Wikipedia:Suspected sock puppets/Biebert

User:Biebert

 * Suspected sockpuppeteer


 * Suspected sockpuppets


 * Report submission by

Nk.sheridan   Talk  22:11, 30 June 2008 (UTC)


 * Evidence
 * 1) (mainspace) Puppetmaster Biebert created article Clear Medical Solutions
 * 2) (mainspace) I requested speedy deleted of article per G11
 * 3) (mainspace) Biebert added hangon tag per
 * 4) (talkspace) Puppet Ryanjeep created talkpage stating he/she approved entry per
 * 5) (talkspace) Puppetmaster Biebert commented that he/she agrees per
 * 6) (talkspace) I argued that article fails WP:SPAM and anon IP puppet 66.84.180.140 argued that his/her edits have addressed my concerns
 * 7) (talkspace) Puppet Ryanjeep agreed with puppet 66.84.180.140 that his/her edits addressed anyones concerns and article shouldn't be deleted per
 * 8) (talkspace) Puppetmaster Biebert thanks the sockpuppets for their consensus and states that article doesn't violate any policies based on such consensus. Per
 * 9) (mainspace) There is a bit more on the associated talkpage which I haven't mentioned with more comments from the suspected socks but it ended with the removal of the AfD notice from mainspace (edit summary from 66.84.180.140 was "removal of notice after discussion" ) per

I wouldn't have listed this due to the backlog but the removal of the AfD was a kicker for me and these appear to be such blatant sockpuppets.
 * Comments

Puppetmaster and sockpuppets are single use accounts that have edited only Clear Medical Solutions which is currently nominated for AfD at Articles for deletion/Clear Medical Solutions by myself after a disputed PROD.

No longer on-going as article and talkpage have been deleted.Nk.sheridan   Talk  18:22, 1 July 2008 (UTC)

If I were an admin I might block the users and salt the article, but as it stands we have a long backlog here, so I'll let it pass and hope it doesn't flare up again. Yechiel (Shalom) Editor review 18:39, 2 July 2008 (UTC)
 * Conclusions