Wikipedia:Picture peer review/Evelyn Evelyn

Evelyn Evelyn


A compelling (and certainly eye-catching) portrait by Kyle Cassidy. I'm nominating it here for a second opinion- I wonder whether FPC may not prefer a portrait that focuses more on the faces of the subject, rather than the very outlandish clothing adopted by these characters. Unusual nomination, as, while Evelyn Evelyn is a band, it makes more sense to treat its members as fictional characters, rather than Palmer/Webley is crazy clothes.


 * Articles this image appears in:Evelyn Evelyn, Amanda Palmer, Jason Webley


 * Creator:Kyle Cassidy


 * Suggested by: J Milburn (talk) 13:22, 30 August 2010 (UTC)


 * Comments:
 * I think it could pass at FPC if it were larger so we could get a better look at the people in it and their faces, as is I'd say probably less than likely. =\ -- I'ḏ ♥  One  06:14, 3 September 2010 (UTC)
 * Really quite small. The surroundings are nice for mood, but there just aren't enough pixels devoted to the people. I prefer this sort of portrait over a face shot, though, because Evelyn Evelyn are supposed to be conjoined twins. It's good, but not quite there. Makeemlighter (talk) 04:29, 8 September 2010 (UTC)
 * I like the full scale of the picture as shown, for the mood and ambience. I think the close up of the faces is a lesser concern when taking the overall look and mood into account. It's fitting, considering the band is less about the actual musicians and more about a theme or backstory as they were performing.  I think the photo - as is - works perfectly in light of that and sums Evelyn Evelyn up perfectly.  Less emphasis sometimes need to be off close-ups of faces, because that gets rather boring and monotonous to look at.
 * Seconder:

