Wikipedia:Picture peer review/STS-124 Kibo installation

STS-124 Garan EVA2


I believe this is just an incredibly detailed picture of an astrounaut working on the ISS.


 * Nominated by: Hans (talk) 16:52, 21 June 2008 (UTC)


 * Comments:
 * There is a higher resolution image available at the nasa-site
 * While an interesting photo, the current version here is too small for FPC (<1000px on the shortest side). Quality is also poor. If you can upload the big version we could have another look. Note however that we have a considerable number of NASA images as FPs and they can come under harsh scrutiny. One of the concerns with this would be the very tight crop. Additionally, while I don't doubt that this was taken in space as suggested, there is actually nothing in the photo that 'proves' this; in other words, how is this picture any better than a similar photo that could be taken on Earth? Finally, the image is only used in a gallery in one article. This gives it insufficient encyclopaedic value and would need to be remedied prior to an FPC nom. --jjron (talk) 19:05, 27 June 2008 (UTC)


 * Seconder:

