Wikipedia:Redirects for discussion/Log/2013 October 3

October 3
This is a list of redirects that have been proposed for deletion or other action on October 3, 2013.

Spam redirects to Măeriște resubmitted



 * The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more redirects. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the redirect's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.


 * The result of the discussion was withdrawn. No prejudice against unbundled nominations (similar groupings, such as the first four, may still be listed together). --BDD (talk) 16:25, 10 October 2013 (UTC)

Looking to clean up some spam in the form of 200+ redirects to a single article Măeriște. I suspect the original author was unhappy about the original article being deleted. As a result, the article for this town Măeriște now has redirects from a multitude of people names, geographic names, newspapers, museums, ethicities, religions, etc.

I recommend speedy delete due to G11: Unambiguous advertising or promotion.

The following redirects should be deleted. These are not appropriate synonyms for the article on Măeriște commune, nor its constituent villages. In most cases these are people, streets, sights, institutions, and others lacking notoriety.


 * Giurtelecu Şimleului Jewish Cemetery
 * Giurtelecu Şimleului Synagogue
 * Giurtelecu Șimleului Jewish Cemetery
 * Giurtelecu Șimleului Synagogue
 * Giurtelecul hc
 * Godea, Ioan
 * Gratian Portan
 * Greek Catholics Giurtelecu Şimleului
 * Greek Catholics Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Greek Catholics in Giurtelec
 * Greek Catholics in Giurtelecu Şimleului
 * Greek Catholics in Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Gyorfi-Deak Gyorgy
 * Gyorgyne
 * Györgyné
 * Győrgy removed from list after retarget Ego White Tray (talk) 03:48, 5 October 2013 (UTC)
 * Győrgyné
 * Halta Giurtelecu Şimleului
 * Halta Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Horia Ciovarnache
 * Hungarians in Giurtelecu Şimleului
 * Hungarians in Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * I. Andriţoiu
 * I. Andrițoiu
 * I. H. Crişan
 * I. H. Crișan
 * Ileana Petrean-Pausan
 * Ioan Bejinariu
 * Ioan Chezan
 * Ioan Ciocian
 * Ioan Dragan
 * Ioan Ghiurco
 * Ioan Godea
 * Ioan Hădade
 * Ioan Lobonţiu
 * Ioan Lobonțiu
 * Ioan Oros
 * Ioan Taloş
 * Ioan Taloș
 * Ioana Maria Oros
 * Ion Pitoiu-Dragomir
 * Ion Pop
 * Iulia-Alexandra Dragos
 * Jewish Cemetery (Giurtelecu Şimleului)
 * Jewish Cemetery (Giurtelecu Șimleului)
 * Jewish Cemetery from Giurtelecu Şimleului
 * Jewish Cemetery from Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Jewish Cemetery from Transylvania
 * Jewish Cemetery from Transylvania (Giurtelecu Şimleului)
 * Jewish Cemetery from Transylvania (Giurtelecu Șimleului)
 * Jewish Cemetery in Giurtelecu Simleului
 * Jewish Cemetery of Giurtelecu Simleului
 * Jewish Cemetery of Giurtelecu Şimleului
 * Jewish Cemetery of Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Jewish Cemetery, Giurtelecu
 * Jewish Cemetery, Giurtelecu Şimleului
 * Jewish Cemetery, Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Jewish graveyard Giurtelecu Şimleului
 * Jewish graveyard Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Jewish graveyard of Giurtelecu Şimleului
 * Jewish graveyard of Giurtelecu Şimleului, Transylvania
 * Jewish graveyard of Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Jewish graveyard of Giurtelecu Șimleului, Transylvania
 * Jews in Austria Hungary (Giurtelecu Șimleului)
 * Jews in Austria Hungary Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Jews in Romania (Giurtelecu Șimleului)
 * Jews in Romania Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Jews in Transylvania (Giurtelecu Șimleului)
 * Jidov Cemetery
 * Jidov Cemetery Giurtelec
 * Jidov Cemetery Giurtelecu
 * Jidov Cemetery Giurtelecu Şimleului
 * Jidov Cemetery Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Jidov Graveyard Giurtelecu Şimleului
 * Jidov Graveyard Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Jurtelec Jewish Cemetery
 * Liviu Garbea
 * Luiza Zaharia
 * László László
 * M. Moga
 * Marcel Lucaciu
 * Marinel Daia
 * Marius Cuteanu
 * Mircea Dragos
 * Mircea Ghiurco
 * Mirghesiu, Teofil
 * Mirgheşiu, Teofil
 * Mirgheșiu, Teofil
 * Măgură
 * N. Chidioşan
 * N. Chidioșan
 * Nicolae Edroiu
 * Onorica Abrudan
 * Piroste
 * Piroşte
 * Piroște
 * Radu Capilnasiu
 * Raluca Ciocian
 * Religions in Giurtelecu Şimleului
 * Religions in Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Romanesc din Giurtelec
 * Romanians in Giurtelecu Şimleului
 * Romanians in Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Sanda Băcueţ Crişan
 * Sanda Băcueț Crișan
 * Sanziana Batiste
 * Silvia Bodea-Salajan
 * Slovaks in Austria Hungary (Giurtelecu Șimleului)
 * Slovaks in Austria Hungary Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Slovaks in Hungary (Giurtelecu Șimleului)
 * Slovaks in Hungary Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Slovaks in Romania (Giurtelecu Șimleului)
 * Slovaks in Romania Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Slovaks in Transylvania (Giurtelecu Șimleului)
 * Slovaks in Transylvania Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Stefan Lucaciu
 * Synagogue of Giurtelec
 * Synagogue of Giurtelecu
 * Synagogue of Giurtelecu Şimleului
 * Synagogue of Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Teodor Saracut-Comanescu
 * Teodor Topan
 * Teofil Mirghesiu
 * Teofil Mirgheşiu
 * Teofil Mirgheșiu
 * Time line of Giurtelecu Şimleului
 * Time line of Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Timeline of Giurtelecu Şimleului history
 * Timeline of Giurtelecu Șimleului history
 * Tărbăcii
 * V. Russu
 * Valentin Mesesan
 * Via lui Damian
 * Viata studenteasca
 * Viaţa studenţească
 * Viaţa studenţeasă
 * Viața studențească
 * Viața studențeasă
 * Viorel Ciubota
 * Viorel Marginean
 * Viorel Muresan
 * Viorel Tautan
 * Viorel Varga
 * Viorica Blaj
 * Zebacinschi, Corneliu
 * Zoia Maxim
 * Îndreiu
 * Şerdan Orga, Daniela
 * Șerdan Orga, Daniela — Preceding unsigned comment added by Hollomis (talk • contribs) 14:36, 4 October 2013 (UTC)


