Wikipedia:New pages patrol/School/Materials

This page is designed to collate materials for NPP School teachers. If you are a NPP trainer please feel free to add your own materials for use by others.

Hello, welcome to your New Page Patrol School page! Please make sure you have this page added to your watchlist. Your NPP School page has been specifically designed according to you and what you have requested instruction in - for that reason, please be as specific as possible when under my instruction, so that I know the best ways to help you (and do not be afraid to let me know if you think something isn't working).

Make sure you read through Notability as that's the knowledge which most of the questions I ask you and tasks you do will revolve around.

This page will be built up over your time in the School, with new sections being added as you complete old ones. Each section will end with a task, written in bold type - this might just ask a question, or it might require you to go and do something. You can answer a question by typing the answer below the task; if you have to do something, you will need to provide diffs to demonstrate that you have completed the task. Some sections will have more than one task, sometimes additional tasks may be added to a section as you complete them. Please always sign your responses to tasks as you would on a talk page.
 * How to use this page

If both the instructor and student make completing the course curriculum a top priority, it will generally take around a month to go through the entirety of the curriculum. This pace is not required or necessarily expected, but rather is provided in order to give participants an idea of what to expect. It is also worth stressing that NPP's focus is on "quality, not quantity" so there should not be a rush to complete assignments.

Notability
 PART 1 

Questions
In your own words, how is notability defined on Wikipedia?
 * Question 1

Would step by step instructions on "How to change a car tire" be considered a notable topic in Wikipedia? Why or why not?
 * Question 2

What are the differences between the WP:GNG and the subject-specific notability guidelines? How do we determine which one to use when patrolling an article?
 * Question 3

Subject-specific notability guidelines
1. Please categorize the subject-specific notability guidelines (listed at Category:Wikipedia notability guidelines) into the following three categories

Primarily additional criteria that are likely to indicate notability

Primarily additional considerations that define or restrict the nature of coverage or sources required

Even mix of the previous two categories

2. Virtually all SNGs that provide additional notability criteria specify that these criteria may indicate that the subject meets notability guidelines. How would you interpret this caveat as a new page reviewer?

Scenarios
For scenarios 1-6 review just based on "subject notability guidelines" (SNG) "alone" for sake of the exercise. Do not consider any sources or other policies. Please answer if the subject meets the SNG guidelines based on the given content below, and specify which notability criteria they meet or fail.

For scenarios 7-11 specify which SNGs would establish the subject's notability.

An editor creates an article about "2028 Summer Olympics" without providing any sources
 * Scenario 1

A New York city based 2020 start up software company, specializing in data mining, has just received a USD 200K investor fund.
 * Scenario 2

Guram Kutateladze who is a Ultimate Fighting Championships fighters with the undefeated mixed martial arts record of 12-2.
 * Scenario 3

An upcoming action drama title "Suleiman the Great" based on the the life of Suleiman the Magnificent, which will be in production in December 2022 and to be released on August 2023 in the cinemas.
 * Scenario 4

A political candidates, without any previous or current political position, who is running for November 2020 election for a Senator position in United States with multiple local newspapers coverage of his candidacy.
 * Scenario 5

A singer who self produced his first album in May 2019 and his songs are listed in Spotify.
 * Scenario 6


 * Scenario 7

Carlos Alós-Ferrer

Alistair Overeem
 * Scenario 8

Jennifer Lopez
 * Scenario 9

Three Mile Island accident
 * Scenario 10

Persepolis
 * Scenario 11

Background for trainees

 * Wikipedia is an encyclopedia. As such, claims made in articles should be supported by independent (secondary), reliable sources for verification. Please read WP:RS, WP:IS, WP:RSP, WP:V, WP:PROVEIT, WP:Primary, WP:Secondary, and WP:Tertiary. WP:New page patrol source guide and WP:Reliable sources/Perennial sources  may be a useful reference for looking up the reliability of a source that have been discussed before on Wikipedia.


 * You can contact WP:RX if you could not find the sources yourself either on the web due to paywalls or offline-only sources.

Exercises

 * 1.


 * 2.


 * 3.


 * In the tables below, please indicate "y" for yes or "n" for no after "ind", "rel" and "sig" (see first example) and give a brief explanation of why you place "y" or "n" for each source.

Frank Lloyd Wright (June 8, 1867 – April 9, 1959) was an American architect, interior designer, writer, and educator. Wright believed in designing structures that were in harmony with humanity and its environment, a philosophy he called organic architecture. His creative period spanned more than 70 years. He works includes The Guggenheim, swirling, snail-shaped museum in the middle of Manhattan. Fallingwater, which has been called "the best all-time work of American architecture." This is one of Wright's most famous private residences (completed 1937), was built for Mr. and Mrs. Edgar J. Kaufmann, Sr., at Mill Run, Pennsylvania. Constructed over a 30-foot waterfall, it was designed according to Wright's desire to place the occupants close to the natural surroundings. The house was intended to be more of a family getaway, rather than a live-in home.
 * 4

Jordan Lennon (born February 22, 2000), is a British film producer and actor. Lennon is currently a member of BAFTA. He continues to work aside 20th Century Fox, Warner Bros, Wicked Wales, Capture Studios, Cineworld, Paramount Pictures, and Rockefeller Foundation.
 * 5

At age 16, the Vice President of 20th Century Fox, Paul Higginson. Who previously worked on Star Wars, Titanic, and Independence Day took on Jordan and Rowan Snow as a mentor. In December 2018, Jordan and Rowan finished British Film Academy. Jordan lived in Skelmersdale for 10 years before moving to Rhyl, North Wales. He's currently writing 'Stranger in the Night' scrreenplay for Warner Brothers.


 * 6



Sonny William Williams (born 3 August 1985), who is a Muslim, is a New Zealand All blacks rugby union footballer, Williams was a Marist Saints junior when he was spotted playing in Auckland by Bulldogs talent scout John Ackland. In 2002 he was offered a contract and moved to Sydney (as the youngest player to ever sign with an NRL club) to play in the Bulldogs' junior grades.

---


 * 7

David Howell Petraeus (born November 7, 1952) is a retired United States Army general and public official. He served as Director of the Central Intelligence Agency from September 6, 2011, until his resignation on November 9, 2012 after his affair with Paula Broadwell was reported.

Petraeus was born in Cornwall-on-Hudson, New York, the son of Sixtus Petraeus (1915–2008), a sea captain from Franeker, Netherlands.

In 2003, Petraeus commanded the 101st Airborne Division in the fall of Baghdad

-


 * 8

Martina Hingis is a Swiss former professional tennis player. She won five Grand Slam singles titles. Hingis was one of the highest-paid female athletes in 2000. She retired in November 2007 after being hampered by a hip injury for several months and testing positive for a metabolite of cocaine during that year's Wimbledon Championships, which led to a two-year suspension from the sport.

-

Questions
Now that we've covered sources, can you apply your knowledge of GNG and SNGs? For each of the above subjects assessed in the previous section, please identify whether they meet notability guidelines (and how/why), based solely on the sources included on this page (i.e. don't go looking for more sources)
 * Question 8


 * 1) Frank Lloyd Wright
 * 2) Jordan Lennon
 * 3) Sonny Bill Williams
 * 4) David Petraeus
 * 5) Martina Hingis

Please explain in your own words why claims need to be verified?
 * Question 9

Could we cite Wikipedia as a source? and why?
 * Question 10

Give an example of a source that is reliable but not independent of a subject, and explain why.
 * Question 11

Give an example of a source that is independent but not reliable and explain why.
 * Question 12

Describe the steps you should take when assessing whether an unfamiliar source is reliable.
 * Question 13

Evaluating sources in the wild
Without consulting any existing Wikipedia consensuses, such as those listed at WP:RSP, WP:NPPSG or WP:RSN, assess whether the following sources are reliable. You may refer to Wikipedia articles for the publications if they exist. Be specific as to how and why you came to your conclusions. Sources are often reliable for some content and unreliable for other content: identify what sorts of articles may have reliable and unreliable coverage from a given source, and consider using examples from their website to illustrate your points. Feel free to offer topic-scoped assessments such as "likely reliable for claims related to pop culture" or "reliable for non-political subject matter". For sources in languages that you can't read, please use Google Translate to evaluate the source to the best of your ability.


 * 14 The Moscow Times


 * 15 USA Today


 * 16 The Hindu


 * 17 Anadolu Agency


 * 18 Popular Mechanics


 * 19 South China Morning Post


 * 20 Seventeen


 * 21 Egypt Today


 * 22 Xconomy


 * 23 Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung


 * 24 Blesk


 * 25 La Jornada


 * 26 The Forward


 * 27 The Daily Californian

---

Article titles
Please read WP:TITLE and answer the questions below

'''1. Article name "Hannibal Barca" - Does the article name need to be change? and Why? (please explain based on Wikipedia guidelines and name/link the guidelines in your answer)'''

Hannibal Barca was a Carthaginian general and statesman who is widely considered one of the greatest military commanders in history. His father, Hamilcar Barca, was a leading Carthaginian commander during the First Punic War (264–241 BC).

Answer:

--

'''2. Article name "Magic Johnson". Does the article name need to be change? and Why?(please explain based on Wikipedia guidelines and name/link the guidelines in your answer)'''

Earvin "Magic" Johnson Jr. (born August 14, 1959) is an American retired professional basketball player and former president of basketball operations of the Los Angeles Lakers of the National Basketball Association (NBA). He played point guard for the Lakers for 13 seasons.

Answer:

---

Biographies of living persons
Please read WP:BLP and answer the questions below.

'''3. Please explain if the content of the below text is acceptable for inclusion and why. (please explain based on Wikipedia guidelines and name/link the guidelines in your answer)'''

Conor Anthony McGregor (born 14 July 1988) is an Irish professional mixed martial artist and boxer. His is a former Ultimate Fighting Championship (UFC) featherweight and lightweight champion.

On 15 August 2019, TMZ Sports published a video that appeared to show McGregor punching a man at The Marble Arch Pub in Dublin. The incident happened on 6 April and was originally reported by Irish media, although without the video that showed the attack. Irish police stated in April that they had opened an investigation. McGregor was charged with assault and first appeared in court on 11 October 2019.

In April 2019, McGregor is the father of Terri Murray's son, Clodagh. Murray bedded McGregor in 2017 at his hotel after the Aintree Grand National just four weeks bofore McGregor's girlfriend Dee Devlin gave birth to their son.

Answer:

--

'''4. Please explain if the content of the below text is acceptable for inclusion and why. (please explain based on Wikipedia guidelines and name/link the guidelines in your answer)'''

Diana Nyad (née Sneed; born August 22, 1949) is an American author, journalist, motivational speaker, and long-distance swimmer who lives in 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue NW in Washington, D.C. and could be contacted at +0-202-456-6213. Nyad gained national attention in 1975 when she swam around Manhattan (28 mi) and in 1979 when she swam from North Bimini, The Bahamas, to Juno Beach, Florida (102 mi). In 2013, on her fifth attempt and at age 64, she became the first person confirmed to swim from Cuba to Florida without the aid of a shark cage, swimming from Havana to Key West (110 mi).

Answer:

Images copyright
'''Please read Image use policy and Public domain image resources. Please answer the questions below and (1) provide an explanation based on Wikipedia guidelines and (2) provide the guidelines/links in your answer.'''

'''5. Could this image-1 be uploaded into Main Page and used in Wikipedia? and why?'''

Answer- Explanation:

Answer - link/guideline:

'''6. Could this image-2 be uploaded into Main Page and used in Wikipedia? Why?'''

Answer- Explanation:

Answer - link/guideline:

'''7. Could be uploaded  into Main Page and used in Wikipedia? Why?'''

Answer- Explanation:

Answer - link/guideline:

'''8. Could this image-4 be uploaded into Main Page and used in Wikipedia? Why?'''

Answer- Explanation:

Answer - link/guideline:

'''9 Certain types of images are a giveaway of COI and/or paid editing, despite not being direct violations of our image policies. Can you guess what kinds of images these are?''' --

Neutral point of view
'''Please read WP:NPOV and MOS:PUFF. Point out the WP:NPOV words/pharses and rewrite the paragraph in Questions 9& 10 from a neutral point of view.'''

'''10. She is a brilliant boxer with a rare and exceptional beauty. She turned Pro at the age of 19 after winning one amateur fight on December 14, 2013 where she destroyed her opponent in 20 seconds. Her talent and marketability made her a fighter to watch right out the gate and she fought under XXX promotion on her next fight on February 2014.''' Answer:

'''11. He is a popular, acclaimed Bulgarian actor, who loves by all who have watched his films. He was born in Veliko Tarnovo and started working in the film industry since he was at the tender, innocent of the age of 14 and he has featured in 44 films.''' Answer:

12. Please read WP:DUE and in your own words, please explain why it is important to provide balance and due weight content in an article. Answer:

--

Extra neutrality practice
For the following paragraphs, identify if they need any edits for neutrality, and if so, draft a corrected version of the paragraph.

1. Goessling is member of the Cancer Genetics Program and the Gastrointestinal Malignancies Program, both at the Dana-Farber/Harvard Cancer Center. He is also advisory dean of the Irving M. London Society for HST students. He has been hailed for his accessbility, compassion and knowledge and his remarkable patient care, even while he has had to fight against his own aggressive malignancy.

Note: Unless you have a subscription to Süddeutsche Zeitung, you're not going to be able to read the entirety of source #4 (and you'll likely need to use Google Translate either way). Translate what you can, and make an educated guess as to whether it justifies the provided content.

2. Nathaniel Coleman (born January 1, 1997) is an American sport climber. He became the first American male climber to qualify to compete in the Olympic Games after advancing to the final at IFSC Combined Qualifier Toulouse 2019 in November–December, 2019. Coleman won three straight USA Climbing Bouldering Open National Championships, from 2016 to 2018, and finished 2nd in the 2019 competition. He also finished second in the 2019 Combined Invitational.

3. The Disque Foundation is a 501(c)(3) Nonprofit created by Dr. Karl "Fritz" Disque in 2012 in response to a medical mission trip to Hati during the 2010 earthquake. The goal of the Disque Foundation is to further advance the quality of education and health care to under served communities both domestic and abroad. Through mission work and free online courses, the Disque Foundation has empowered over 1,000,000 people around the world with life saving skills.

4. Patrick John Harrington, QC is a Welsh criminal law barrister and Queen's Counsel. He has acted in more than 250 homicide trials, and has been noted for work on some of "the largest and most complex fraud cases in the UK". He has been referred to as one of Wales' "most prominent" lawyers.

5. Danielle and Jennifer grew up Harleysville, Pennsylvania and started out in the entertainment industry at very young ages. Danielle was the first to get the acting bug and Jennifer was soon to follow. Danielle started acting at the age of 5 and landed her first commercial at the age of 6. Danielle's talent was soon recognized and she secured a role on Broadway in Les Miserables at the age of just 7 years old. Danielle is also a member of The Broadway Kids and can be heard on their latest album, "Hey Mr. DJ!". Jennifer was of course wasn't far behind and landed starring roles in Law & Order:SVU, Law & Order: CI and All My Children. Both sisters have a long list of voice-over credentials including voice-over characters in Blue's Clues, and jingles for (Hess Truck(Spanish), Curad, Charmin, Pepsi). They have been seen in TV commercials as well such as Wendy's, Ethan Allen, ASPCA, AT&T, and Monster.com. Danielle has performed in the 2003 Off-Broadway musical "The Alchemists". Danielle and Jennifer shared the stage in the Off-Broadway shows "A" for Adultery and The House of Bernarda Alba.

