Wikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations/Karfiol/Archive

Evidence submitted by Takabeg
His/Her first edit was performed on 19 November 2010. But according to his behavior, it is difficult to think him a new comer. All edits are related with his/her own Turkish nationalistic POV and anti-Kurdism. We can see same tendency in edits Ozgurcan86, Aniosgel and 82.236.107.61. All of them (he/she) tried to make people Turkish people.

For example he/she want to make Mesut Özil Turkish footballer, to make Cem Özdemir, who said Ich bin ein Inlander, Türk kökenim önemli değil (My Turkish origin is not important), Turks in Germany.

In the article Yılmaz Güney, who was not Turkish citizen when he died, we can see same or similar edits of Ozgurcan86-A, Ozgurcan86-B, 82.236.107.61-A, 82.236.107.61-B

In Turkish Wikipedia he/she is blocked indefinitely because of he/she used sockpuppets. All of them tried to remove "Kurdish" and change them "Turkish" in many article. In French Wikipedia 82.236.107.61 is blocked till 1 June 2011 because of his Turkish nationalistic vandalism.
 * Aniosgel
 * Khis
 * Ozgurcan86
 * 82.236.107.61

I think that IP 85.210.37.4 is not same person but off-line Meatpuppet.

Thank you. Takabeg (talk) 16:10, 22 November 2010 (UTC)

Auto-generated every six hours.
 * User compare report

Comments by accused parties
See Defending yourself against claims.

Comments by other users
The long discussion in Talk:Mesut Özil, begun by the actions of user:Tmhm and, after his banning, continued by user:Karfiol focus on this soccer player having held the Turkish citizenship in the past before relinquishing it.

On the Turkish Wikipedia, the tr:user:Aniosgel puppet tr:User:Khis, stated during his sockpuppetry trial that he was the one who developped the tr:Mesut Özil there. In the history of that article one can see that he was involved in a long revert war over a statement that Özil is the second Turkish player having played in the Real Madrid club.

Thus there is a similarity in behavior between user:Tmhm and user:Karfiol here and also between user:Karfiol here and tr:user:Aniosgel (tr:User:Khis) on tr-wiki. Assuming that tr:user:Aniosgel is the same as user:Aniosgel here, that's two lines of evidence that user:Karfiol is a previously banned user. --İnfoCan (talk) 20:33, 2 December 2010 (UTC)

Clerk, patrolling admin and checkuser comments

 * I'm closing this for now. The master was blocked for a month, and two of the three listed socks were indef blocked for block evasion or vandalism; the third hasn't edited in a year. Feel free to relist if new evidence arises. —  Hello Annyong  (say whaaat?!) 13:14, 3 December 2010 (UTC)