60) Draft:Trevin Giles
 * 61) Draft:Bristol Sport
 * 62) Draft:Jeff jeff bob bob
 * 63) Draft:Ashley Nadesan
 * 64) Draft:Rahmel Dockery
 * 65) Draft:Sammy Michael
 * 66) Draft:Richard Drucks
 * 67) Draft:Dina Živojinović
 * 68) Draft:V Square S Business Development Consultants
 * 69) Draft:Shahoon malik
 * 70) Draft:Dean Conger
 * 71) Draft:2016 Tasmanian Floods
 * 72) Draft:Alianza Consultants
 * 73) Draft:Tendring Volleyball Club
 * 74) Draft:Pup Star
 * 75) Draft:Azam Chaudhary
 * 76) Draft:Sarfraz Farakh
 * 77) Draft:Joanna Woodham (Nee Glen)
 * 78) Draft:Larry McGraw
 * 79) Draft:Simran Sharma
 * 80) Draft:Pilchinnampalayam
 * 81) Draft:MeldTuber
 * 82) Draft:Suhaib Saqib
 * 83) Draft:Bodega
 * 84) Draft:Moses Jacob Storm
 * 85) Draft:Wilhelm Abt
 * 86) Draft:Kiran vegireddy
 * 87) Draft:Tim Mickleburgh
 * 88) Draft:Kiddzies Studios
 * 89) Draft:Ernst Saager
 * 90) Draft:Wladimir Sabler
 * 91) Draft:Sea Oleena
 * 92) Draft:Sanjit singh
 * 93) Draft:GTime
 * 94) Draft:Marlin olsen
 * 95) Draft:Cinemassacre
 * 96) Draft:Alfred Zipp
 * 97) Draft:Karl Friedrich
 * 98) Draft:Nihat emre tosun
 * 99) Draft:Blade Auto Center
 * 100) Draft:Ambanidadora
 * 101) Draft:Aaron Nelson
 * 102) Draft:First Recorded Sound
 * 103) Draft:Heinrich List
 * 104) Draft:The Urmar or Burki
 * 105) Draft:National Brotherin Day
 * 106) Draft:Andreas Zink
 * 107) Draft:Imisordia
 * 108) Draft:Alfred Zuner
 * 109) Draft:FlatSat
 * 110) Draft:Glasgow Irish FC
 * 111) Draft:Ethan McClellan
 * 112) Draft:David Avetyan
 * 113) Draft:Rahul Khurana
 * 114) Draft:Sandeep Kulhari
 * 115) Draft:Josef Auer
 * 116) Draft:Spanish recipients of the Deutsche Adlerorden fünfter Klasse (mit oder ohne Schwertern)
 * 117) Draft:Santosh Kumar Srivastava
 * 118) Draft:Walter Zugehör
 * 119) Draft:Cotensor product
 * 120) Draft:Sonia trabelsi
 * 121) Draft:ItsRickTV
 * 122) Draft:Wilhelm Zimmermann
 * 123) Draft:Heartfulness meditation
 * 124) Draft:Balagurusamy
 * 125) Draft:Famou$ Bueller
 * 126) Draft:Godfred Yaw Prebbie Mensah
 * 127) Draft:Sentinels (band)
 * 128) Draft:Ajay gaikwad
 * 129) Draft:Behrouz sebt rasoul
 * 130) Draft:Jarred Ogungbemi-Jackson
 * 131) Draft:Hopf algebra of a graph
 * 132) Draft:Oskar Zwillus
 * 133) Draft:Rupert Zug
 * 134) Draft:Vom Air
 * 135) Draft:Otto Zipperer
 * 136) Draft:Gerhard Zink
 * 137) Draft:Heinrich Zimmermann
 * 138) Draft:Nicole McDonald
 * 139) Draft:Joan Margaret Bielski AO AM
 * 140) Draft:Herbert Ender
 * 141) Draft:Stephan Gierets
 * 142) Draft:Marciano Soetoredjo
 * 143) Draft:Sumit goyal
 * 144) Draft:Bentzion Abramovicz
 * 145) Draft:Willy Zirkel
 * 146) Draft:Josef Zinecker
 * 147) Draft:Farr 727
 * 148) Draft:Amelia Sheridan
 * 149) Draft:Md mehdi
 * 150) Draft:Jarod Goodman
 * 151) Draft:Leopold Zöller
 * 152) Draft:Alfons Schill
 * 153) Draft:Adam Blampied
 * 154) Draft:Mark Roberts Darts Player
 * 155) Draft:Claire Vredenburg
 * 156) Draft:Astasia Sanchez
 * 157) Draft:Paul Raeside
 * 158) Draft:Sai charan nowapda
 * 159) Draft:Esteban Dong
 * 160) Draft:UiO
 * 161) Draft:Freddy Magistrale
 * 162) Draft:MedalRock Media Alliance
 * 163) Draft:Graded Hopf algebra
 * 164) Draft:Aquababy Warrior
 * 165) Draft:Karl Zimmermann (Wehrmacht)
 * 166) Draft:Equivariant homology
 * 167) Draft:Swami (TV Series)
 * 168) Draft:Sonic the hedgehog jr
 * 169) Draft:PMMP
