Wikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations/Wüstenfuchs/Archive

09 December 2012

 * Suspected sockpuppets




 * User compare report Auto-generated every hour.
 * Editor interaction utility

Yesterday I blocked User:DemirBajraktarevic and Wüstenfuchs for one week each for edit-warring across multiple articles based on this report. The IP, who is static and geolocates to Bosnia and Herzegovina, today reverted three edits by Demir in three separate articles, all within the space of a couple of minutes. I've blocked the IP for one week for block evasion. Bbb23 (talk) 14:56, 9 December 2012 (UTC)

Comments by other users
''Accused parties may also comment/discuss in this section below. See Defending yourself against claims.''

Clerk, CheckUser, and/or patrolling admin comments

 * Closing, since the filer has already actioned the case. Reaper Eternal (talk) 22:20, 9 December 2012 (UTC)

4 May 2015

 * Suspected sockpuppets



Wüstenfuchs was active from 31 October 2008 until 20 September 2014. The present-day User:AnulBanul (previously known as Yerevani Axjik, among other names) became active only two days later on 22 September 2014.
 * User compare report Auto-generated every hour.
 * Editor interaction utility

This user seems to hold the same anti-Bosniak views as the blocked Wüstenfuchs. Including replacing the term Bosniak with Bosnian Muslim and removing any mention of Bosniak, including categories: Wüstenfuch's edit 1, Wüstenfuchs edit 2 - AnulBanul edit 1, AnulBanul edit 2.

Wüstenfuchs created the page Bilal Bosnić on 11 September 2014. Wüstenfuchs became inactive 20 September 2014. AnulBanul became active 22 September 2014 began editing the page frequently on 6 October 2014.

All three users (Wustenfuchs, Serb1914 and AnulBanul) have several pages they have frequently edited, including, but definitely not limited to, Serb Democratic Party (Bosnia and Herzegovina). Serb1914 was blocked 17 February 2015.

This report is a work in progress, no where near complete yet.--Dragodol (talk) 08:50, 4 May 2015 (UTC)

Comments by other users
''Accused parties may also comment/discuss in this section below. See Defending yourself against claims.''
 * User had disruptive editing since their arrival as AnulBanul. Croatian-WP check-user already provided information that AnulBanul is indeed sockpuppet of user Wustenfuchs (see his CentralAuth). User is expanding nationalistic and separatistic bias, based on their contributions. User added his own location map of Republika Srpska, which is entity in State of Bosnia and Herzegovina. Bosnia is small country, for which is one map more that enough. Apparently, user had some intentions to make it separate (please see: this is where I reverted map, and this is his/"her" map). There is probably more edit patterns which is by me for now impossible to see. Please also check out: . --Munja-x86 (talk) 10:38, 4 May 2015 (UTC)
 * Please check this one User:ArmenMM. Probably has connection with AnulBanul, since there is only one edit made by it! --Munja-x86 (talk) 19:03, 8 May 2015 (UTC)
 * I'll do it fore you. --AnulBanul (talk) 00:21, 9 May 2015 (UTC)

This is statement made by User:Potočnik, as written on Joy's talk page: "Connections bewteen Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul and Wustenfuchs:


 * First ever upload on commons by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul was uploading a map of the Croatian 2014 presidential election, this same map was added to the Croatian presidential election, 2014–15 article by a Bosnian IP (5.133.xxx.xxx) in Mostar, the same IP created the Teroristički napad u Mostaru 1997. (1997 Terrorist Attack in Mostar) article on the Croatian Wikipedia which Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul later created on the English Wikipedia as Mostar terrorist attack


 * Dragan Čović, Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul uploaded an image of the Bosnian Croat politician and credited it to Herr Ziffer Herr Ziffer was Wustenfuchs' handle at commons


 * Talk:Croatian Republic of Herzeg-Bosnia, removal of WikiProject Former countries by Wüstenfuchs, later same removal of WikiProject Former countries by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul


 * Military intervention against ISIL, first edit ever on English Wikipedia by the Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul account, moving a bit of info relating to Croatia


 * Džafer Kulenović, same "Croatian politician" POV


 * Osman Karabegović, article created by Wustenfuchs, expanded by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul


 * Hasan Brkić, article created by Wustenfuchs, portrait image uploaded by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul


