Wikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations/Caiyad/Archive

14 October 2011

 * Suspected sockpuppets




 * User compare report Auto-generated every hour.

Shortly after the deletion of the (self-)promotional Caiyad Phahad at Articles for deletion/Caiyad Phahad, User:TheKingsMaker shows up and reposts similar content at User:TheKingsMaker/Caiyad Phahad. The alleged sockmaster is the creator of the "article" in question. MER-C 09:52, 14 October 2011 (UTC)
 * See also the MFD of the WP:FAKEARTICLE. MER-C 13:19, 14 October 2011 (UTC)

Comments by other users
''Accused parties may also comment/discuss in this section below. See Defending yourself against claims.''

OK, User:Anna Frodesiak and I were helping "Kings" one of these users in the IRC and I post now the chatlog after getting the permission. it might be useful.


 * [11:19:18] Kings [5660e216@gateway/web/freenode/ip.86.96.226.22] hat #wikipedia-en-help betreten
 * [...]
 * [14:49:33] <+mabdul> Anna_Frodesiak: check also the spi case
 * [14:49:40] <+Anna_Frodesiak> ah
 * [14:49:44]  i did all i can
 * [14:49:44] <+Anna_Frodesiak> didn't see that
 * [14:49:47] <+Anna_Frodesiak> checking...
 * [14:49:47]  so do my friend
 * [14:50:00]  we need help
 * [14:50:09]  someone has to pick it up and edit it for us
 * [14:50:35] <+mabdul> Anna_Frodesiak: you should have read the full mfd
 * [14:51:36] <+Anna_Frodesiak> mabdul: where's the spi case?
 * [14:51:42] <+Anna_Frodesiak> i see not template on his talk
 * [14:51:55] <+mabdul> linked in the mfd -_-
 * [14:53:24] <+mabdul> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Sockpuppet_investigations/Caiyad
 * [14:53:25] <+mabdul> so
 * [14:54:11]  ??????????????
 * [14:54:29] <+Anna_Frodesiak> kings: still checking...
 * [14:54:59] <+mabdul> Kings: I gave anna some information she overread
 * [14:55:01] <+Anna_Frodesiak> mabdul: i will socktag his talk
 * [14:55:08] <+Anna_Frodesiak> i think we are obliged to do so
 * [14:55:11] <+mabdul> thanks
 * [14:55:16] <+Anna_Frodesiak> standby...
 * [14:56:30] <+Anna_Frodesiak> mabdul: i never know why we're supposed to socktag user pages of registered users and not talk
 * [14:56:34] <+Anna_Frodesiak> nobody can see it there
 * [14:56:39] <+Anna_Frodesiak> i tagged his talk
 * [14:57:06] <+Anna_Frodesiak> kings: can i ask you directly: are you also Caiyad?
 * [14:57:27]  nope
 * [14:57:28] <+mabdul> Anna_Frodesiak: okay. I also doesn'Ät understand wthis. maybe we should make a RfC at WP:VP/M XD. But I'm really not involved in SPI
 * [14:57:54]  im Allauddin
 * [14:58:23] <+Anna_Frodesiak> mabdul: :) i guess that's neither here nor there at the moment
 * [14:58:23]  Caiyad are Ahmed and Selena
 * [14:58:38]  Id caiyad was used mainly by Ahmed and Selena
 * [14:58:43] <+Anna_Frodesiak> kings: are you also http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:Caiyad
 * [14:58:44]  and i know them
 * [14:58:44] <+Anna_Frodesiak> ?
 * [14:59:12]  <+Anna_Frodesiak> NOPE ! as mentioned USER CAIYAD ID was used by Selena and Ahmed
 * [14:59:22]  they created that id to create the article
 * [14:59:26] <+Anna_Frodesiak> ok so they are friends of yours
 * [14:59:32]  someone i know
 * [14:59:36] <+Anna_Frodesiak> ok. about your article
