Wikipedia:Requests for comment/Antidote/User comments

sub-page for Requests for comment/Antidote

Examples of offensive/uncivil/confrontational/controversial comments

 * "There is a problem that needs to be assessed. Assuming it is not a problem just because many are not concenred with it is a bad method to go by. You cannot just ignore others input as you have been doing. You are just as stubborn as I in many cases, perhaps more." Antidote 18:17, 18 December 2005
 * "Note: this is Arniep's spam (see Special:Contributions/Arniep) to rally against me because of personal reasons. Our dispute together is separate from this and can be resolved in List of Ukrainians/Talk." Antidote 21:02, 10 December 2005
 * "how in the hell does he have anything to do with this list?" Antidote 01:12, 9 December 2005
 * "Delete oooh ooh I was waiting for shit like this to delete" EscapeArtistsNeverDie 01:41, 8 December 2005
 * "*Delete it sure did put effort into the bullshit though." EscapeArtistsNeverDie 01:29, 8 December 2005
 * "inform me in which edit wars you are participating and I will aid you." HotelRoom 22:34, 7 December 2005
 * "pulling 8 million people out of your ass" Antidote 20:10, 7 December 2005
 * "Again, Pecher, you have no idea what you're talking about. I have made any deletions I've conducted rather clear, and agree completely with HotelRoom's criteria - which makes perfect sense to me. I also do not agree with some additions of ethnic Germans to the list of Poles and have made sure ethnic Germans like Nernst (apparently he had Polish ancestry though), Fahrenheit, and Klitzing have been removed from the list." Antidote 21:13, 5 December 2005
 * "I've noticed a lot of Wikipedian users are assholes, but this just takes the cake." Antidote 06:09, 5 December 2005
 * "Jesus Christ people, chill out." Antidote 05:52, 5 December 2005
 * "the source isnt old at all what are you talking about?" Antidote 18:27, 2 December 2005
 * "Child." StabRule 21:23, 30 November 2005 (UTC)
 * "Oh yes. SUCH a troublemaker. Just ban me already - as I see that's everyone's goal." StabRule 04:14, 30 November 2005
 * "What now, my username is inappropriate? Jesus, if I knew I would have so many people obsessed with me I would have never joined." StabRule 04:08, 30 November 2005
 * "Can't see anything wrong with that - no one was hurt, no one was insulted, and hence, no apologize is needed. Clearly you (among others) have been rather offended by the recent purges of Jewish lists and need some type of scapegoat to pour out their emotions on. It hasn't worked as of yet and won't. Again, you have no idea what you're requesting - just basing them on your petty feelings on the subject matter." StabRule 00:58, 30 November 2005
 * "No I singled it out because about 10 other lists exist exactly like it - and it's way too specific. I also would like for you to act at least minimally more mature as I have explained to you perhaps 100 bazillian times that I have not sockpuppeted and don't do anything to spite you - in fact, you certainly do much more to spite me." StabRule 21:56, 29 November 2005
 * "If anyone should be apologizing it is the so-called "hotheads" who spewed their guts out on the afd. Ofcourse, I don't see the end for any apologies on anyone's part for in the end a consensus was reached. Learn to live with it." StabRule 21:40, 29 November 2005
 * "And just to show you I'm not acting nice to anyone just to get support --- I personally still think User:Peyna acts like an asshole. There." StabRule 21:14, 29 November 2005
 * "Get a life. Thanks." StabRule 21:08, 29 November 2005
 * "O shit, but that means that now we're going to have to delete all those Lists I closed." StabRule 03:13, 28 November 2005
 * "You can go ahead and throw immature insults at me; that's fine I'll take them" StabRule 23:17, 27 November 2005
 * "Yea, clearly I can see you're not taking this seriously. I can't help but be shocked at how unfair this conclusion was. Now there is no way to renominate this list because 3rd AFD would make the keep voters shit their pants and put hysterical keeps" Antidote 23:12, 27 November 2005
 * "because people will probably take it too seriously and bitch and complain...blah blah." Antidote 22:42, 27 November 2005
 * "Please refrain from instructing me on what I should or should not do given your COMPLETE ignorance on the occurence. Please see comments above. Thank you." StabRule 19:31, 27 November 2005
 * "''It's quite simple: I will continue to revert additions of people who have barely anything to do with Ukraine. I will try to add as many ethnic Ukrainians as possible (considering this list is seriously lacking in important people). Secondly, if you feel that this list should INCLUDE Ukrainian Jews and Russians - please explain to me why it's ok for them to have their separate list -> List of East European Jews, List of Russians but not ethnic Ukrainians? Is it bias or just foolishness? HotelRoom 07:00, 27 November 2005
 * "Yea. I've noticed a lot of Czechs and Poles have Germanic, sometimes even Romanic last names. Still, I looked up the name Mikovini and it doesnt exist outside of him. Also, nice job on the Jozef Murgaš article!" HotelRoom 03:50, 26 November 2005