6.

On 20 January 2022, a group of Oromia police officers fired at Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahedo followers while the congregants transporting Ark of the Covenant to Woybela Mariam Church during feast day of Saint Michael in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, killing three people from direct gunshot, and injured ten other people.

Event
The Oromia police began assaulting the congregants of Orthodox Tewahedo while they transporting the Ark of the Covenant to Woybela Mariam Church during the feast day of Saint Michael. They threw tear gas to the children's choir to stop ritual progression. The mayhem was motivated when they saw the flag of Ethiopia shirt worn by the congregants at the celebration and they start to extort them. Three people were killed by the police brutality—both were from direct gunshot—at Alert Hospital in Addis Ababa while ten people were critically injured.

Response
The event stirred up criticism directed to Abiy Ahmed's government, who was blamed for not quickly responded to the action. Abune Melke Tsadek, Archbishop of Addis Ababa, had decision to keep the Ark of the Covenant to Keraneyo Medhanealem Church. Oromo Liberation Front and Oromo Liberation Army jointly accused for alleged massacre. In aftermath, the Ethiopian Orthodox followers began mobilizing to resume the solemn progression.

No original research
Please read WP:OR and WP:NOT and answer the questions below

13. In your own words, why is Wikipedia not a platform for publishing original research?

Answer:

14.  In your own words, please provide one example with explanation when it is appropriate to insert an original content or synthesis in an article.

Answer:

15. See this video and write an article paragraph that properly presents claims supported by the source. Assume that Alsuleiman's opinions are DUE for inclusion as part of this response.'''

Answer:

Additional OR practice
For each of the following, state whether the prompt is an example of original research, as well as your reasoning

1. An editor writes a new article about an album. The entirety of the "Reception" section is just "According to Pitchfork" followed by a direct quote from a review in ''Pitchfork.

2. Source A in an article about Green Wugs states that 70% of green wugs have a checkerboard pattern in their feathers. Source B states that green wugs with checkerboard patterns have a high incidence of sickle cell anemia. An editor writes in the article 70% of green wugs have checkerboard patterns in their feathers and sickle cell anemia and cites both sources

3. Source A in an article about Green Wugs states that 70% of green wugs have a checkerboard pattern in their feathers. Source B states that all green wugs with checkerboard patterns have sickle cell anemia. An editor writes in the article 70% of green wugs have checkerboard patterns in their feathers and sickle cell anemia and cites both sources

4. In an article about Human rights in South Asia by country, almost all of the sources specifically analyze one country at a time. An editor writes a lead that summarizes the information in the article, including phrases such as roughly half of the countries in South Asia allow for the use of the death penalty and Most countries in South Asia developed their modern legal codes based off of British colonial law.

5. In a review for a song, the editor includes an analysis of the song's lyrics and their meanings that are cited to Genius (website)

6. In an article titled International reactions to the Israeli occupation of the Palestinian Territories, an editor creates a map based on the information in the article where countries are colored in based on their public stances on the issue. These stances are individually supported by citations in the article's text, but no map is cited.

7. In an article about a company, Source A says that in 2018, the company made $100k in revenue selling Product X. Source B says that in 2018, the company made $200k selling Product Y. An editor writes in the article In 2018, the company made $300k in revenue from selling products X and Y.

8. In an article about the Climate of South America, a source provides measurements in Celsius. An editor converts the measurements to Fahrenheit in the article.

Additional OR practice II
1. In an article about Celebrity McPerson, Source A says that Celebrity McPerson was an alcoholic, and that they died liver cancer. Source B says that liver cancer is a common symptom of long term alcohol abuse. An editor writes McPerson died of liver cancer, a common symptom of alcohol abuse, citing Source A after the comma and Source B at the end of the sentence.

2. In an article about the Political McCandidate, Source A says that McCandidate lost their reelection bid, carrying 54% of white voters but only 12% of black voters. An editor then writes McCandidate lost the election due to a lack of support among black voters

3. In an article about journalist Steve Meinung, an editor writes Meinung has been published in many major newspapers including the New York Times, The Guardian, and The Wall Street Journal. Each of mention of these newspapers is accompanied by a citation to an opinion piece written by Meinung in that publication

4. In an article about the Third Crusade, an editor draws a map of the path followed by the various crusader armies.

5. In an article about Betty Author, the lead includes the sentence Author's works have received favorable reviews from critics including the LA Review of Books and the New York Times. In the article, a Reception section discusses critical responses to Author's work in depth. These responses are largely favorable, and positive reviews in the LARB and NYT are included as citations and discussed.

6. In an article about the film Cameraperson, an editor adds a plot summary without providing any sources.

7. In an article about the Seminoles, Source A says The Seminoles were able to defend themselves from American incursions in the swamps of Florida for a very long time. Source B says The Seminoles were much better than the Americans at navigating the swamps of Florida. An editor writes The Seminoles were able to successfully defend themselves from American attacks for a long time. Seminoles had a much easier time moving through the swamps of Florida than the Americans

8. Exactly the same set up as the previous question, but this time the editor writes The Seminoles were able to successfully defend themselves from American attacks over a long period of time due to their greater ability to move through Florida's swamps

-

Verifiability
Please read WP:V and answer the questions below

'''16. Three independent, reliable sources say that a subject has 2 sons, but in reality he has 3 sons. Could we change the content from "2" sons to "3 sons"? Why?''' Answer:

-

Filtering - Criteria for speedy deletion
 PART 2 


 * We have looked at the requirements needed for a page to meet notability guidelines, content policies and the types of sources needed to merit a page in Wikipedia in Part 1 (Assignment 1, 2 & 3). In assignment 4, we look at what type of articles need to be filtered out from our system when reviewing a page. There are many criteria of WP:Criteria for speedy deletion. Here we discuss (1) General criteria (G1-G14),  (2) Article criteria (A1-A11) and R2.


 * Please do the following


 * 1) Please set up your CSD log by installing MYCSD so that I can review your CSD nominations. After saving, you have to bypass your browser's cache to see the changes - see instruction at Bypass your cache.
 * 2) Bookmark Earwig's Copyvio Detector in your computer.
 * 3) Install CV-revdel. After saving, you may have to bypass your browser's cache to see the changes - see instruction at Bypass your cache.

General criteria

 * 1. Please review (G1-G14) at General and answer the following questions in your own words. When providing examples, be specific

Article and redirect criteria

 * 1. Please review A1-A11, R2, and R3 criteria at WP:CSD and answer the following questions in your own words. When providing examples, be specific.

Scenarios
For scenarios 1-3, 9, 11-13, and 15-19 all names are made-up and should not be looked up outside of the training environment; the rest may be searched. These can be broken up into multiple practice sets so as to not overwhelm the trainee.


 * Scenario 1

A user with the username "BobSucks" creates an article called "John Smith" that contains solely the following text: John Smith is the worst elementary school teacher on the planet.


 * Scenario 2

A user with the username "GoodTimesLLC" creates a user page with the following text Good Times LLC is an organization dedicated to helping your children get the highest quality education at an affordable price. Visit our website at goodtimes.info and contact us at 123-456-7890.


 * Scenario 3

A user creates an article titled "Edward Gordon" with the following text: Edward Gordon (born July 1998) is an aspiring American actor and songwriter. So far, he has starred in many school plays and has published two albums on SoundCloud. He has over 500 subscribers on YouTube.


 * Scenario 4

A user creates an article titled "Bazz Ward" with the following content: Bazz Ward was a Hall of Fame roadie and I wish he was as well known as Lemmy. Cheers Bazz.