 * Milan Gorkić, article created by Wustenfuchs, expanded by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul


 * Nermin Nikšić, article created by Wustenfuchs, end of term added by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul


 * Bilal Bosnić, article created by Wustenfuchs, updated by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul , addition of Wikiproject Bosnia and Herzegovina by 5.133.xxx.xxx


 * Bariša Čolak, article created by Wustenfuchs, updated by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul


 * Marinko Čavara, article created by Wustenfuchs, updated by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul


 * Fadil Hadžić, identical denial that the man is Bosniak


 * Asaf Duraković, identical denial that the man is Bosniak


 * Ante Jelavić, infobox update by Wustenfuchs, infobox update by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul


 * Croatian National Assembly, article created by Wustenfuchs, later moved and updated by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul


 * Independence Day (Bosnia and Herzegovina), article created by Wustenfuchs, later moved and updated by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul


 * Barryevi amandmani, article created by Wustenfuchs, updated by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul , updated by 5.133.xxx.xxx


 * Croatian Peasant Party of Stjepan Radić, moved by Wustenfuchs, later moved by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul


 * Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bosnian language removed and Serbo-Croatian added by Wustenfuchs, same edit later done by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul


 * Jure Pelivan, article created by Wustenfuchs on the Croatian Wikipedia, Croat ethnicity added by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul on English Wikipedia


 * Križančevo selo killings, concerning the deaths of Bosnian Croats, moved by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul to Križančevo Selo massacre


 * Bosnian Muslims, same removal of redirect and replacement with DAB


 * Canton 10, same return of unconstitutional symbols


 * John Kasich, same concern of Croatness in early life section

Connections between Serb1914, Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul, and Wustenfuchs:


 * List of endorsements in the Scottish independence referendum, 2014, update by Wustenfuchs of Serb1914's reference


 * Ruža Tomašić, same concern of Croatian Party of Rights membership


 * Miroslav Tuđman, infobox editing by Wustenfuchs by Serb1914  by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul


 * Fahrudin Radončić, infobox editing by Wustenfuchs by Serb1914  by Yerevani Axjik/AnulBanul


 * Serbian Progressive Party, removal of populism


 * Council of Ministers of Bosnia and Herzegovina, update of current cabinet

Pretty open-and-shut to me. The irony of him of all people having started WikiProject Republika Srpska is too much to bear. :) This decietful persona which he has created is an obvious attempt to game the system, avoid scrutiny, and/or troll, all of which are explicitly forbidden under general guidelines and ARBMAC. His claim that he has "no connection to the said user whatsoever" is an outright lie --Potočnik (talk) 09:27, 9 May 2015 (UTC)"

--Munja-x86 (talk) 16:05, 9 May 2015 (UTC)

@VanjaGenije. In my defence, regarding your endorsment of comparing Serb1914 and my account, I can say that perhaps, Serb1914 saw my edit, and just repeated it. It happens. Just saw, he added "Bosniak nationalism" before I did. --AnulBanul (talk) 23:29, 14 May 2015 (UTC)

Clerk, CheckUser, and/or patrolling admin comments
First, you have not explained the connection of Serb1914 to the other two. Please, provide some evidence, preferably WP:diffs of similar edits. Second, you proved that Wüstenfuchs and AnulBanul are (probably) run by the same person, but I don't see what is WP:ILLEGIT in that situation. User is allowed to abandon one account and create other, if that is not used for illegitimate purposes. If you think there is anything illegitimate, please explain.  Vanjagenije  (talk)  18:40, 4 May 2015 (UTC)
 * No explanation given. Closing the case.  Vanjagenije  (talk)  10:06, 7 May 2015 (UTC)
 * I've reopened the case since new information was added.  Vanjagenije  (talk)  19:40, 10 May 2015 (UTC)

Vanjagenije, I have given my observations here, somewhat expanding on what Potočnik had already noted. Should I copy-paste my comment or are the two investigations considered related? Surtsicna (talk) 16:53, 11 May 2015 (UTC)
 * To compare with . This diff may be used as evidence:  vs.  (both adding "Bosniak nationalism" to the infobox).  Vanjagenije   (talk)  22:18, 14 May 2015 (UTC)


