Wikipedia:Peer review/Fitz Hugh Ludlow/archive1

Fitz Hugh Ludlow
GFDL release by the author of an article previously published elsewhere. Interesting, well written page. --Duk 18:26, 22 Apr 2005 (UTC)

To be featured the lead will need to be expanded to better summarise the content of the article. Many of the descriptions of the New York stories are just a sentence, they should be expaneded where possible. What was the reaction to his work at the time of publication and what do critics say about his work now? Which contemporary writers have been influenced by Ludlow's writing? You may also want to have a list at the end of the article that summarises the publications, with ISBNs--nixie 11:50, 28 Apr 2005 (UTC)

I have added to the lead. I am reluctant to expand much on the "New York Stories" section because the article is so large already. I have added some information on the critical reaction to his work (contempory and current) to The Hasheesh Eater page. A complete summary of his publications would be too large, I think. -Moorlock 00:40, 24 May 2005 (UTC)