 * Scenario 5

A user creates an article Marks v. Shoup with the following content: Under the law of Oregon which was in force in Alaska when the seizure and levy of the plaintiff's goods were made by the defendant as marshal of Alaska under a writ of attachment, that officer could not, by virtue of his writ, lawfully take the property from the possession of a third person, in whose possession he found it.


 * Scenario 6

A user creates an article, but you can't understand any of it because it's in a foreign language.


 * Scenario 7

A user creates an article, but shortly after creating it, the same user blanks the article by removing all of its content.

A user creates an article which is an identical copy of another article on Wikipedia.
 * Scenario 8


 * Scenario 9

A user with the name "WikiRockers" creates the following article Phabricators are Fabulous is the debut single of an exciting new group called the WikiRockers.


 * Scenario 10

A user creates an article and 5 minutes after it was created the article only has a single category with no other text.

A user creates an article Larry Footy with the following wikisource (in other words it properly displays in the article):
 * Scenario 11

A user with the name Gamerfan123 creates the following article: GamerCon is an annual event held in the garage of Shelly Sony. Last year 10 people attended - a record. This year's event will be held October 19-21.
 * Scenario 12

A user creates the article HomeTown Pizza with the following content: HomeTown Pizza is a local pizza maker. It has been open since 2004. Its most popular topping, according to the local paper, is pepperoni.[1]
 * Scenario 13

References 1.^ localalnewspaper.com/hometownpizza/profile.html

A user Someguy54321 makes the following article and 3 days later gets community banned for repeatedly operating a bot without approval. Mary Beth Walz is a state senator in the New Hampshire House of representatives.
 * Scenario 14

User:PhilHDoct creates the following article at Solar Panel 2.0: Phil Doct has created a new solar panel which will increase energy output from existing solar panels by 30%. He was granted a patent on this invention on May 15.
 * Scenario 15

A user converts a redirect Tayo into an article with the following wikisource. In your answer, also evaluate if anything would be different if a user made this as a new article, rather than from a redirect. You: Kill Tayo!!!!!!!!!!! Rogi: Nooooo You!!!!!!! Tayo:Help!!!!! Blood, this is my sad Gani: Call Emergency!!!!! You: Kill Gani!!!!!! Lani:321! Bomb you!!!
 * Scenario 16

A user named John from Acme Inc creates the following article. Assume that there is secondary sourcing present for all statements. Acme Inc is a Mumbai based widget company with 1200 employees and 10 million (US) in revenues. They were founded in 2015 by Wiley C Oyote. Their first product was a one inch widget. Acme have won several awards for quality.
 * Scenario 17

A user named John from Acme Inc creates the following article. Assume that there is sourcing to the company's website present for all statements. Acme Inc is the premier award-winning Indian widget company. Located in beautiful Mumbai, the company has 1200 hard-working dedicated employees who have powered the company to over 10 million (US) in revenues. In a flash of inspiration brilliant inventor Wiley C Oyote started the company in 2015. Their first product revolutionized widgets and amazingly each new product has been even more impressive. Acme has shown themselves to be the best in the business and only has the greatest things ahead of them. "If you want widgets, you want Acme," Chief Marketing officer John Roadrunner said.
 * Scenario 18

A user named John from Acme Inc creates the following article. Acme Inc is an award-winning[1][2] Indian widget company. The company has 1200 hard-working dedicated employees[3] who have powered the company to over 10 million (US) in revenues.[2] We were founded in 2015 by Wiley C Oyote.[3] Our first product was a one inch widget.[4] Acme has become an important widget manufacturer.[3] "If you want widgets, you want Acme," Chief Marketing officer John Roadrunner said.[4]
 * Scenario 19

Conflicts of interest and paid editors

 * Please read WP:NPPCOI, WP:COI and WP:PAID and answer the following question

Answer:
 * 11. How do we spot a COI/PAID editor?

Answer:
 * 12. What should you do when you review an NPP article and notice the creator is a COI editor?

Answer:
 * 13. What should you do when you review an NPP article and notice the creator is a paid editor?

Additional COI practice
For each of the following prompts, identify how likely it is that the described behavior is COI or PAID editing (not COI/unlikely/possible/likely/very likely), as well as what measures would be appropriate to take (both in terms of messages sent to the involved editors and whether to approve/delete/draftify/tag the article). Don't assume any information about the scenarios beyond what is written: if you feel like you would need additional information to provide a proper answer, describe the various outcomes you would consider based on additional hypothetical evidence.


 * 1 An editor makes 10 edits to a variety of articles, then creates an article about an obscure businessperson in a single edit, and does not make any additional edits for 3 months. The article appears to meet notability guidelines.


 * 2 An editor with several hundred edits to a variety of topics makes a new article in a small amount of edits about a new TV show. The article is not neutrally written. Since having finished the article, the editor has continued to make a handful of contributions to other articles.


 * 3 An editor makes 10 edits to articles about locations in Georgia, then creates a meticulously sourced article about a species of tree native to Georgia in a single 50,000 byte edit. They have not made any additional edits since then.


 * 4 An editor with the username "ApuOcalanPKKForever" creates a biography about a Turkish dissident. The article is not neutrally written.


 * 5 A new editor with the username "BillieFan214" writes a non-neutral article about an upcoming Billie Eilish album. They have not made any edits to other articles since completing it


 * 6 A new editor with the username "BEOfficial" writes an article about an upcoming Billie Eilish album. They have not made any edits to other articles since completing it.


 * 7 Over the course of 5 years, an editor writes several articles about a small group of academics and their business ventures. The articles are well-sourced and neutrally written. You've come across their most recent creation, which appears to be notable. Every single article that they've edited in the past five years appears to be somehow related to this group of academics


 * 8 An editor with several hundred edits to a variety of topics named "Ismail Oyo" makes a new article about a notable businessperson from Nigeria, and claims the photo in the infobox as their own work.


 * 9 An editor with 50 edits to a variety of topics is named "StacyRichardson". Included among these edits are the creation of two new articles about businesspeople from Russia. You are reviewing the most recent article, and it does not appear to be notable, although it is neutrally written.


 * 10 An article is moved from draftspace by an editor with less than 50 edits. Previously, the article had only been edited by accounts blocked for sockpuppeting. The subject appears notable


 * 11 An article is moved from draftspace by an AfC reviewer with several thousand edits. Previously, the article had only been edited by accounts blocked as NOTHERE. The subject does not appear to meet GNG.


 * 12 An article is moved from draftspace by an editor with a few hundred edits. Previously, the article had only been edited by an account that has been blocked for violating CIVIL. The subject is a borderline case for notability.

-

Filtering - Deletion policy & other alternatives
In assignment 4, we looked at articles which meetWP:Criteria for speedy deletion (CSD) and which can be deleted promptly after nomination. In Assignment 5, we discuss the what actions should be taken for those articles do not fit under the CSD criteria but do not meet relevant criteria for content of the encyclopedia.

Please read WP:PROD,  WP:BLPPROD, WP:MERGE, WP:DRAFTIFY, WP:NPPDRAFT and WP:REDIR, WP:AFD and answer the following questions. (Provide links and hisdiff as needed.)

Answer:
 * 1. Under what circumstances do we propose deletion (PROD) a page and why do we do that?

Answer:
 * 2. What should we do before we PROD a page? And what should be considered during a nomination?

Answer:
 * 3. What is the criteria when nominating a BLPPROD? If we choose not to BLPPROD a page what are the alternatives? (give three examples with explanations)

Answer:
 * 4. In what circumstances can we nominate an AFD and what step should be done prior such action.

Answer:
 * 5 How long do PROD, BLPPROD and AFD last before it is deleted or decline?

Answer:
 * 6. Suppose a page has been previously BLPROD and a source was provided. If you still think that article should be deleted, what can you do?

Answer:
 * 7. What are the reason to WP:Merge a page to another page?

Answer:
 * 8. List 10 reasons we may WP:REDIR instead of deleting.