 * AnulBanul and Serb1914 appear to be ❌. The other account, not being endorsed, has not been checked.
 * This is by no means conclusive, but AnulBanul is editing from the same ISP and geographic area that the master was. ​—DoRD (talk)​ 13:36, 15 May 2015 (UTC)
 * . As I already said, AnulBanul is probably the same person as Wüstenfuchs, but nothing WP:ILLEGIT was proven. No evidence against was presented here. AnulBanul is technically unrelated Serb1914, and behavioral evidence is not particularly strong. I'm closing this case with no action.  Vanjagenije   (talk)  17:17, 15 May 2015 (UTC)

09 May 2015

 * Suspected sockpuppets


 * User compare report Auto-generated every hour.
 * Editor interaction utility

There are no any evidence. However, User:Munja-x86 is concerned that this might be my account. -- AnulBanul (talk) 00:41, 9 May 2015 (UTC)

Comments by other users
''Accused parties may also comment/discuss in this section below. See Defending yourself against claims.''


 * Something is fishy here, I've seen two different users accuse AnulBanul of sockpuppetry, one at WP:ANI, and the other at my talk page, see . --Joy &#91;shallot&#93; (talk) 15:43, 10 May 2015 (UTC)


 * Of course user is sockpuppeting. I added User:Snuns based on their contribs. Same summary in edits also. --Munja-x86 (talk) 14:06, 11 May 2015 (UTC)
 * "Fishy" is one way to put it. The evidence presented by Potočnik seems damning enough, but the correspondence with AnulBanul/Yerevani Axjik on my talk page might be of some relevance as well. While I had suspected for quite a while that AnulBanul/Yerevani Axjik might be pushing some kind of an agenda (the loaded word I normally strive to avoid), there were things that struck me as purely bizarre. For example, claiming that (s)he was not aware that (s)he had made this edit. That's not a punctation mark gone missing but a complete rewording of a sentence along with removal of a reference - which, apparently, can be done unknowingly. A case of multiple personality or of multiple accounts? Or simply an X-file?
 * Anyway, Potočnik noted that a Bosnian IP from Mostar edited an article on en.wikipedia to add an image which had been uploaded by AnulBanul/Yerevani Axjik 3 days earlier; AnulBanul/Yerevani Axjik and the same Mostar IP then created the same article on en.wikipedia and hr.wikipedia respectively. Curiously, the supposedly Armenian-born almuna of the University of Belgrade no longer lives in Serbia, but does "visit Mostar very often".
 * Also of note are the unmistakably similar views on the "statehood" of the entities of Bosnia and Herzegovina promoted as facts by AnulBanul/Yerevani Axjik on en.wikipedia and by Wüstenfuchs on hr.wikipedia.
 * This is not to say that AnulBanul/Yerevani Axjik takes no interest in Armenian politics, however; both (s)he and Wüstenfuchs have edited articles about Nagorno-Karabakh. Finally, the last few edits by Wüstenfuchs were made on 20 September 2014, concerning the article about the Bosnian jihadist Bilal Bosnić; AnulBanul/Yerevani Axjik made her (his?) first few edits two days later, in an article about the military intervention against ISIL. AnulBanul/Yerevani Axjik first edited the article about Bilal Bosnić 16 days after Wüstenfuchs's last contributions, and continued to be very much involved in the article. Surtsicna (talk) 16:45, 11 May 2015 (UTC)


 * There's definitely some sockpuppetry going on here. I think a checkuser might help shed some light on the situation (although I believe the Wüstenfuchs account would be stale). Most telling is that the AnulBanul account started editing - precociously - immediately after Wüstenfuchs stopped. ArmenMM would be the most useless sockpuppet ever, as the account hasn't actually done anything, although the timestamp of their sole edit fits nearly into AnulBanul's editing patterns. bobrayner (talk) 21:18, 11 May 2015 (UTC)


 * I have nothing to do with suspected sockpuppets. That's what I have to say in my defence. --AnulBanul (talk) 15:22, 12 May 2015 (UTC)
 * It should be noted, however, that Wüstenfuchs is not on this list of suspected sockpuppets. Intentionally or not, your refutal thus does not encompass that account. For what it's worth, AnulBanul has been blocked indefinitely on Croatian Wikipedia on the account of being a sockpuppet of Wüstenfuchs. Surtsicna (talk) 17:08, 12 May 2015 (UTC)
 * He's not in the scope of this investigation, therefore such phrasing. --AnulBanul (talk) 17:24, 12 May 2015 (UTC)


