Wikipedia:Suspected sock puppets/Hillock65


 * The following discussion is an archived debate of the case of suspected sockpuppetry. Please do not modify it. No further edits should be made to this page. All edits should go to the talk page of this case. If you are seeing this page as a result of an attempt to open a new case of sockpuppetry of the same user, read this for detailed instructions.

User:Hillock65

 * Suspected sockpuppeteer


 * Suspected sockpuppets

Yarillastremenog 00:59, 23 January 2007 (UTC)
 * Report submission by:

Account created recently after User:Hillock65 had asked his useraccount be deleted, very similar to edit warring and accusing others of being 'xenophobic' and inciting hatred by accusing others of being Jewish
 * Evidence

,, , , 

when told about the source of the screenshots in question (a war documentary) he accuses the uploader of being an avid porn fan 


 * Report by Betacommand

 Block log (last 20):  

 Chuprynka  


 * 12:08, February 26, 2007 Betacommand (Talk | contribs | block) blocked "Chuprynka (contribs)" (anon. only, account creation blocked) with an expiry time of indefinite (Suspected sock puppets/Hillock65)

 Hillock65  


 * 12:08, February 26, 2007 Betacommand (Talk | contribs | block) blocked "Hillock65 (contribs)" (anon. only, account creation blocked) with an expiry time of indefinite (Suspected sock puppets/Hillock65)
 * 19:30, December 27, 2006 Yanksox (Talk | contribs | block) blocked "Hillock65 (contribs)" with an expiry time of 1 week (per consensus on http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WP:ANI#User:Hillock65_and_.22Jewish_atrocities_during_the_Ukrainian_famine.22)
 * 06:13, December 26, 2006 SlimVirgin (Talk | contribs | block) blocked "Hillock65 (contribs)" with an expiry time of 24 hours (3RR on History of the Jews in Ukraine)
 * 03:54, November 26, 2006 El C (Talk | contribs | block) blocked "Hillock65 (contribs)" with an expiry time of 24 hours (3RR)



 Pages edited in common by   Hillock65 and Chuprynka :   

 Page: Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II 

 Chuprynka  


 * 15:54, January 22, 2007 (hist) (diff) Articles for deletion/Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II)
 * 19:42, January 20, 2007 (hist) (diff) Articles for deletion/Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II)

 Hillock65  


 * 00:28, January 18, 2007 (hist) (diff) Articles for deletion/Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II)

 Page: Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II 

 Chuprynka  


 * 13:24, January 22, 2007 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Other forms of cooperation with occupying axis forces)
 * 13:10, January 22, 2007 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Other forms of cooperation with occupying axis forces)
 * 01:31, January 22, 2007 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Other forms of cooperation with occupying axis forces)
 * 22:12, January 21, 2007 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (Further unsubstantiated and misrepresenting pictures)
 * 19:06, January 21, 2007 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Salacious pictures)
 * 18:54, January 21, 2007 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Mess)
 * 18:09, January 21, 2007 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Mess)
 * 18:02, January 21, 2007 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Salacious pictures)
 * 17:57, January 21, 2007 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Salacious pictures)
 * 17:28, January 21, 2007 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Salacious pictures)
 * 17:04, January 21, 2007 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Salacious pictures)
 * 12:39, January 21, 2007 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Salacious pictures)
 * 12:30, January 21, 2007 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Salacious pictures)
 * 11:21, January 21, 2007 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Salacious pictures)
 * 19:36, January 20, 2007 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Salacious pictures)
 * 12:48, January 20, 2007 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Future of this article)

 Hillock65  


 * 00:36, December 26, 2006 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→This article in general)
 * 23:37, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→This article in general)
 * 20:47, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Title)
 * 15:34, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→This article in general)
 * 14:53, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→This article in general)
 * 08:31, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Ukrainian women and German soldiers)
 * 08:10, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Ukrainian women and German soldiers)
 * 07:43, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Ukrainian women and German soldiers)
 * 07:07, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Ukrainian women and German soldiers)
 * 05:36, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Ukrainian women and German soldiers)
 * 05:34, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (Ukrainian women and German soldiers)
 * 22:30, December 24, 2006 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→infoukes.com)
 * 22:16, December 24, 2006 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→infoukes.com)
 * 22:05, December 24, 2006 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→infoukes.com)
 * 20:20, December 23, 2006 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Title and opening paragraph)
 * 20:18, December 22, 2006 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Outrageously inacurate)
 * 20:18, December 22, 2006 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Outrageously inacurate)
 * 19:53, December 22, 2006 (hist) (diff) Talk:Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (←Created page with '== Outrageously inacurate == There are so many inconsistancies and outright inventions, it is even hard to pinpoint which one is the worst. Even thought there are...')