Answer:
 * 9. Please list the ways that you should search for sources in preparation for a PROD or AfD nomination, including steps which may only be relevant for certain subjects. How does this list change for subjects which are likely to have coverage in languages that you cannot read?

Answer:
 * 10. When can an article be moved to draft space?

Answer:
 * 1. In your own words, describe the difference between policies, guidelines, and essays. Also explain briefly how references to each of these may be used in deletion discussions

Answer:
 * 2. Some WikiProjects have published essays on notability for topics related to their project, such as WikiProject Military history/Notability guide. As a new page reviewer, how should you use such essays?

Answer:
 * 3. When evaluating notability, are you primarily evaluating the article, or the article's subject?

Answer:
 * 4. What is your interpretation of the role of WP:BURO and WP:IAR in new page patrol and deletion discussions?

Answer 1:
 * 11. Nominate 5 articles for WP:AFD by using WP:Twinkle and provide explanations for your nominations. Take as much time as you need in order to complete this assignment successfully.

Answer 2:

Answer 3:

Answer 4:

Answer 5:


 * 12. Participate in 5 WP:AFD that have no votes other than the nominator's statement. Please provide your reason either to delete, keep, redirect or merge.

Answer 1:

Answer 2:

Answer 3:

Answer 4:

Answer 5:

Answer 1:
 * 13. Nominate 2 articles for WP:PROD and state your reasons. Take as much time as you need in order to complete this assignment successfully.

Answer 2:

Answer 1:
 * 14. Nominate 2 article for WP:BLPROD and state your reasons. Take as much time as you need in order to complete this assignment successfully.

Answer 2:

Answer 1:
 * 15.Nominate 2 article for WP:NPPDRAFT and state your reasons. Take as much time as you need in order to complete this assignment successfully.

Answer 2:

-

Tagging
In this assignment we look at tagging pages for problems. There any many tags available in Wikipedia and we will look at some of them here.


 * Please enable HotCat in your "Wikipedia references" - see How to enable/disable HotCat. The tool lists and proposes existing categories for auto-completion.
 * Please install StubSorter user script. The script is for adding/removing stub tags.
 * Please install Rater user script. The scripts provides a dialog interface to add, remove, or modify WikiProject banners, including class and importance assessment. Accessible from either the page itself or its talk page. after saving, you have to bypass your browser's cache to see the changes - see instruction at Bypass your cache.
 * Please enable User:Galobtter/Shortdesc helper gadget for editing, adding, and importing short descriptions.

Tagging in the article
Please read WP:TAGGING and answer the questions below. Please provide explanations in your own words and provide hist diff when applicable.


 * 1. Why do we place tags on the article?


 * 2. What does "drive by tagging" mean?


 * 3. List 8 common tagging behaviors that should be avoided in an article


 * 4. When is it appropriate to remove the tags?


 * 5. Describe an article or link an example of an article where it would be appropriate to place three or more tags on an article


 * 6. Think of 3 combinations of two tags that would never make sense to apply at the same time

(pls provide links)
 * 7. Tag 10 articles from Special:Newpagesfeed where appropriate tags are needed and provide a personal message to the creator using page curator tool.

i.  Answer:

ii. Answer:

iii. Answer:

iv. Answer:

v.  Answer:

vi. Answer:

vii. Answer:

viii. Answer:

ix. Answer:

x.  Answer:


 * 7. Read WikiProject Stub sorting/Stub types and use StubSorter user script. Tag 10 sub class article correctly from Special:Newpagesfeed. (pls provide links)

i.  Answer:

ii. Answer:

iii. Answer:

iv. Answer:

v.  Answer:

vi. Answer:

vii. Answer:

viii. Answer:

ix. Answer:

x.  Answer:

Categorization

 * 7. Please read Categorization and assign 10 articles from Special:Newpagesfeed to one or more useful categories. You can check similar articles for potentially relevant categories. (pls provide links)

i.  Answer:

ii. Answer:

iii. Answer:

iv. Answer:

v.  Answer:

vi. Answer:

vii. Answer:

viii. Answer:

ix. Answer:

x.  Answer:

WikiProject Sorting

 * 8. Please read WikiProject and Content assessment and tag 10 articles from Special:Newpagesfeed with appropriate WikiProject and class types on the articles' talk pages. Please use Rater user script. (pls provide links)

i.  Answer:

ii. Answer:

iii. Answer:

iv. Answer:

v.  Answer:

vi. Answer:

vii. Answer:

viii. Answer:

ix. Answer:

x.  Answer:

--

WikiProject Short description
i.  Answer:
 * 9. Short descriptions help a reader to identify which search result is most likely to suit their needs.  Most mainspace pages should have a description, preferably no longer than 40 characters. Please read Short description and WikiProject Short descriptions and provide 10 short descriptions in 10 different articles  from Special:Newpagesfeed. Please enable User:Galobtter/Shortdesc helper prior making the edits. (pls provide links)

ii. Answer:

iii. Answer:

iv. Answer:

v.  Answer:

vi. Answer:

vii. Answer:

viii. Answer:

ix. Answer:

x.  Answer:

Communication with editors

 * Wikipedia is the product of collaborations between many editors, some experienced and some  new. Wikipedia values all constructive editors' contributions alike. Communication in a civil, respectful manner is a vital part in Wikipedia, and it should be welcomed rather than discouraged especially for new editors who are not familiar with Wikipedia guidelines and policies. Most new editors find it is a steep learning curve during the first few months of editing articles or creating articles in Wikipedia. Please read Assume good faith, WP:BITE, WP:CIVIL, Etiquette, and welcome template and answer the following questions. Do provide links and hist diff where appropriate.

Communication and editor interactions

 * 1. In your own words, why is it important to WP:AGF and not WP:BITE new editors?

Answer:
 * 2. How do we deal with a bad faith registered user and how do we deal with a bad faith IP editor?

i.  Answer:
 * 3. What can we do to welcome and help the newcomers.? (List down 10 different ways/scenario)

ii. Answer:

iii. Answer:

iv. Answer:

v.  Answer:

vi. Answer:

vii. Answer:

viii. Answer:

ix. Answer:

x.  Answer:


 * 4. In you own words, provide 10 ways to avoid biting the newcomers.

i.  Answer:

ii. Answer:

iii. Answer:

iv. Answer:

v.  Answer:

vi. Answer:

vii. Answer:

viii. Answer:

ix. Answer:

x.  Answer:


 * 5. Place 5 different welcome templates on 5 different newcomers. (Pls provide user talk page links)

i.  Answer:

ii. Answer:

iii. Answer:

iv. Answer:

v.  Answer:

v.  Answer:

i.  Answer:
 * 6. List 5 uncivil behaviors and explain how you would deal with them.

ii. Answer:

iii. Answer:

iv. Answer:

v.  Answer:

A token of appreciation
We reward Wikipedia editors for their hard work and due diligence by awarding them barnstars as a token of appreciation, encouragement and make its recipient feel good of their contributions. The choice of banstar given should be fair and appropriate, which will help prevent over-use. There are many different type of banstars, kindly read Barnstars, Personal user awards

i.  Answer:
 * 5. Give 5 different banstars to 5 different editor and do provide relevant text as to why you are awarding them. (Pls provide links)

ii. Answer:

iii. Answer:

iv. Answer:

v.  Answer:

Tools and help
-

Assignment 1

 * WP:AGF and not WP:BITE -We should always help the new editors who want to provide good contribution and want to improve Wikipedia even at time they might not know the the Wikipedia guidelines


 * WP:Notability - In Wikipedia, notability means "worthy to be noted" - it is defined as a topic is "presumably" notable for stand-alone article or list if (1) it has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject whee by the sources talk "directly" about the subject in depth and in length and not only passing mentioned and (2) it is not excluded under the What WP:Wikipedia is not policy.


 * WP:GNG and SSN - both could be used when reviewing an article.