 * The most obvious connection is to Wüstenfuchs; perhaps this SPI could be tied to that account as the sockmaster, but first things first - we need to deal with the problem rather than restart this SPI on a different page to make the paperwork look slightly neater. bobrayner (talk) 21:56, 14 May 2015 (UTC)

Clerk, CheckUser, and/or patrolling admin comments

 * Is there any evidence to connect AnulBanul to either ArmenMM or Snuns? I don't see any evidence here.  Vanjagenije  (talk)  20:58, 11 May 2015 (UTC)
 * I have not encountered either user. Surtsicna (talk) 22:10, 11 May 2015 (UTC)
 * Take a look at the contribs: User Snuns is registered to make first edit 30th March, with few edits among which is Zvornik police station shooting. User has same editing, summarizing and referencing pattern as AnulBanul. --Munja-x86 (talk) 22:18, 11 May 2015 (UTC)


 * You have to understand that WP:SOCKPUPPETRY means using multiple accounts for illegitimate purposes (on English Wikipedia). You made a detailed discussion here proving that AnulBanul is the same person as . I agree that they are probably one at the same, but that is not sockpuppetry because nothing illegitimate was done (at least you did not explain). User is allowed to abandon one account and make a clean start with another (unless he is blocked/banned, which is not the case with Wüstenfuchs). made just one edit, on the talk page. Even if he is the same person as AnulBanul, there is nothing illegitimate there neither. I personally checked editing interaction between Snuns and AnulBanul  and found just two common articles. None of the edits to those articles are even similar. Is there something I'm missing here?  Vanjagenije   (talk)  22:04, 14 May 2015 (UTC)
 * Indeed, the relation between the AnulBanul and Wüstenfuchs accounts cannot be said to constitute sockpuppetry. I wanted to agree with Joy's description of the situation as "fishy". While I am not sure whether a user can be "officially" reprimanded for it, the ultimate goal of deliberate misrepresentation of oneself (i.e. the invention of an entire persona) can hardly be anything other than sinister. Surtsicna (talk) 22:22, 14 May 2015 (UTC)
 * "Deliberate misrepresentation of oneself"? We met before? --AnulBanul (talk) 23:11, 14 May 2015 (UTC)
 * Yes, we have had sporadic interactions before your reincarnation as an Armenian woman. Surtsicna (talk) 00:10, 15 May 2015 (UTC)
 * And prior to that I was...? --AnulBanul (talk) 00:28, 15 May 2015 (UTC)
 * ... not an Armenian woman. Surtsicna (talk) 10:25, 15 May 2015 (UTC)
 * Adding Republika Srpska map instead of Bosnia and Herzegovina one is disruptive editing. So, user is sockpuppeting. --Munja-x86 (talk) 11:42, 15 May 2015 (UTC)


 * I'm closing this because I received no explanation about the WP:ILLEGITimate usage of multiple accounts. You obviously do not understand WP:SOCKPUPPETRY. If user is disruptive, report him to WP:ANI. The fact that he is disruptive does not prove sockpuppetry.  Vanjagenije   (talk)  21:16, 17 May 2015 (UTC)
 * I understand. User was reported by me on WP:ANI, nothing happened. --Munja-x86 (talk) 21:31, 17 May 2015 (UTC)
 * Just to say this in my defence about this case, once and for all, I have tried to make a compromise with you, and your answer was "do what ever you want", or similar. This is not the way in which we can discuss, especially after I have made a very reasonable suggestion. --AnulBanul (talk) 03:11, 18 May 2015 (UTC)

06 July 2015

 * Suspected sockpuppets




 * User compare report Auto-generated every hour.
 * Editor interaction utility

Background information:

is an account that demonstrably belongs to user a fact that runs counter to his blatant lie that he has "no connection to the said user whatsoever". The user, in spite of his "Armenian who lived in Serbia" persona, has never once edited the Armenian Wikipedia (hy.wikipedia.org) or Serbian Wikipedia (sr.wikipedia.org). Note that Wüstenfuchs joined WikiProject Armenia and that later AnulBanul joined WikiProject Armenia as editing from Georgia  then Russia. He then began building his persona changing his intitial name from Anulmanul to Anna Sahakyan, then Anushka , then Yerevani Axjik , and then to his current name AnulBanul. He then uploaded a selfie image to presumably impersonate a person named Anna Sahakyan from Yerevan that he took off a Facebook profile or VK (Russian social networking website). He proceeded to use that image on his userpage and refer to himself as "Anna" and created a backstory for the said individual. Numerous FB and VK profiles exist under that name, but I won't link any for their privacy.