 * 170) Draft:Huna Mission Hall
 * 171) Draft:Marcelo Fernandes é um Jogador de Futebol, nascido em Cascavel - Paraná - Brasil em 01/01/1991
 * 172) Draft:Open19
 * 173) Draft:Infamousparsa
 * 174) Draft:Danny Bramson
 * 175) Draft:Varon Bonicos
 * 176) Draft:Angustia
 * 177) Draft:Elizabeth Ashmead Schaeffer
 * 178) Draft:Ixel alpha 505
 * 179) Draft:Castle Craig Farm
 * 180) Draft:Snowy Gaming
 * 181) Draft:Migizi Miigwanan Secondary School
 * 182) Draft:Charlie Salt (Musician)
 * 183) Draft:Zachary Brignac
 * 184) Draft:Azusa: The Next Generation
 * 185) Draft:London Perrantes (basketball)
 * 186) Draft:Hassanbihi Ahmed Ali
 * 187) Draft:Fibration of simplicial sets
 * 188) Draft:B.k bags
 * 189) Draft:Karl Zimmermann
 * 190) Draft:Tausif Alam Khan
 * 191) Draft:Guatauva
 * 192) Draft:Wilhelm Geue
 * 193) Draft:Zenith Soccer Academy
 * 194) Draft:Nathan Krenice
 * 195) Draft:William 'Bill' Hewison
 * 196) Draft:Wilhelm Quade
 * 197) Draft:OTP banka Hrvatska
 * 198) Draft:Mbombela United Football Club
 * 199) Draft:English scorpion
 * 200) Draft:Star Trek: The Corinthian Empire
 * 201) Draft:Varun Shekade
 * 202) Draft:Kalri Minor
 * 203) Draft:Weather Geeks
 * 204) Draft:Dan Holland (at 150)
 * 205) Draft:Viktor Bauer (at 150)
 * 206) Draft:Wark F.C. (at 150)
 * 207) Draft:Julia Barinova (at 150)
 * 208) Draft:Chris Dollar (at 150)
 * 209) Draft:Tap to Riches (at 150)


 * — Godsy (TALK CONT ) 21:54, 22 June 2017 (UTC)


 * Keep Draft:Geoffrey de Lusignan and Draft:Dooa El Adl, i.e. 2 out of the first 50 due to their page history. Neutral on the other first 48. Will expand this later. —  Godsy (TALK CONT ) 00:26, 23 June 2017 (UTC)
 * Oppose this as seeking to develop end runs around the G13 process. Instead, openly seek to broaden G13 to cover all draft pages, and then see the discussion develop with respect to things in draft space not simply as new topic ideas.  "Putting an AfC template" on pages to make them G13 is highly objectionable.  --SmokeyJoe (talk) 00:32, 23 June 2017 (UTC)
 * Comment valid redirects and subsequently expanded pages would not be deleted by any Admin working this list. Godsy should not be unblanking a page that failed AfC and then was blanked by the only author making it G7 deletable, just to disrupt this MfD nomination. The author requested deletion already, give it to them already. Legacypac (talk) 01:46, 23 June 2017 (UTC)
 * Keep all per SmokeyJoe; I misread the part of the nomination statement which they pointed out. No prejudice against proper individual nominations or speedy deletion requests for any of the pages. Even a proper group nomination would be more appropriate; it doesn't sit well with me that no mfd notices were applied to the pages and the authors were not notified as is required and recommended respectively. — Godsy (TALK CONT ) 02:46, 23 June 2017 (UTC)
 * Keep all per SmokeyJoe. This kind of mass-nomination is totally inappropriate, and as SmokeyJoe said, an attempted end-run around the consensus limiting G13 to a narrow set of circumstances. This clearly a form of gaming the system. In fact, i am thinking that an ANI discussion is warranted. DES (talk)DESiegel Contribs 07:05, 28 June 2017 (UTC)
 * The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the page's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this page.