Assignment 2

 * WP:Sources - Sources needed are significant coverage of published Independent / WP:SECONDARY, reliable sources to verify the content claimed where by the sources talk about the subject in lenght and in depth and not only passing mentioned.

Assignment 3

 * WP:Content Policy - Article needs to adhere to Wikipedia Content Policy in article article title, WP:Biographies of living persons, image and text ( Wikipedia:Image use policy and WP:COPYVIO, WP:NPOV, verifiability


 * WP:COPYVIO - Public domain and note proper nouns are not Copyvio


 * Image use policy - check the original source

Assignment 4

 * WP:CSD - go through the criteria


 * WP:COI / WP:PAID - Self-disclosure by COI/PAID editors is one of the many ways we find out that they are COI/PAID. The different between a COI say an COI editor write about themselves, or friends is that written prose is not that perfect as compared that to a professional writers' (PAID editor). Secondly, if the article is about a company, the prose of the article is written more like a businesslike (business writing). Thirdly, professional paid editor would provide neat citations and only take one or 2 edits to create the article. In addition, professional PAID editors would create multiple different companies article that normal COI editors would not. Do note PAID is a subset of COI and an COI would also a PAID editor such as a small business owner write about their company or a rapper write about their own article in Wikipedia


 * G11 (promo) - What constitute a G11? At times it is hard to define. Although if a article is blantantly promote or advertise about the subject then it is a G11. Sometimes, the it is a little subtle and that would be a judgement call. As a rule of thumb, if article about an entertainers (actor/singer/DJ/artist and etc) in dept of how hard they work, how motivated they are, using all the puffery/flowery languages and especially the subject does not meet notability guidelines. For a corporation, we would see they list down all they product/services, their directors/key person in the company, they mission, their client, they are the influencer in their industrial, all the words/phrased to enhance/market the company and no substantial info that is supported by independent reliable sources. If you look at the this version of Zapp Scooters which you tagged G11, I have to agree with the editor who removed the tag that it is not a G11 and unsourced info can be removed.


 * G12 (copyvio) - Copyright violation addresses the use of original expression without permission of the holder which is a violation of laws even the credit is given to the source. For articles, the Copyright Law gives the copyright protection to the “original works of authorship fixed in in a tangible medium of expression” in the newspaper, magazine and freelance article at the moment of their creation, for the life of the creator plus 70 years after, and 95 years for corporation publication or 120 years from date of creation, whichever is shorter.


 * A7, A9 and A11 - "Claimed of signification"  - As long as the content states a claim of significant in regardless there is no source provided  or the claim might not be true, then A7/A9/A11 does NOT apply. Example: "John Smiths is the US senator who lives in Texas" or " Let's Jump, Let's Dance is ranked #2 in Billboard chart in October 2019" or "DM7-29 is a  U.S. self-propelled artillery gun developed in 2010 capable hitting the target of 500 miles" - all these 3 examples do claim of significant and some of them might not even be true and there have no source, but they do not qualify for A7/A9/A11. The option is either to PROP them or to do a WP:BEFORE or to do a R2, for potential subject,  if it has no source or only primary source provided  and if they fails the WP:BEFORE then AfD them. A7 would be something like "John Smiths is my high school teacher, who have a lot of knowledge of algebra"  or "The Minnesota Valhalla is the heavy metal band from Minnesota. The band makes up of my brother, Alan, my little sister, Mary and two of my mates, Ken and Jesus. We practice every Monday and Friday at our home garage".

Assignment 5

 * WP:NPPDRAFT - do so for articles have no sources or sources that are primary/not independent, such as from their home page, user generated sites or sport databases, club home page for sportspersons. If you would find 3 independent, reliable sources to support the notability of the subject, then please do so and add the source in the article and mark reviewed. It can be tempting for new reviewers to overuse this; it should not be used as a substitute for taking an article to AfD.


 * PROD - (1) When it does not fall under CSD but not controversial deletion with the notion that it will be deleted if the article is AfDed. (2) We can only PROD the article once thus do check the history page to make sure the article has not been PROD before. (3) If the PROD is removed, do not replace it (4) PROD would last for 7 day start from the date of the nomination and will be either deleted or removed of the tag by an uninvolved admin who decides the outcome of the nomination.


 * BLPROD - (1) nominated if only there is no source for article about a living person. (2) BLPPROD can be removed only an reliable is added. (3) Even item 2 has been performed but editor still think it is should be deleted under PROD (1) criteria then a PROD can be tag. (3) if PROD (1) is not applicable and editor could nominate the article for AfD if the subject is not notable.


 * AfD - Nominated articles to AfD if the subject is not notable or fall under Wikipedia:What Wikipedia is not. A WP:BEFORE should be done prior the nominated. If the article states the nationality of the subject and a local name is provided, do search the local name in said country in Google to look for sources if any (2) Reason / justification based on notability guidelines should be address when nominate AfD or participate in a AfD. (3) Do not AfD if the sources are provided but you can locate/view them due to paywall, print book/article to determined the content claimed as per sources. (4) Request paywall article /print book from WP:RX to view the content (make sure you have you email provided in your preferences page, so the RX editors could send you the article via email). (4) You might want to reconsider to AfD an article if the sources of the article would be found mostly in other languages besides English or your languages you comprehend. For example if an article is about a Russian poet or sportman or actors / singer but the subject has not reach worldwide notability/popularity where by most source could not be found in their country reliable newspapers or books other languages but English. I dont often participate/vote for Indian actors as I dont read any Indian languages.

Assignment 6

 * Taggaing - sue scripts/tools to tag appropiate cat/wikiproject/subsort/issues in the their respectively fields.

Assignment 7

 * Many ways to communicate with the editors - focus on the subject not the ediots. Be civil and helpful always.

Assignment 8

 * Tools - as per listed

Assignment 9

 * Reviewing article - Apply what have learnt from Assignment 1-8 when reviewing article.


 * Paywall site: If the source is from a paywall site, then see help from WP:RX and you need to forward me the print article once WP:RX send it to you via email.


 * Lack of sources : If there is lack of sources, we need to do a WP:BEFORE, then we and add in the sources (at least 3 independent, reliable sources in the article) if we going to mark review.


 * Print sources: I do suggest to avoid any print sources for they are hard to located.


 * Digital sources of foreign languages: If the sources are digital and in foreign languages, then get it translated.


 * Filtering: If you are going to AfD, or PROD then you need to provide reasons of why you are doing do. I would like you to work on different outcomes (some review, some nominated AfD or PROD); however, you still need to do the rest of the requirement such as tagging cats, Wiki Project, subsort (if it is a sub class), send personal messages and etc.


 * Work on subject you are familiar with


 * For any article without source and you would like to review it and accept the article (meet notability requirements) then you need to find the independent sources (at least 3) which would support the content claimed then place inline citation.


 * If you have a hard time to find (say the sources most probably in foreign languages) and it is a potential article, then do a R2.


 * For foreign language sources, use google translate, I do that all the time.


 * If there is a native name provided in the article, and you know which country the subject is from, then google the native name with the associate country in google search such as a Russian subject then Google search on "native name.ru".


 * When reviewing, first pls check if the article fit CSD criteria (do remember to check copyvio), then if the article has no source - do a R2 (I usualy do a R2 for potential article) or tag BLPPROD if it is a BLP or search for the source (I always search for source if I know the subject is notable and add the sources it). For sourced articles, check sources against content claimed. If meet notability guidelines (at least 3 independent, reliable sources needed and check SSN guidelines), then mark review. If the article fails the notability guidelines, then do a PROD if you think if send to AfD will be a definitely delete or nominate AfD for discussion, if you think a discussion should take place.


 * Always check all the sources. Any articles that you not sure if it meets notability guidelines, then left them to other patroller.


 * When reviewing, make sure take your time - always quality over quantity.