 * "The Mikov- part sounds Slovak though, while the -ini part doesnt'. It is slightly important because we should know if he was infact a Slovak." HotelRoom 02:50, 26 November 2005
 * "How's this: if we can make it so that Ethnic Ukrainians greatly outnumber nonethnic Ukrainians on this list then fine - I'll be cool - but as of now this list is farfetched. I will help to improve the list - IE: adding people, making articles - but will continue to revert if we do not fix up this list quick." HotelRoom 01:55, 26 November 2005
 * "''How in the hell is Ukraine multicultural? ESPECIALLY in comparison to the USA and Canada. It's 77% Ukrainian, and 16% Russian. As you are not representing ethnic Ukrainians (the type listed on Ukrainians page) I suggest you replace this article with List of Ukrainians/temp - renaming this one - as there is no point to make this list vastly different from the others. 72.144.68.52 21:05, 25 November 2005
 * "Since you all agree with eachother and there's no way for me to stop that, the only fair thing for you all do is rename this article to something like List of people associated with Ukraine, List of people born in Ukraine, or whatever else you want - and replace this list with List of Ukrainians/temp." HotelRoom 20:02, 25 November 2005
 * "There are many lists that include just ethnic peoples associated with the nationality list of Poles doesn't include people who aren't Poles - where do you get that? list of Germans includes all Germans List of Italians includes all Italians list of English people include all English people -- why should list of Ukrainians be different? Only because list of Russians started that bad trend?!" HotelRoom 19:44, 24 November 2005
 * "I think we should ONLY include ethnic Ukrainians in thist list - for it is the only way this list will ever work and not end up repeating names." HotelRoom 00:33, 24 November 2005
 * "can you people please LOOK to see why something is deleted before reverting - jesus" Special:Contributions/65.9.143.27 20:56, 23 November 2005
 * "''Nice Job on Ukraine! I appreciate how you organized it. If you wish, we could work together to expand this list and clean it up a bit. My Username is User:HotelRoom. Give me a chime whenever you want me to write an article, add more names etc. 72.144.71.229 08:10, 22 November 2005
 * "please stop using my words "immature" and "hyserical" out of context." Antidote 04:52, 22 November 2005
 * "Delete (sigh) same as always." EscapeArtistsNeverDie 23:20, 20 November 2005
 * "Lulu, I am curious why you voted "keep" on Jewish jurists. It seems that we both know exactly where these lists are headed." EscapeArtistsNeverDie 04:36, 20 November 2005
 * ":I'm having some problems dealing with immaturity on list of Jewish jurists - wonder if you can help?" Antidote 23:10, 18 November 2005
 * "Please note: User:Lulu of the Lotus-Eaters just started it today. Seriously, can we act mature please?" Antidote 23:03, 18 November 2005
 * "Delete One of an infinite amount of pointless lists that have no predecessors or contemporaries. NOTE: The first keep on this list was made by the page creator." Antidote 20:05, 18 November 2005
 * "What you were doing initially was vandalism as well. I see no reason why I can't do the same." Antidote 18:48, 13 November 2005
 * "Can we please come to a consensus? I hate revert wars. Is there any way you will include differing numbers in the population statistics? If no, then we will have to take this up the ladder." Antidote 15:43, 11 November 2005
 * "Please do not be foolish and stop reverting the edits. Thank you" Antidote 23:26, 8 November 2005
 * "it's better to have educated guesstimates than "unknown"" Antidote 20:22, 7 November 2005
 * "I knew you would not be mature enough to admit defeat." Antidote 19:57, 5 November 2005
 * "Australia is approximately 70% of English descent, Canada a little over half, and US is underrepresented due to registration as "American")" Antidote 19:54, 5 November 2005
 * "Please refrain from editing on a list you know nothing about. Thanks." (to admin User talk:Brian0918) 72.144.71.194 19:50, 28 October 2005
 * "I deleted parts of your letter that were rambling so I can more easily respond to your questions, genius. You need to calm down and get a grip." 72.144.71.194 19:34, 28 October 2005
 * "there's no way in HELL i'm letting you revert all this work" Antidote 01:13, 21 October 2005
 * "You people are completely impossible. First you bitch about copyrights, then when I put them on you bitch some more. Seriously, get over it. If you have a problem with the way i copyright it; help copyright me for it. Done." Antidote 01:12, 21 October 2005
 * "eh fuck it; if you want to bloat the nationalty w/e" 65.10.36.80 04:45, 16 October 2005
 * "I'm adding something here so my name won't appear red." Antidote 19:06, 13 October 2005
 * "the IP below belongs to Antidote; so you people cant put "anonymous vandalism" anymore" Antidote 19:05, 13 October 2005

