Wikipedia:Peer review/Criticisms of communism/archive1

Criticisms of communism
Remarkably well-written and NPoV article, especially considering the subject. It has been laden with tags by a single contentious editor, who also occasionally reverts. I looked at the article in an effort to mediate this dispute, and was impressed by the quality of the majority text. His points of difference should be resolved; they are listed at some length on the Talk:criticisms of communism, especially the one actual accuracy dispute (about the relative productivity of Hungary and France); and any other questions of accuracy and PoV raised. Septentrionalis 17:46, 2 August 2005 (UTC)


 * Septentrionalis is not a neutral mediator in this discussion but is involved in other disputes with me, like in democratic peace theory. My version contains much referenced critique of communism that is ignored or misrepresented in the other version. I am however thankful for suggestions for improvement. Ultramarine 17:56, 2 August 2005 (UTC)
 * And there he is, being contentious again. Septentrionalis 12:53, 3 August 2005 (UTC)