Note that AnulBanul instead edits the Croatian Wikipedia which when he does concerns right-wing and far-right Croatian politicians and parties. which is quite odd when the user labels himself a liberal from the University of Belgrade. Indeed it's hard to believe it's anyone other than him when he does such obscure and specific edits such as (among the litany of other identical ones shown below). Note that the Wüstenfuchs account became inactive on 20 September 2014, two days later the AnulBanul account became active on 22 September 2014. The last edit of Wüstenfuchs (Bilal Bosnić, ISIL recruiter) and first edit of AnulBanul (Military intervention against ISIL) are both related to Islamic extremism. Further note that Wüstenfuchs' Mostar IP was blocked for block evading in order to edit war. That same IP edited three articles, all of which were created by Wüstenfuchs and all of which were later edited by AnulBanul/Wüstenfuchs with the same POV: Avdo Humo (IP:, AnulBanul: ), Hasan Brkić (IP: , Wüstenfuchs ), and Osman Karabegović (IP: , Wüstenfuchs: )

On 26 May AnulBanul was topic banned from anything related to Bosnia and Herzegovina for 3 months Immediately the day after he proceeded to vandalize a Bosnia and Herzegovina related userbox in order to troll. A week later he violated his topic ban via IPs and  both Mostar IPs. Both have the same exact lines and POV on obscure articles with one of them being pushed against Dragodol, his edit warring buddy that was also topic banned, in the Nijaz Duraković article and in the Jovan Divjak article the same exact line of unsourced nonsense that he was a "show general". Note that the 93.180.126.249 Mostar IP's contributions on the Croatian Wikipedia. He picks up where Wustenfuchs and AnulBanul left off on the Croatian Party of Rights of Bosnia and Herzegovina article and on the Croatian Democratic Union 1990 article  where his Herr Ziffer (blocked) and Wustenfuchs accounts formerly edited and on the Croatian Party of Rights (Bosnia and Herzegovina)  article where Wustenfuchs formerly edited. Another IP (blocked) that edited all those same articles in the same manner also created the Nijaz Duraković article on the Croatian Wikipedia. He later admitted that those were indeed his IPs however those were not the only topic ban evading IPs. Other discovered evading IPs that AnulBanul did not disclose include, , and and there are more than likely many others out there. The story does not stop with using IPs to just topic ban evade as he has also used them to vandalize, commit BLP violations, edit war and circumvent 3RR, etc and the AnulBanul account is not the only sockpuppet he has and has used the and  accounts to split his edits, evade scrutiny, and have sleeper accounts. There may be many more such accounts out there.

Evidence that ties the accounts together:


 * First ever upload on commons by AnulBanul was uploading a map of the Croatian 2014 presidential election, this same map was added to the Croatian presidential election, 2014–15 article by a Mostar IP , the same Mostar IP created the Teroristički napad u Mostaru 1997. (1997 Terrorist Attack in Mostar) article on the Croatian Wikipedia which AnulBanul later created on the English Wikipedia as Mostar terrorist attack


 * Wüstenfuchs joined WikiProject Armenia, later AnulBanul joined the WP as editing from Georgia then Russia


 * Dragan Čović, AnulBanul uploaded an image of the Bosnian Croat politician and credited it to Herr Ziffer Herr Ziffer was Wustenfuchs' sockpuppet handle at commons


 * Talk:Croatian Republic of Herzeg-Bosnia, removal of WikiProject Former countries by Wüstenfuchs, later same removal of WikiProject Former countries by AnulBanul


 * Džafer Kulenović, same "Croatian politician" POV


 * Osman Karabegović, article created by Wustenfuchs, expanded by AnulBanul


 * Hasan Brkić, article created by Wustenfuchs, portrait image uploaded by AnulBanul