 * Delete all except the entry I retargeted, since none of these have an reason to redirect to the town. Ego White Tray (talk) 03:50, 5 October 2013 (UTC)
 * Keep – All. I go to the very first one, find it mentioned in the article in the History section and see nothing to indicate that it is a spam link.  If the nom wants some of these deleted, then there is a need to withdraw, start over and rethink this proposal.  The first redirect hasn't even been tagged and disengaged, so I assume none of them have.  If this is not withdrawn and restructured, then it might sit here on this page awaiting disposition for quite a while. –   Paine Ellsworth   C LIMAX ! 09:12, 5 October 2013 (UTC)
 * Keep all-First off, WP:G11 doesn't even come close to applying, so let's just take speedy deletion off the table. Secondly, none of these redirects have been tagged for deletion, which is a significant procedural problem. Some of these appear invalid, but at least a few are mentioned in the target article. As it is, this list is simply too large and too broad to deal with. --Fyre2387 (talk • contribs) 21:49, 5 October 2013 (UTC)
 * Withdraw. It is indeed a procedural nightmare to delete one by one, seeing that a particular user has created over 200 redirects here.Hollomis (talk) 20:08, 9 October 2013 (UTC)
 * The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page.

Spam redirects to Măeriște



 * The following is an archived discussion concerning one or more redirects. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on an appropriate discussion page (such as the redirect's talk page or in a deletion review). No further edits should be made to this section.


 * The result of the discussion was speedy close. Please renominate and specify which redirects to delete. Non admin closure. Ego White Tray (talk) 04:25, 4 October 2013 (UTC)

Looking to clean up some spam in the form of 200+ redirects to a single article Măeriște. I suspect the original author was unhappy about the original article being deleted. As a result, the article for this town Măeriște now has redirects from a multitude of people names, geographic names, newspapers, museums, ethicities, religions, etc.

I recommend speedy delete due to G11: Unambiguous advertising or promotion.

Targets are all the present redirects to this article except the following:
 * Criștelec
 * Doh, Sălaj
 * Giurtelecu Șimleului
 * Kerestelek
 * Krasznahídvég
 * Maladia
 * Maladé
 * Măerişte
 * Somlyógyőrtelek
 * Somlyóújlak
 * Uileacu Şimleului
 * Wüst Görgen

Thanks, Hollomis (talk) 03:12, 3 October 2013 (UTC)
 * Speedy close - we simply can't deal with this nomination in this form. Many of the redirects result from the Sălaj County, Romania template and of the ones listed in the nomination several are legitimate as constituent villages of this place. The nominator needs to identify the redirects that are, for example, misleading or otherwise harmful and then list them, with more specific rationales in the form specified at WP:RFD for multiple nominations. The Whispering Wind (talk) 14:58, 3 October 2013 (UTC)
 * The above discussion is preserved as an archive of the debate. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page.