 * Creating article - make sure the subject is notable with significant coverage of published Independent / WP:SECONDARY, reliable sources to verify the content claimed where by the sources talk about the subject in length and in depth and not only passing mentioned.

Alternative introduction to Communications
While notability is the most important concept for a reviewer, communication is our most important responsibility. Communication takes a few forms for the NPP reviewer:
 * Always using clear and helpful edit summaries while patrolling - While using edit summaries is generally good practice, while doing NPP it's important to take it a step further. For instance, a common occurance will be to find an album by a musician with a page, but a particular album doesn't seem to meet any of the criteria of WP:NALBUM. The normal patrol action here is to redirect the album to the page of the artist. An inadequate edit summary would be "redirecting to artist" or some such. I prefer a more complete summary along the lines of "No indication in article of how album is notable per WP:NALBUMS. Redirecting as an WP:ATD."
 * Edit summaries are not a replacement, however, for real communication. Depending on context this should either be done on the talk page or the user talk page of the editor. This is especially to be done even if the other editor is only communicating through edit summaries. We have a higher obligation to do it right. Doing this proactively is great. Just as frequently it will be more reactive - for most editors who contact you it will be out of confusion or ignorance. However you will get some angry ones as well. In all cases being the calm professional one in the conversation is vital.
 * The final main mode of communication is through the toolset itself. Find a great article? Make sure to leave a comment. See a few articles in a row by a newer user all of which are notable? Leave some wiki love.
 * There are a few essential policies and guidelines when it comes to communication. Please read (or re-read) Assume good faith, WP:BITE, WP:CIVIL, and Etiquette.

--

Putting all together -reviewing articles

 * Please install COPYVIO check script. This is a script which displays the % of copyvio in a separate section of the info menu of the NPP toolset. After saving, you have to bypass your browser's cache to see the changes - see instruction at Bypass your cache.


 * Please install Superlinks script. This script allows users to quickly view pages and information related to the page they are currently viewing or editing without the need to navigate away from the page or open large numbers of new tabs. After saving, you have to bypass your browser's cache to see the changes - see instruction at Bypass your cache.


 * Bookmark NPP flowchart in your devices.


 * Note: quality reviewing is extremely important, please do not sacrifice quality for quantity.

Reviewing articles

 * Please refer to NPP flowchart and read all the reading material provide from Assignment and tools 1-8 and answer the questions below. Please pick 10 articles from the new pages or draft pages from Special:NewPagesFeed and follow the NPP flowchart and provide the appropriate answer below (pls place N/A if not applicable). Pick articles that have 3-4 sources for the exercises below.


 * 0. Example
 * 1) Article (pls provide link)  = Assignment 2 - Sources   Q 8 and 9 Q 8 - David Howell Petraeus
 * 2) Article titles (need to change if so state the change) = OK
 * 3) Images copyright = US free image
 * 4) NPOV (if not then state why) =yes
 * 5) COI / PAID (if yes then provide explanation)= no indication
 * 6) COPYVIO (if yes then provide source (URL) = not
 * 7) Article Class  =  Stub class
 * 8) Short Description =  U.S. Army general
 * 9) Categories (3-5)  = 1952 births  ; Living people ; Commandants of the United States Army Command
 * 10) Review (Review/AfD/PROD/BLPPROD/R2) = Reviewed
 * 11) Reason (for 10)  =  = meet GNG and  Military history/Notability guide#2
 * 12) WikiProject      = Biography,  Military history, Espionage, New York (state), Iraq, Afghanistan
 * 13) Sources (see below)


 * Pls indicate "y" for yes or "n" for no after "ind", "rel" and "sig" (see first example) and give a brief explanation of why you place "y" or "n".

--


 * 1.
 * 1) Article          =
 * 2) Article titles   =
 * 3) Images copyright =
 * 4) NPOV             =
 * 5) COI / PAID       =
 * 6) COPYVIO          =
 * 7) Article Class    =
 * 8) Short Descr      =
 * 9) Categories       =
 * 10) Review/AfD/PROP/CSD =
 * 11) Reason (for 10)  =
 * 12) WikiProject      =
 * 13) Sources

-


 * 2.
 * 1) Article          =
 * 2) Article titles   =
 * 3) Images copyright =
 * 4) NPOV             =
 * 5) COI / PAID       =
 * 6) COPYVIO          =
 * 7) Article Class    =
 * 8) Short Descr      =
 * 9) Categories       =
 * 10) Review           =
 * 11) Reason (for 10)  =
 * 12) WikiProject      =
 * 13) Sources

--


 * 3.
 * 1) Article          =
 * 2) Article titles   =
 * 3) Images copyright =
 * 4) NPOV             =
 * 5) COI / PAID       =
 * 6) COPYVIO          =
 * 7) Article Class    =
 * 8) Short Descr      =
 * 9) Categories       =
 * 10) Review/AfD/PROP/CSD =
 * 11) Reason (for 10)  =
 * 12) WikiProject      =
 * 13) Sources

--


 * 4.
 * 1) Article          =
 * 2) Article titles   =
 * 3) Images copyright =
 * 4) NPOV             =
 * 5) COI / PAID       =
 * 6) COPYVIO          =
 * 7) Article Class    =
 * 8) Short Descr      =
 * 9) Categories       =
 * 10) Review/AfD/PROP/CSD =
 * 11) Reason (for 10)  =
 * 12) WikiProject      =
 * 13) Sources

--


 * 5.
 * 1) Article          =
 * 2) Article titles   =
 * 3) Images copyright =
 * 4) NPOV             =
 * 5) COI / PAID       =
 * 6) COPYVIO          =
 * 7) Article Class    =
 * 8) Short Descr      =
 * 9) Categories       =
 * 10) Review/AfD/PROP/CSD =
 * 11) Reason (for 10)  =
 * 12) WikiProject      =
 * 13) Sources

--


 * 6.
 * 1) Article          =
 * 2) Article titles   =
 * 3) Images copyright =
 * 4) NPOV             =
 * 5) COI / PAID       =
 * 6) COPYVIO          =
 * 7) Article Class    =
 * 8) Short Descr      =
 * 9) Categories       =
 * 10) Review/AfD/PROP/CSD =
 * 11) Reason (for 10)  =
 * 12) WikiProject      =
 * 13) Sources

--


 * 7.
 * 1) Article          =
 * 2) Article titles   =
 * 3) Images copyright =
 * 4) NPOV             =
 * 5) COI / PAID       =
 * 6) COPYVIO          =
 * 7) Article Class    =
 * 8) Short Descr      =
 * 9) Categories       =
 * 10) Review/AfD/PROP/CSD =
 * 11) Reason (for 10)  =
 * 12) WikiProject      =
 * 13) Sources

--


 * 8.
 * 1) Article          =
 * 2) Article titles   =
 * 3) Images copyright =
 * 4) NPOV             =
 * 5) COI / PAID       =
 * 6) COPYVIO          =
 * 7) Article Class    =
 * 8) Short Descr      =
 * 9) Categories       =
 * 10) Review/AfD/PROP/CSD =
 * 11) Reason (for 10)  =
 * 12) WikiProject      =
 * 13) Sources

--


 * 9.
 * 1) Article          =
 * 2) Article titles   =
 * 3) Images copyright =
 * 4) NPOV             =
 * 5) COI / PAID       =
 * 6) COPYVIO          =
 * 7) Article Class    =
 * 8) Short Descr      =
 * 9) Categories       =
 * 10) Review/AfD/PROP/CSD =
 * 11) Reason (for 10)  =
 * 12) WikiProject      =
 * 13) Sources

--


 * 10.
 * 1) Article          =
 * 2) Article titles   =
 * 3) Images copyright =
 * 4) NPOV             =
 * 5) COI / PAID       =
 * 6) COPYVIO          =
 * 7) Article Class    =
 * 8) Short Descr      =
 * 9) Categories       =
 * 10) Review/AfD/PROP/CSD =
 * 11) Reason (for 10)  =
 * 12) WikiProject      =
 * 13) Sources

Creating article

 * Please create an article in via Articles for creation where by the subject is notable, the content adhere to all the requirement and appropriate tagging/labeling/linkings as discussed from Assignment 1-8. Some notable subjects could be found at WikiProject Women in Red/API Women

Part 1
1. In your own words, how should you communicate with editors whose articles you are reviewing?


