Wikipedia:Peer review/Pagtatag!/archive1

Pagtatag!


This article is about SB19's second extended play, Pagtatag!, which they released last year in June. It included the single, "Gento", which is a featured article. I have taken Pagtatag! to FAC recently but was archived due to multiple prose issues and decided to take this to a peer review before nominating it again for FAC. I believe I have addressed the issues raised in the previous FAC nomination and I hope to see more suggestions to improve the article before taking it to another FAC, which I hope will get the article promoted successfully soon. I thank the reviewers in advance for their efforts in this review. – Relayed (t • c) 12:43, 17 July 2024 (UTC)

Courtesy pinging and  for their involvement in the article's previous FAC nomination. Please take a look if I have addressed your comments to your liking. Below are the comments that were not applied in the article, with respective comments.


 * FAC comments responses
 * There should be a chart box per WP:ALBUMSTYLE.
 * Unfortunately, the Philippines does not have album charts. The EP also did not enter any international charts, so the chart box is not included in the article.
 * Apologies, I misread the article and thought the EP charted, not the single. — PerfectSoundWhatever  (t; c) 16:38, 17 July 2024 (UTC)
 * Add a music ratings box too
 * Same here, local publications do not do album "ratings", nor international publications cover a review of the EP with a rating, so the template is excluded.

Template:FAC peer review sidebar
I have added this to the FAC PR sidebar. Please consider reviewing articles listed there. Z1720 (talk) 21:14, 18 July 2024 (UTC)