Wikipedia:Peer review/Kolárovo/archive1

Kolárovo
Kamocsai 18:11, 17 February 2006 (UTC) This article is a fantasctic one ! It is telling everything about of Kolárovo, and i thing that it deserve a nomination for featured article !


 * Desperately needs sources/references, especially for details like the history. The photos are a nice touch, unfortunately, like all the images, they need to have non-redundant image tags (I suspect that the map is copyrighted, if it isn't, could you give the source and explain why it isn't?). Some details, like the hotel, belong on Wikitravel, not Wikipedia. The wikifying could do with more attention eg link Slovan Bratislava to the football club not the city; also consider linking the nationalities to their articles. It's very comprehensive; perhaps more should be said on how important it is to the Hungarian community in Slovakia - is it a cultural hub or a backwater? The list of streets serves little purpose; perhaps the more important or interesting streets should be listed, with a brief description? Overall its of much lower quality than recent featured articles, the quality of English is pretty good but probably needs a bit of help to make it sparkle, and the lack of references and sources really lets it down. These days its not enough even to have references, you have to put them into the text (look at the current and recent featured articles: not only is there usually a list of sources at the bottom, they rely heavily on the system. It's a very decent start, and I'm extremely glad to see more articles on settlements in Slovakia, d'akujem! Like much of Eastern Europe we have a serious lack of articles there, and it's good to see someone building up the quality and thoroughness of our article base. TheGrappler 08:38, 18 February 2006 (UTC)

The Kolárovo Team 9:45 18 February 2006 (UTC) I love this article !