Wikipedia:Trading card game/Action plan/Phase 2:Cards/Individual card proposals/Rejected

Rejected proposals
Place all rejected proposals here, archiving the discussion with it.

Main page

 * Name of card: main page
 * Class: Article (good)
 * Text: High Priority page
 * Protected: YES *Proposed by:  Canvas  Hat 

confirmed

 * Name of card: confirmed
 * Class: Userbox
 * Text: Act as autoconfirmed
 * Required user access level: USER Registered
 * Proposed by:  Canvas  Hat 

WP:autopatrolled

 * Name of card:Autopatrolled
 * Class: Userbox
 * Text:All new articles start as C-class.
 * Required user access level: Registered
 * Proposed by:  Canvas  Hat 

MJ

 * Name of card: Michael Jackson...Woo!
 * Class: Article (good)
 * Text: Non political.
 * Protected: YES
 * Proposed by:  Canvas  Hat  00:41, 7 December 2010 (UTC)

Impact Event

 * Name of card: Impact Event
 * Class: Discord
 * Text: Everyone loses 50 cJ, discards their entire hand, and draws a new one. All articles are regressed by two stages, and all bots are destroyed.
 * Proposed by: VeryPunny

Lolcat

 * Name of card: Lolcat
 * Class: Article (good)
 * Text: I Can Has Cheezburger?
 * Protected: no
 * Proposed by: 29. November 2010

Glitched archive bot

 * Name of card: Glitched archive bot
 * Class: Discord/VandalBot
 * Text: An archiving bot has begun archiving random pages, +1 vandalism for all pages starting with letters a-d, k-q or u-z.
 * Proposed by: 28 November 2010

Marvel Comics

 * Name of card: Marvel Comics
 * Class: Article (good)
 * Text: N/A - Tribute
 * Protected: No
 * Proposed by: -- ♫Greatorangepumpkin♫ T 18:28, 9 December 2010 (UTC)

List of superhuman features and abilities in fiction

 * Name of card: NOT GONNA TYPE THAT AGAIN
 * Class: Article (good)
 * Text: THIS IS MY TRIBUTE...
 * Protected: SEMI
 * Proposed by:  Canvas  Hat  00:55, 7 December 2010 (UTC)

Obligatory cheese donation

 * Name of card: Obligatory cheese donation
 * Class: Wikipedia (bad)
 * Text: As long as this card is in play, you may not create or improve any articles until you have either improved or created an article relating to cheese.
 * Your first edit each turn must be applied to a cheese-related article.
 * Protected: YES
 * Proposed by: Bob the Wikipedian (talk • contribs) 06:08, 11 November 2010 (UTC)
 * Quote: All users of Wikipedia must make a small donation of 10 Kg of Cheddar Cheese. -- AGK

Noob

 * Name of card: Noob
 * Class: Article (bad)
 * Text: Effect:Every time this creature edits an article, it gets a vandalism message on its talk page.
 * Proposed by:

Friend of a gay

 * Name of card: Friend of a gay
 * Class: Vandal
 * Text: Causes one vandalism on each player's turn.
 * Proposed by: Bob the Wikipedian (talk • contribs) 16:40, 1 November 2010 (UTC)
 * Note: This card would HAVE to include a witty quote that explains the joke... something along the lines of "Insertions like "CHRIS IS A HOMO" make up one of the largest percentages of vandalism. If we fail to include a quote that adequately explains the joke, it'll look discriminatory.

CoD:BO

 * Name of card: Call of Duty: Black Ops
 * Class: Article (good)
 * Text: Video game article, Cold war article and Vietnam war article. Made by Treyarch. Famous (OPTIONAL)
 * Protected: YES
 * Proposed by:  Canvas  Hat  01:18, 13 November 2010 (UTC) called it. This is my tribute.

