Wikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations/Meoconne/Archive

Report date March 8 2009, 22:53 (UTC)

 * Suspected sockpuppets




 * Evidence submitted by Warrington (talk)

User(s) try to bias article, repeatedly removing relevant and sourced facts, most probably also using sock puppet(s). This user was editing the Westminster Kennel Club Dog Show‎ and the Komondor dog article as an IP adress, IP adress 70.121.204.57, than under one username, User:Meoconne He or she  probably also edits the article Komondor as User:Lynovella and continues also as IP adress 70.121.204.57. User:Lynovella Lynovella also claiming that thing which have been removed has never been removed. Combined IP adress :70.121.204.57 and red link User:Meoconne repeatedly reverted edits at Westminster Kennel Club Dog Show‎ and Komondor dog breed, non-NPOV edits. Remove edits from the Komondor article such as : No upper height limit is given. and other relevant and sourced breed caracteristics such as the dog breeds average height. Both average height (sourced) has been removed, (several times),    ,     upper limit height (sourced) ,  mentioning other similar Hugarian sheepdogs , which all of them are indeed  relevant information for this encyclopaedia article on this dog breed,  and when we (and even ClueBot)     put them back he keeps removing them , and  makes quite few  unhelpful edits isntead , removing reference title,  without any consensus.

This qualifies as Edit war, disruptive editing,, and most probably sockpuppetry by same editor.

This edit was also copright violation from the FCI Komondor Standards, poorly formulated edit added upper case The above mentioned newly created new red link user accounts are all editing the same articles, Westminster Kennel Club Dog Show‎ Komondor.

They are all concentrated on the same issue at Westminster Kennel Club Dog Show‎ and Komondor dog breed, trying to adjust the article in a certain way. Namely that the breed is smaller than it actually is and it is more like a certain dog.

A dog the accounts and IP might be related to, or like this dog, which the accounts  call Ouincy, (thoug they deny this), which is a smaller Komondor dog with a longer body than the Internationall and even other standards calls for.

It is also possible that the account User:Goldie102 has been created to support this issue around this dog, see edit.

They were trying to ignore breed standard, other sources and pictures presented in argumentation.

This breed being fairly unknown, not many people check that article, or try to defend it from bias. Warrington (talk) 22:53, 8 March 2009 (UTC)


 * Comments by accused parties    See Defending yourself against claims.


 * Comments by other users


 * Clerk, patrolling admin and checkuser comments

the problem editing has stopped. Mayalld (talk) 17:15, 13 March 2009 (UTC) Mayalld (talk) 17:15, 13 March 2009 (UTC)
 * Conclusions