 * Milan Gorkić, article created by Wustenfuchs, expanded by AnulBanul


 * Nermin Nikšić, article created by Wustenfuchs, end of term added by AnulBanul


 * Bilal Bosnić, article created by Wustenfuchs, updated by AnulBanul , addition of Wikiproject Bosnia and Herzegovina by 5.133.xxx.xxx


 * Bariša Čolak, article created by Wustenfuchs, updated by AnulBanul


 * Marinko Čavara, article created by Wustenfuchs, updated by AnulBanul


 * Fadil Hadžić, identical denial that the man is Bosniak


 * Asaf Duraković, identical denial that the man is Bosniak


 * Ante Jelavić, infobox update by Wustenfuchs, infobox update by AnulBanul


 * Croatian National Assembly, article created by Wustenfuchs, later moved and updated by AnulBanul


 * Independence Day (Bosnia and Herzegovina), article created by Wustenfuchs, later moved and updated by AnulBanul


 * Barryevi amandmani, article created by Wustenfuchs, updated by AnulBanul , updated by 5.133.xxx.xxx


 * Croatian Peasant Party of Stjepan Radić, moved by Wustenfuchs, later moved by AnulBanul


 * Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Bosnian language removed and Serbo-Croatian added by Wustenfuchs, same edit later done by AnulBanul


 * Jure Pelivan, article created by Wustenfuchs on the Croatian Wikipedia, Croat ethnicity added by AnulBanul on English Wikipedia


 * Križančevo selo killings, concerning the deaths of Bosnian Croats, moved by AnulBanul to Križančevo Selo massacre


 * Bosnian Muslims, same removal of redirect and replacement with DAB


 * Canton 10, same return of unconstitutional symbols


 * John Kasich, same concern of Croatness in early life section


 * Željko Komšić:
 * addition of "illegitimate representative" content and reference stuffed by Wüstenfuchs, sources replaced (note sfn template) by K. Solin
 * removal of information relating to Georgetown University degree by K. Solin, removal of information relating to Georgetown University degree by Mostar IP , removal of information relating to Georgetown University degree by AnulBanul


 * Dragan Čović: infobox updated by K. Solin, infobox updated by AnulBanul


 * Milan Gorkić: created by Wüstenfuchs, updated by AnulBanul and K. Solin  (note same HHVM tag)


 * Canton 10: cantonal assembly updated by K. Solin, by Mostar IP , by AnulBanul


 * Faculty of Law, University of Mostar: article created by Wüstenfuchs, redirect created by Herr Ziffer , article updated by K. Solin


 * Faculty of Philosophy, University of Mostar: created by K. Solin, moved and updated by AnlBanul to Faculty of Humanities, University of Mostar


 * Commons: Both at the University of Mostar specifically the Faculty of Philosophy/Humanities. Use identical name format using (1), (2), (3), etc. Use identical licensing and summary.
 * AnulBanul uploaded images of a speaker at the Faculty of Philosophy, University of Mostar
 * AnulBanul uploaded images of the exterior of the Faculty of Philosophy, University of Mostar
 * K. Solin uploaded images of a speaker at the Faculty of Philosophy, University of Mostar
 * K. Solin updated logo of Faculty of Law, University of Mostar intially uploaded by Herr Ziffer

[[Datoteka: and compare to AnulBanul's page [[File:
 * First edit ever edit on Croatian Wikipedia was creating a sophisticated userpage with a gradient and image. Note the code in RossaLuxx's page 
 * Added category to AnulBanul's File:Croatia 2014 map results.PNG upload, then uploaded File:Croatia 2015 map results runoff.PNG in same style of original, same summary, and same license
 * Mostar IP added AnulBanul's File:Croatia 2014 map results.PNG upload, 13 days later RossaLuxx added File:Croatia 2015 map results runoff.PNG using near identical description


 * Žitomislić: Herr Ziffer blaming destruction of a church on different army,, AnulBanul blaming destruction of same church on same army , later he claimed that he "wasn't aware" that he made the edit


 * Bitka za Karvačar: Herr Ziffer uploaded File:Bitka za Karvačar.jpg map on commons, the map was added to the article by Wüstenfuchs , article edited by K. Solin (note there are only 4 editors who have ever edited the page )


