Wikipedia:Picture peer review/CreamTea

Cream Tea Photograph


I think this image is suitable as a featured picture as it clearly highlights an example of Cream tea, with the clotted cream and scones in the foreground, with the tea and accessories in the background which complement each other.


 * Creator:Liyster


 * Nominated by: Liyster (talk) 00:51, 12 March 2009 (UTC)


 * Comments:
 * It's a reasonable contribution for the article but would be unlikely to succeed at FP for several reasons. Shots like this are regarded as 'easily reproduced' and are usually judged quite harshly. On a technical front it is very soft, has some significant chromatic aberration, and the noise, though not too bad, may be frowned upon. As far as composition goes, I just don't think you've quite hit it - the plate is clipped left and bottom, the cup/saucer is cutoff at right, there's too much dead space of table at front right and that red thing poking in at the bottom right corner is distracting. Also, just a personal point, I think it would be better to have sugar bowl rather than the sugar sachets to go with the 'traditional' scene. Thanks for putting it up here. --jjron (talk) 13:56, 12 March 2009 (UTC)


 * Seconder:

