Wikipedia:Peer review/Demi Lovato discography/archive1

Demi Lovato discography
This peer review discussion has been closed. I've listed this article for peer review because I want to bring it to FL but I feel like it would be wiser to get it peer reviewed first ;) Any user's comments will be appreciated!

Thanks, Pancake (talk) 16:31, 12 July 2011 (UTC)

Starting Peer Review
Review started.shaidar cuebiyar (talk) 06:05, 23 July 2011 (UTC)
 * 1) Toolbox (external links) indicates problem with this link.
 * 2) Toolbox (alt text) shows no information has been provided for any image. Add to infobox below Caption, provide suitable text.

Lead
 * 1) Lovato starred as Mitchie Torres in the > Lovato starred in the Lovato's role is not important to her discography.
 * 2) number nine > number nine Note: wikicode includes a non-breakable space. Use this on similar instances elsewhere e.g. top twenty.
 * 3) Lovato's debut single, > Lovato's debut solo single, Already has a single as a duet.
 * 4) "La La Land" charted moderately in the United Kingdom, Ireland and Germany, 'moderately' is rather vague, I'm afraid Germany will be dropped off with > "La La Land" charted into the top 40 in the United Kingdom and Ireland,
 * 5) To date, Here We Go Again has sold > As from February 2010, Here We Go Again has sold or Here We Go Again has sold

Wikitables
 * 1) Each table that has non-charting entries needs "—" denotes release that did not chart or was not released. or similar, added across the bottom row.
 * 2) First two columns of the albums tables should have the same widths.
 * 3) In Singles table, a note should be supplied for "Skyscraper" indicating that it is still currently charting, something like As from July 2011, "Skyscraper" was still in the US and Canadian charts and may not have peaked yet.
 * 4) Promotional singles and Other charted songs. According to WP:DISCOGSTYLE, only notable songs that achieved significant chart positions should be listed. Are any of the Promotional singles official releases? The two tables can be melded as Other charted songs retaining only the charting songs/singles.
 * 5) In the Music videos table, 'Unknown' for Director(s): I've seen Discographies fail FL with two unknown directors. Here we have four out of eleven. Greater effort is needed to find these.

References Review done.shaidar cuebiyar (talk) 03:49, 24 July 2011 (UTC)
 * 1) De-link second, or subsequent, appearances of any linked term within this section, e.g. MTV News, MTV Networks, Viacom.
 * 2) Check publisher/work for Hung Medien-related references, e.g. ARIA Charts > Australian Charts Portal. Whilst ARIA has supplied the information, these charts are published by Hung Medien and not by ARIA. Australian Charts Portal only show peaks in 1–50. Meanwhile ARIA Charts positions 1–100 are archived here and require more work to find peak positions.
 * 3) Avoid redirect on ChartsPlus use UKChartsPlus, also note italics on subsequent uses.
 * 4) Check language, for first instance provide a wikilink/piped wikilink, e.g. German > German
 * 5) According to Record charts, "Since Chart Stats is an anonymous archive, its use has been challenged in the past". OCC only gives top 75 positions.
 * 6) Ref [31] needs language = German.
 * 7) Ref [39], English is the default language and so does not have to be specified.