 * Dragan Čović: AnulBanul uploaded a crop of Herr Ziffer's copyvio image


 * Rafael Boban: image uploaded by Herr Ziffer, added to article by Wüstenfuchs

As shown above the user shows a propensity to evade scrutiny throughout Wikis by constant logged out IP hopping, fragmenting edit history among new accounts, and making sleeper accounts. In addition to this he has also:


 * Used a Mostar IP of Anulbanul in order to commit sneaky vandalism, a BLP violation, and libel by referring to a man as a "shithead" ("govnar") in Serbo-Croatian and pretending it's his surname
 * Used a Mostar IP of Anulbanul to immaturely troll on the Valentin Inzko article and has even vandalised a "on this day" template he personally dislikes while logged in
 * Used Mostar IPs to help initiate and facilitate edit wars, avoid 3RR, and then report the other user
 * Canton 10:, , ,
 * Herzegovina-Neretva Canton:
 * Used Mostar IPs to delete sourced information and/or push POV
 * Bosnian mujahideen:
 * Blaž Kraljević:
 * Jovan Divjak:
 * Mostar:

Note almost all of his discovered accounts have been indef blocked on various Wikis for tendentious editing and sockpuppetry:
 * Wüstenfuchs (hr)
 * AnulBanul (hr)
 * Herr Ziffer (bs, hr)
 * Wustefuchs (bs, commons)
 * Wustenfuchs (bs, commons)
 * K. Solin (hr)
 * RossaLuxx
 * Ayohayem

His Wustefuchs and Wustenfuchs  accounts were both blocked on commons "unfree files after warnings" and abuse of multiple accounts. Despite this he has evaded his block via sockpuppets and continued to purposefully upload copyrighted material under false CC licenses with his Herr Ziffer, AnulBanul, and K: Solin handles as the authors.
 * Uploading as AnulBanul an image crop of a file uploaded by Herr Ziffer which was removed for copyright violation


 * Uploading as K. Solin an image crop of a file uploaded by AnulBanul which was removed for copyright violation


 * Uploading an image taken from  while claiming he made it and falsifying the license


 * Uploading an image taken from  while claiming he made it and falsifying the license


 * Uploading several other copyright infringing images as sockpuppets Herr Ziffer and AnulBanul

Summary:

In summary his activity on Wikipedia involves:
 * 1) The absolute denial of any connection to his sockpuppet AnulBanul account and creation and non-disclosure of any other sockpuppet and sleeper accounts (K. Solin, RosaLuxx, etc)
 * 2) The impersonation of an Armenian female individual named Anna Sahakyan from Yerevan to appear more neutral, completely unrelated to past edits/accounts, and assume her identity (even going so far as to upload her selfie image) in order to deceive other users
 * 3) The constant splitting of his past edit history through new accounts and IP hopping to game the system, sockpuppeteer, deceive users, vandalize, commit BLP violations, circumvent 3RR, and avoid scrutiny
 * 4) The forging of a clean slate that is without previous ARBMAC warnings and blocks to appear in good standing and receive more leeway around admins
 * 5) The willingness to repeatedly avoid blocks and topic bans if he was sure he wouldn't be caught

First he claimed he had "no connection whatsoever" to the Wüstenfuchs account and that it wasn't his, then claimed all accounts but the Wüstenfuchs account weren't his,  and then claimed all but the Wüstenfuchs and K. Solin accounts weren't his. Note he's deleted his AnulBanul userpage likely to make evidentiary diffs of his user page null and to make the RossaLuxx claim unverifiable. Potočnik (talk) 04:25, 6 July 2015 (UTC)

Comments by other users
''Accused parties may also comment/discuss in this section below. See Defending yourself against claims.''

