Wikipedia:Suspected sock puppets/JakeGavin

User:JakeGavin

 * Suspected sock puppeteer


 * Suspected sock puppets


 * Report submission by
 * - Barek (talk • contribs) - 04:20, 16 October 2008 (UTC)

All edits involve. The issue is around the addition of non-notable individuals, soapboxing, lack of reliable sources, and insertion of original research. The reverts have been done by multiple editors, including myself.
 * Evidence

(only edits are on or about this article)
 * Edits involved: Oct 14 edit, adding non-notable individuals and unsourced soapboxing.
 * The user questioned my reasons on my talk page Oct 15 edit, to which I replied Oct 15 edit.
 * He then proceeded to reinsert the data, but used the school newspaper as a source Oct 15 edit.

(only recent edits are on this article)
 * Over multiple edits, added additional non-notable names as well as unsourced criticism of school actions Oct 15 edit
 * When these edits were reverted, re-inserted the same content again Oct 15 edit
 * When both the edits by the IP and JakeGavin were reverted again, restored both sets of content Oct 16 edit

(only edits are on this article)
 * When the IP's edits were reverted, restored the content again Oct 16 edit
 * When the content was reverted, performed a partial restore of the unsourced criticism/soapboxing content Oct 16 edit

Hello. I am WunderWu. I began editing the Ashland High School page as 66.241.94.198,‎ but when it became clear that there were disagreements over the formentioned page, I created an account in order to facilitate discussion over the matter. It should be noted that 66.241.94.198‎'s last edit is prior to WunderWu's first edit. JakeGavin is a friend of mine and we both attend Ashland High School. I apologize if I violated the terms of Wikipedia in doing so. In regard to the allegations of adding non-notable names to the forementioned article, I conceded that I did add non-notable names to the page. However, I dispute the accusation of adding critizing/soapboxing content (I assume that Barack is discussing content added under the subheading "The Half-Moon") to the forementioned page. This view expressed here is part of the offically recognized (by Ashland High School) Revolutionary Club and is not my own personal critism of the Ashland High School Administration.
 * Comments

WunderWu

Not sure who has the power to do this but you can check the IPs. Yes WunderWu and I are friends. No we are not the same person. Im not sure exactly what proof you would like me to provide but the mere fact that we were both interested in adding the same type of content to the same page does not seem like reasonable evidence.

You say "He then proceeded to reinsert the data, but used the school newspaper as a source Oct 15 edit" which under my interpretation fulfilled what you claimed to be the requirement for me to post that information. But I guess this is a different issue and has nothing to do with "sock puppets"

JakeGavin (talk) 07:22, 17 October 2008 (UTC)


 * Conclusions
 * The two accounts are blocked 24 hours apiece for blatant meatpuppeting.  Enigma  message 21:23, 22 October 2008 (UTC)