 Page: Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II 

 Chuprynka  


 * 22:13, January 21, 2007 (hist) (diff) Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (edited out false and misleading picture - see discussion)
 * 13:55, January 21, 2007 (hist) (diff) Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (edited out salacious unverified and unsourced pictures. Fair use rationale on them is being reviewed.)
 * 11:23, January 21, 2007 (hist) (diff) Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Other forms of Cooperation with occupying axis forces - there are no sources on these images, please check WP:V)
 * 19:38, January 20, 2007 (hist) (diff) Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Other forms of Cooperation with occupying axis forces - edited out unverified and salatious pictures)
 * 12:49, January 20, 2007 (hist) (diff) Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Other forms of Cooperation with occupying axis forces - edited out unsourced salacious pictures)

 Hillock65  


 * 12:49, December 27, 2006 (hist) (diff) m Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Righteous people of the world)
 * 12:09, December 27, 2006 (hist) (diff) m Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (grammar)
 * 12:08, December 27, 2006 (hist) (diff) m Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (corrected info, please read the quoted source carefully and don't misrepresent the numbers)
 * 23:38, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) m Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (added source)
 * 17:46, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (Please do not erase evidence of reputable american historian, do not erase without discussion.)
 * 17:06, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) m Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Righteous people of the world - please do not delete without discussion)
 * 17:05, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) m Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (please do not delete without discussion)
 * 15:59, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) m Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Righteous people of the world)
 * 15:58, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) m Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II
 * 15:57, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Ukrainian women and German soldiers - additions)
 * 14:55, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II
 * 09:06, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) m Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II
 * 09:03, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) m Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II
 * 09:02, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) m Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II
 * 08:42, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) m Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→References)
 * 08:13, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Ukrainian women and German soldiers - Copying and pasting material from anothe site is violation of the copy right even if it is referenced.)
 * 07:50, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Ukrainian women and German soldiers - deleted copy righted section from http://www.ekathimerini.com/4dcgi/_w_articles_ell_5990153_25/02/2006_66850)
 * 05:03, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (( per talk - not only POV but factual inaccuraccy claimed))
 * 22:10, December 24, 2006 (hist) (diff) m Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Evidence of collaboration - multiple tendetious and unverified allegations)
 * 21:56, December 24, 2006 (hist) (diff) m Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II
 * 20:38, December 24, 2006 (hist) (diff) m Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→See also)
 * 19:16, December 24, 2006 (hist) (diff) Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Evidence of collaboration)
 * 19:10, December 24, 2006 (hist) (diff) m Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Evidence of collaboration)
 * 20:31, December 22, 2006 (hist) (diff) Ukrainian-German collaboration during World War II (→Evidence of collaboration)

 Page: Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents 

 Chuprynka  


 * 17:10, January 21, 2007 (hist) (diff) Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents (→User:Yarillastremenog)
 * 13:52, January 21, 2007 (hist) (diff) Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents (User:Yarillastremenog)

 Hillock65  


 * 19:29, December 27, 2006 (hist) (diff) Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents (→Consensus on Blocks?)
 * 19:17, December 27, 2006 (hist) (diff) Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents (→Consensus on Blocks?)
 * 16:38, December 27, 2006 (hist) (diff) Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents (→Hillock's defence)
 * 16:32, December 27, 2006 (hist) (diff) Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents (→Hillock's defence)
 * 16:07, December 27, 2006 (hist) (diff) Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents (→User:Hillock65 and "Jewish atrocities during the Ukrainian famine")

 Page: User talk:Yarillastremenog/Archive 2 

 Chuprynka  


 * 14:20, January 21, 2007 (hist) (diff) User talk:Yarillastremenog/Archive 2 (Warning)

 Hillock65  


 * 18:16, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) User talk:Yarillastremenog/Archive 2 (→Please do not delete)
 * 17:10, December 25, 2006 (hist) (diff) User talk:Yarillastremenog/Archive 2 (Please do not delete)

Response to report
This report only shows that two users edited the same article. However, their behavior at the talk page was strikingly different. Chuprynka's comments were civil and reasonable. Hillock's were uncivil and defiant.

Additionally, Hillock has been notorious for POV-pushing and revert warring all over Wikipedia, while Chuprynka was not. There was no evidence that Hillock was anything more than a nationalist POV-pusher. This does not make him a socker per se. Further, the report was submitted by Yarillastremenog, a user now himself banned for sockmastering, as a retaliation for a sock-check submitted against him.

To summarize, no evidence whatsoever that Hillock is a sockmaster whatever disruptive his edits were. (I am not concenred with the fact of his block per se). Additionally, the edit patterns of the two editors are dissimilar enough to reject the match based on their edits alone. Their editing the same article does not prove sockpuppetry. I am here only to disprove false accusations. Hillock may stay banned for disruption, but he is no guilty for socking. Chuprynka has no reason to be blocked whatsoever. --Irpen 19:24, 26 February 2007 (UTC) Upon review it was decided that there's no sockpuppetry here; both users unblocked. --Akhilleus (talk) 00:33, 28 February 2007 (UTC)
 * Conclusions