 * Answer:

'''2. What kind of sources are needed to demonstrate the notability of the subject? Why is this important?'''


 * Answer:

'''3.What constitutes a WP:COPYVIO? When might something not be copyvio despite having text identical to a source?'''


 * Answer:

4. What should we do when we encounter WP:COPYVIO in an article?


 * Answer:

5. What should we do when we encounter WP:PAID?


 * Answer:

6. When do we nominate a page for WP:G12 and when do we WP:REVDEL the COPYVIO text?


 * Answer:

'''7. What makes an article a WP:PROMO page? What should we do when we encounter such an article?'''


 * Answer:

'''8. Why do we tag a page? What are common tags to place in an article?'''


 * Answer:

9. When do we WP:R2 a page?


 * Answer:

10. When do we WP:PROD a page?


 * Answer:

11. When do we WP:BLPPROD a page?


 * Answer:

12. When do we WP:AfD a page?
 * Answer:

13. Why it is important to WP:CSD a page when the article fit the CSD criteria?


 * Answer:

14. When do we decide to WP:R2 / WP:PROD / WP:BLPPROD a page when the article has no source in it?


 * Answer:

15. In your own words, list 5 things you have learnt from observing and participating in AfD.


 * Answer i:


 * Answer ii:


 * Answer iii:


 * Answer iv:


 * Answer v:

Part 2
'''Pls review WP:PROMOTION and WP:G11 and provide 5 successful CSD criteria G11 articles you have nominated from Special:NewPagesFeed (New Page Patrol or Article for Creation section). Pls provide the article names and hist diff/links'''

Answer i:


 * Answer ii:


 * Answer iii:


 * Answer iv:


 * Answer v:

Part 3
'''Pls review WP:COPYVIO, WP:REVDEL, WP:COPYPASTE, WP:DCM and WP:G12 and provide 5 successful CSD G12 articles you have nominated from Special:NewPagesFeed (New Page Patrol or Article for Creation section). Pls provide the article names and hist diff and I will check them at your CSD log. You can use Earwig's Copyvio Detector tool to check if an article is in violation of COPYVIO.'''

Answer i:


 * Answer ii:


 * Answer iii:


 * Answer iv:


 * Answer v:

Part 4
'''Pls read and A1-A11 and R2 at WP:CSD and and provide 5 successful "Article CSD" articles (with at least two of them are CSD A7) you have nominated from Special:NewPagesFeed (New Page Patrol "ONLY"). Pls provide the article names and hist diff.'''

Answer i:


 * Answer ii:


 * Answer iii:


 * Answer iv:


 * Answer v:

Part 5
1. Nominate 2 articles for WP:PROD and state your reasons. Answer i:


 * Answer ii:

2. Nominate 1 article for WP:BLPROD and state your reasons. Answer i:

3.''' Pls read WP:R2 and WP:NPPDRAFT and  provide 2 successful WP:R2 from Special:NewPagesFeed (New Page Patrol "ONLY"). Pls provide the article names and hist diff.'''

Answer i:


 * Answer ii:

Part 6
'''1. Participate in 5 WP:AFD where by you are the first voter of the discussion. Please provide you reason either to delete, keep, redirect or merge.''' Answer i:


 * Answer ii:


 * Answer iii:


 * Answer iv:


 * Answer v:

Part 7
Nominate 5 articles for WP:AFD by using WP:Twinkle and provide explanation of your nomination.


 * Answer ii:


 * Answer iii:


 * Answer iv:


 * Answer v:

Part 8
Pls list 10 things that need to be considered when reviewing a page.


 * Answer i:


 * Answer ii:


 * Answer iii:


 * Answer iv:


 * Answer v:


 * Answer vi:


 * Answer vii:


 * Answer viii:


 * Answer xi:


 * Answer x:

Part 9
'''Pls follow the NPP flowchart and read all the reading material provide from Assignment and tools 1-8 and answer the questions below. Please pick 5 articles that meet the notability guidelines (no PROD/BLPPROD/R2/AfD/CSD) from the new pages from Special:NewPagesFeed and follow the NPP flowchart and provide the appropriate answer below (pls place N/A if not applicable). Pick articles that have 3-4 sources for the exercises below. (pls provide link and hist diff)'''

1

 * 1.
 * 1) Article          =
 * 2) Article titles   =
 * 3) Images copyright =
 * 4) NPOV             =
 * 5) COI / PAID       =
 * 6) COPYVIO          =
 * 7) Article Class    =
 * 8) Short Descr      =
 * 9) Categories       =
 * 10) Review/AfD/PROP/CSD =
 * 11) Reason (for 10)  =
 * 12) WikiProject      =
 * 13) Sources

2

 * 2.
 * 1) Article          =
 * 2) Article titles   =
 * 3) Images copyright =
 * 4) NPOV             =
 * 5) COI / PAID       =
 * 6) COPYVIO          =
 * 7) Article Class    =
 * 8) Short Descr      =
 * 9) Categories       =
 * 10) Review/AfD/PROP/CSD =
 * 11) Reason (for 10)  =
 * 12) WikiProject      =
 * 13) Sources

3

 * 3.
 * 1) Article          =
 * 2) Article titles   =
 * 3) Images copyright =
 * 4) NPOV             =
 * 5) COI / PAID       =
 * 6) COPYVIO          =
 * 7) Article Class    =
 * 8) Short Descr      =
 * 9) Categories       =
 * 10) Review/AfD/PROP/CSD =
 * 11) Reason (for 10)  =
 * 12) WikiProject      =
 * 13) Sources

4

 * 4.
 * 1) Article          =
 * 2) Article titles   =
 * 3) Images copyright =
 * 4) NPOV             =
 * 5) COI / PAID       =
 * 6) COPYVIO          =
 * 7) Article Class    =
 * 8) Short Descr      =
 * 9) Categories       =
 * 10) Review/AfD/PROP/CSD =
 * 11) Reason (for 10)  =
 * 12) WikiProject      =
 * 13) Sources

5

 * 5.
 * 1) Article          =
 * 2) Article titles   =
 * 3) Images copyright =
 * 4) NPOV             =
 * 5) COI / PAID       =
 * 6) COPYVIO          =
 * 7) Article Class    =
 * 8) Short Descr      =
 * 9) Categories       =
 * 10) Review/AfD/PROP/CSD =
 * 11) Reason (for 10)  =
 * 12) WikiProject      =
 * 13) Sources

---

Part 10
Creating article

'''Please create an article in via Wikipedia:Articles for creation where by the subject is notable, the content adhere to all the requirement and appropriate tagging/labeling/linking as discussed from Assignment 1-8. Some notable subjects could be found at WikiProject Women in Red/API Women.

Answer:

Advanced questions
This section contains more difficult questions for extra practice, as well as questions tailored toward coaching editors who already have some NPP experience or who are otherwise very familiar with Wikipedia policy in general.

Introductory questions

 * 1. What is the purpose of new page patrol? Be specific, what kinds of content do we want to accept, what kinds of content do we want to keep out, and what kind of maintenance should we be performing beyond accepting/deleting articles?


 * 2. How do GNG, SNGs, and CSD criteria interact in the NPP process?


 * 3 What is the role of IAR in the NPP process?

For these patrols, please select articles from the new page queue that are significantly different in subject matter and document your process of reviewing them step by step