Wikipedia:Peer review/DJ Hero/archive1

DJ Hero
This peer review discussion has been closed. I've listed this article for peer review because need to gain input in comparison to other Guitar Hero articles as this is a slightly different beast.

Thanks, M ASEM (t) 04:37, 27 December 2009 (UTC)

Okay, here's my input:


 * Infobox needs ratings from OFLC, BBFC and PEGI, with citations. You should try and fill out as many fields in the Infobox as possible.


 * Lead section does not broadly summarize the entire article. Need to mention critical response and commercial success here.


 * Gameplay section is good.


 * File:DJ Hero spread out.jpg should probably go somewhere else. You probably might need to open a "Promotion" sub-section under Development and move the image there.


 * The Development section might need some better organization.


 * There are six references after the following sentence in the Soundtrack section: "The individual songs themselves have been pulled from a large number of music genres, including pop, grunge, soul, R&B, techno, hip hop, and house." Realistically, there should only be about three there at the absolute most.


 * The Reviews sub-section is going to need a makeover because it's not broad enough in its coverage. I don't think I need to elaborate as it's fairly obvious what needs to happen with the Reception section.


 * The Pre-release sub-section is pretty small and way too choppy. Consider expanding it, or merging it somewhere else.


 * References 31 and 50 need proper formatting. Reference 38 is from YouTube, and should probably be removed as there are already two other citations before it.

Hope this helps. CR4ZE (talk) 01:17, 28 December 2009 (UTC)