User's comments on anonymous users and sock puppets

 * "''If i edit under anons its because I get logged out. User:StabRule and I are not the same person - we are two different people from the same area. I can guarantee you that. Antidote 03:01, 10 December 2005
 * "I have explained to you perhaps 100 bazillian times that I have not sockpuppeted " StabRule 21:56, 29 November 2005
 * ":(sigh) Again, Arniep, I vote once per AFD - I'm not sockpuppeting. The anons are from my area - frequent contributors to Wikipedia who had their say. I'd like the crazed accusation to stop. I also stand by my AFD on List of Jewish Americans, but if speedy keep is reached then that's fine." StabRule 02:16, 28 November 2005
 * "What else is there to explain? One vote per user - no problem, ay? Also, stop abusing the AFD on List of Jewish Americans you know why I put it up." StabRule 02:12, 28 November 2005
 * "Arniep, you seem to have an obsession with investigating my voting pattern. Why not just let the votes play out for themselves. I voted once on each AFD (as stated before) and made a user account BECAUSE I didn't want to be just an anon IP. I attain no sock puppets except the one I admitted. I also stand by the AFD on List of Jewish Americans" StabRule 02:07, 28 November 2005
 * "Wikipedian policy claims anon votes are allowed, and given this I see little harm in presenting afd votes to some fellow Wikipedian users given it is their decision to put keep or delete." StabRule 02:02, 28 November 2005
 * "As I see, there seems to be the misconception that the anon votes are from me. I repeat I did not vote more than once under any anon name. Though I do know who the anon contributions might be, I can attest they were not me and I had no say in the people's decisions. Also, I still stand by my AFD vote on List of Jewish Americans." StabRule 01:51, 28 November 2005
 * "Jesus Christ, I voted ONCE on each article. The only anon IP I used I already replaced with my username. That simple. I see you and Penya are taking these lists WAY too personally, and I pity you." StabRule 01:42, 28 November 2005
 * "The reason I created a name is to prevent from these accusations - which I knew would erupt. I already mentioned the only IP I used for voting here. Also, WP:NPA and assume good faith, as I was expecting attacks of some sort." StabRule 01:20, 28 November 2005
 * "As I stated in a previous AFD, anonymous users IPs only record their actions on wikipedia up to a certain point - it's likely that this user has had other contributions that aren't recorded in this session. Then again, it might be bad faith attempt - I don't know. But I think it's best to assume best intentions." Antidote 21:30, 27 November 2005
 * "That's because their IPs probably only record what they've done at that time." Antidote 20:00, 27 November 2005
 * "The administrator himself said that even after accounting for possible sockpuppets " Antidote 19:19, 27 November 2005
 * "First of all the user who posted above isn't me. Secondly, you explicitly stated that if I wish I could make another list which only contained ethnic Ukrainians - now that I have, you put it up for deletion. You leave me no option but to continuously revert the main Ukrainians page." HotelRoom 22:05, 25 November 2005
 * "The discussion on this page isn't about anonymous IP voting like so many people assume - it's about the page itself - voting to keep a list just on the principle that it was an anon vote (which is allowed ANYWAY) does not take into account the real reasons why this list should be deleted and is frankly immature." Antidote 04:13, 22 November 2005
 * "No, I'm referring to User:Sheynhertz-Unbayg, who voted twice." Antidote 21:42, 19 November 2005
 * "I think what the user is implying is that this might be a double-voter --- and I think your attempt to hide that won't work." Antidote 20:06, 19 November 2005
 * "Incase you are not aware, you cannot vote twice on the same AFD. Thanks." Antidote 19:41, 19 November 2005
 * "I just don't understand what is all the fuss with these Jewish lists; people are literally making new usernames to keep them on here." Antidote 00:13, 19 November 2005