Wikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations/Hugo 87/Archive

07 July 2011

 * Suspected sockpuppets




 * User compare report Auto-generated every hour.

These two user work in complete harmony in ImDisk article, its talk page and its AfD but have never communicated. Judging by ImDisk talk page and ImDisk AfD, both think that it is notable because it has features that no other counterpart has, both refuse to provide notability evidence and both have disregard Notability in the same way. Meanwhile, none of them have ever verbally disagreed or even agreed with the other – even in AfD – which is odd. Most surprising, 89.204.137.229 who is passionately involved in Talk:ImDisk and the AfD has never said "Keep" in the AfD! (It is Hugo 87 who has said "keep" in 89.204.137.229's place.)

In AfD for ImDisk, they both have written in the same style of writing (collocation and indentation), not very long after each other, and both believe that Talk:ImDisk has conclusively proved that ImDisk is notable. Most notably however is the timing of the AfD posts of these two: Hugo 87 posted on Afd at 19:53 (UTC) and asked for keep. 89.204.137.229 posted on AfD at 21:08 (UTC) and commented on a WQA about ImDisk that he had started. There is a 15 minutes space of time. The WQA however is posted in this 15 minutes space of time, at exactly 19:57 (UTC).

Not only both believe that ImDisk is not a stub, Hugo has reverted my reinstatement of stub tags without an edit summary, and then it was 89.204.2137.229 that explained the reversal in the article talk page. Wikipedians usually don't explain one another's actions.

Conclusion: We have people that write the same way, think the same way, never communicate but act in harmony. Fleet Command (talk) 09:04, 7 July 2011 (UTC)

Comments by other users
''Accused parties may also comment/discuss in this section below. See Defending yourself against claims.''

I'm very sure that Hugo 87 was not 89.204.137.229 when I had this IP, and your checkuser efforts are supposed to clarify if this user ever used an o2-DE IP, or at least any IP in Germany. If you are interested in more dynamic o2-DE IPs I used in the last days see 89.204.153.142, 89.204.137.134, or 89.204.137.160.

You might be also interested in IPs used in recent edits of the page VFD before its redirection. That was merged into another page by FleetCommand, because I noted on its talk page that there are too many stubs for in essence the same topic. –89.204.137.160 (talk) 15:02, 9 July 2011 (UTC)

Clerk, CheckUser, and/or patrolling admin comments

 * I don't know if the master forgot to log in or what, but the IP is clearly here to edit in collusion. As such I've blocked it for a week. —  Hello Annyong  (say whaaat?!) 02:35, 8 July 2011 (UTC)