Wikipedia:RfA reform 2012/Proposal by Anthonyhcole

There are two stages to the RfA: argument and vote. In the first stage, the community constructs
 * WP:RfA/Drongo/Case for and
 * WP:RfA/Drongo/Case against

a couple of essays with diffs basically, analogous to the closing arguments/presentations in a hearing before a judge. Questions to the candidate may appear on either of the case talk pages. That is, discussion occurs on
 * WT:RfA/Drongo/Case for and
 * WT:RfA/Drongo/Case against,

while
 * WP:RfA/Drongo/Case for and
 * WP:RfA/Drongo/Case against

would contain the product of that discussion, with diffs. When both essays are stable, they or links to them are posted at the top of WP:RfA/Drongo.

Then the community votes. --Anthonyhcole (talk) 11:13, 22 June 2012 (UTC)