Clerk, CheckUser, and/or patrolling admin comments

 * This case should be history-merged into Sockpuppet investigations/Wüstenfuchs.  Vanjagenije  (talk)  18:33, 6 July 2015 (UTC)
 * ✅ &mdash;Darkwind (talk) 04:18, 8 July 2015 (UTC)


 * As I understand, admits using those accounts (here). She claims that she has "not once edited with any of those accounts at the English Wikipedia, except Wustenfuchs". That clearly not true.  made several edits is 2014, as did  and . AnulBanul explicitly admits using the  account here. Also, AnulBanul was   blocked for 10 days on 17 June, after she admitted using two IPs to avoid her topic ban (see here). One of those two IPs is also mentioned in this case . According to the evidence presented above, the  IP also belongs to her. I see no evidence for other IPs, but it's not so important anyway. So, in short, there is not much to investigate here. User admits using those accounts and (some of) those IPs. The question is whether this behavior represents sockpuppetry and, if it does, what kind of action is needed to stop the abuse. I'd say that this kind of behavior is disruptive: user created several accounts to edit same topics and push same POV, which is WP:ILLEGIT. But, there is no fresh sockpuppetry here. All those accounts except AnulBanul have not been active since December. And, all those IPs have been inactive since AnulBanul was blocked for logged-out editing.
 * I propose next solution:
 * AnulBanul should clearly mark all her alternative accounts with the User alternative account tag. And, not just those accounts mentioned here, but also any other account she created that is not mentioned in this case. If any account is discovered that belongs to her and is not tagged this way, AnulBanul should be blocked indefinitely.
 * AnulBanul should immediately stop using any other accounts or IPs. If she makes any logged-out edit or uses any other account any time in the future, she should be blocked indefinitely.  Vanjagenije  (talk)  10:17, 8 July 2015 (UTC)


 * Whether it's "fresh" is absolutely and utterly irrelevant. You don't get a pass on these kind of multiple and simultaneous serious offenses just because someone didn't notice it at the time and didn't bother to put in the leg work writing it all up. One can only imagine what other sleeper accounts and other IPs there are. It's been demonstrated he has a propensity for this sneaky and deceptive behavior and has falfely impersonated an Armenian female and stolen some stranger's selfie all in an attempt to sockpuppet as effectively as possible. You don't award clever misconduct. He has already used all these accounts to evade the indefinite block that he recieved on the Croatian and Bosnian Wikipedias and it would be delusional to believe he won't continue this type of conduct given his propensity, effort, and willingness. He's already lied multiple times about the accounts not being his and I see no reason to trust a word he has to say.


 * The IP misconduct is as important as the rest and here is the evidence for the IPs:


 * 
 * :
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * Of course the IPs are "inactive" since they are dynamic IPs from some local cafe bars. He also used other discovered evading IPs that AnulBanul did not disclose:, , and .--Potočnik (talk) 13:49, 8 July 2015 (UTC)
 * Excuse me, but it is relevant. In Wikipedia, blocks are used to prevent damage or disruption to Wikipedia, not to punish users (see: WP:NOPUNISH). We don't block users for damage made months or years ago. What exactly do you think should be done here?  Vanjagenije  (talk)  15:27, 8 July 2015 (UTC)
 * Except it's not just from a "months or years ago", but a continuing persistent pattern (for which he last got reprimanded on 17 June) which you choose to ignore and label "not so important". Every reason for WP:BLOCKPREVENTATIVE applies here. I assumed good faith the first time you claimed there was nothing "WP:ILLEGIT" going on in the first SPI despite my contentions that he obviously attempted to avoid WP:SCRUTINY and WP:GAMETHESYSTEM that you did not bother to address. I suggest you remove yourself from the case as possible COI sympathies exist between you and AnulBanul on account of you joining the Wikiproject Republika Srpska that he created.  I suggest you let a checkuser individual do their job per the overwhelming evidence provided for both the accounts and IPs. I suggest you let the SPI quickly wrap up and let the complex matter be taken to ARB and decided there per the numerous suggestions at ANI.  --Potočnik (talk) 16:50, 8 July 2015 (UTC)


 * I see that Vanjagenije has placed this investigation "on hold", but as far as I can see has not said why. Are you waiting for some development or some sort of further evidence? If so, perhaps it would be helpful to state here what that is. If not, would it not be better to take the case off hold, so that it can be dealt with? The editor who uses the pseudonym "JamesBWatson" (talk) 11:27, 25 July 2015 (UTC)
 * It's off hold now.  Vanjagenije  (talk)  11:30, 25 July 2015 (UTC)

— Berean Hunter   (talk)  14:33, 26 September 2015 (UTC)
 * Indeffing sock accounts as Annul has not complied with tagging alt accounts as proscribed. Closing.