 * [14:59:37]  not very close friend
 * [14:59:43]  we live in same town
 * [14:59:47]  so we know each other
 * [14:59:53] <Kings> Dubai is small place
 * [14:59:58] <+Anna_Frodesiak> it seems very clear that you are working together to promote the topic of the article
 * [15:00:01] <Kings> most of the people know each other
 * [15:00:05] <Kings> yes
 * [15:00:14] <+Anna_Frodesiak> that clearly seems the reason you want the article there
 * [15:00:15] <Kings> they spent 2 and half years
 * [15:00:17] <Kings> imagine that
 * [15:00:21] <+Anna_Frodesiak> not to help visitors to the encyclopedia
 * [15:00:25] <+Anna_Frodesiak> but instead to promote yourself
 * [15:00:34] <Kings> we want visitors
 * [15:00:36] <+Anna_Frodesiak> it is for that reason that I'm not interested in helping
 * [15:00:44] <+Anna_Frodesiak> right you want to promote your interests
 * [15:00:44] <Kings> Caiyad Phahad is already well known
 * [15:00:53] <Kings> i mean we dont need promotion like this from him
 * [15:00:56] <+Anna_Frodesiak> my interest is in building a quality encyclopedia
 * [15:01:02] <+Anna_Frodesiak> our interests don't converge
 * [15:01:18] <Kings> so that is what i am asking <+Anna_Frodesiak> please do it your way
 * [15:01:32] <+Anna_Frodesiak> my way?
 * [15:01:46] <Kings> <+Anna_Frodesiak> do what you think is best, re-edit it, delete some contents, make sure its healthy and informative for people to visit
 * [15:01:56] <Kings> we are creating this for his fanz worldwide
 * [15:02:09] <+Anna_Frodesiak> i think facebook would be best to promote your article
 * [15:02:11] <Kings> let me give you his fan page link too
 * [15:02:15] <+Anna_Frodesiak> why not make a great page there
 * [15:02:20] <+Anna_Frodesiak> this is an encyclopedia
 * [15:02:33] <Kings> https://www.facebook.com/CaiyadPhahad01
 * [15:02:39] <Kings> he has a great page there already
 * [15:02:46] <+Anna_Frodesiak> sorry im in china. conveniently no facebook
 * [15:02:48] <+Anna_Frodesiak> :)
 * [15:03:00] <Kings> he has over 2500 fanz from across the world
 * [15:03:03] <Kings> i understand Anna
 * [15:03:09] <Kings> we as fanz of CP will appreciate
 * [15:03:15] <Kings> and feel honor
 * [15:03:18] <Kings> and previliged
 * [15:03:22] <+Anna_Frodesiak> really not interested
 * [15:03:24] <+Anna_Frodesiak> sorry kings
 * [15:03:29] <+Anna_Frodesiak> i make frog species articles
 * [15:03:40] <Kings> if you edit this article the way you think is good
 * [15:03:54] <Kings> or atleast put ur comments in discussion page to support
 * [15:04:01] <+Anna_Frodesiak> no sorry
 * [15:04:22] <+Anna_Frodesiak> i'm not in the habit of supporting the careers of strangers
 * [15:04:56] <+Anna_Frodesiak> but i do respect your determination and persistence
 * [15:05:03] <+Anna_Frodesiak> you should sell stuff over the phone
 * [15:05:20] <+Anna_Frodesiak> sell real estate!

<b style="font-family:Courier New; display:inline; border:#009 1px dashed; padding:1px 6px 2px 7px; white-space:nowrap; color:#000000; font-size:smaller;">mabdul</b> 13:42, 14 October 2011 (UTC)

Clerk, CheckUser, and/or patrolling admin comments

 * I think this passes the WP:DUCK test. v/r - TP 17:59, 20 October 2011 (UTC)
 * Sock blocked. Left the puppetmaster alone. v/r - TP 17:59, 20 October 2011 (UTC)