Willy on Wheels (2)

 * Name of card: Willy on Wheels
 * Class: Vandal (bad)
 * Text: When in play, this causes 3 vandalisms at the beginning of any admins', Jimbo or bureaucrats' turn.
 * Proposed by: 23 November 2010

{{collapse|

Comments
Glad to see you read the rules first. That's a step few people remember to take before proposing. Hmmmm....I'd like to hear the story of Willy on Wheels, actually, as I have no idea what exactly happened with this infamous vandal. Also-- I'm not sure I like the idea of glorifying a specific vandal by honoring him with a card, but this is up for debate...I'd be interested in hearing what others have to say on the issue of featuring a specific vandal on a card. Bob the Wikipedian (talk • contribs) 04:01, 24 November 2010 (UTC)


 * I think that it would be funny, but if Willy ever found out about it, it would be a bad thing, and we don't exactly want a tribute to him anywhere. Because of that, I think that we should not have cards for specific vandals. Also, Bob, if you want to find out, go look around. :) You have no idea how long I spent searching for anything at all about it... And udually, all I got were little references to it here and there, for the most part. Bleh. It is interesting, though, and I'm glad I did it. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Hi878 (talk • contribs) 04:09, 24 November 2010


 * See WP:WILLY for a description of his terrorous trail of vandalism. I see that there was already a rejected card about him here. 　—Preceding signed comment by Nicky Nouse (talk) 21:52, 24 November 2010 (UTC)


 * How did I not find that? GAH!!! — Preceding unsigned comment added by Hi878 (talk • contribs) 22:29, 24 November 2010


 * I first saw a link to it in the Wikipediholism test. By the way, I think Willy was there for attention, and would feel rather satisfied to have his own card. 　—Preceding signed comment by NICKY NOUSE (talk) 22:32, 24 November 2010 (UTC)


 * That was why I said it would be a bad idea. :)  Hi 8 7 8   (Come shout at me!) 22:44, 24 November 2010 (UTC)


 * That's no reason for him to return. There isn't a way for WP to track him; he'd still be vandalizing if he wanted to. Besides, this game is supposed to have some bearing on reality (although no talk pages makes sense.) 　— Preceding signed comment by NICKY NOUSE  (talk) 22:48, 24 November 2010 (UTC)


 * So what does anyone think of some sort of vandalized redirect marker especially for this card? It could be anything, a special marker, even turning cards backwards/face-down, or whatever you feel appropriate. Maybe placing those articles on... I have no idea how to represent redirect vandalism. —Preceding signed comment added by NICKY NOUSE  (talk • contribs) 23:16, 24 November 2010 (UTC)


 * I do not think that having a tribute to any vandal, especially this one, is a good idea. He seems to like seeing his name places, so giving him a card in a TCG would be a bad thing.  Hi 8 7 8   (Come shout at me!) 01:14, 25 November 2010 (UTC)
 * Alright, I can put myself into your shoes and see what you mean. I'll leave this here until tomorrow. If nobody disputes, I'll move it to the rejected cards page. —Preceding signed comment added by Nicky Nouse (talk • contribs) 01:26, 25 November 2010 (UTC)


 * Comments from the card's original proposal}}

Wild card

 * Name of card: Wild
 * Class: Special
 * Text: This card can be used as any card, good or bad, for or against any player (but it cannot break rules.)
 * Proposed by: 28 November 2010

{{collapse|

Comments
I am totally opposed to wild cards, for the simple reason that in a TCG, I doubt anyone will be able to know what all fo the cards are (unless you are us, and you are designing them). This would make it unfair, because someone may know about a card that othes do not, and they would be able to use it when the other people would not. Hi 8 7 8  (Come shout at me!) 02:05, 29 November 2010 (UTC)


 * We might be able to fit a list of available uses on the card somewhere, instead of allowing players to choose anything. —Preceding signed comment added by Nicky Nouse (talk • contribs • wikia) 02:28, 29 November 2010 (UTC)


 * I don't know, I just don't like the whole idea of it.  Hi 8 7 8   (Come shout at me!) 02:54, 29 November 2010 (UTC)


 * Comments from the card's original proposal}}

Ceiling Cat

 * Name of card: Lolcat
 * Class: Article (bad)
 * Text: Ceiling Cat is watching you [sample]
 * Protected: no
 * Proposed by: 29. November 2010

SpongeBob SquarePants

 * Name of card: SpongeBob SquarePants
 * Class: Article (good)
 * Text: (tribute card)
 * Protected: Autoconfirmed only (as in real life)
 * Proposed by: 28 November 2010

Homer Simpson

 * Name of card: Simpson
 * Class: Article (good)
 * Text: D'oh!
 * Protected: no
 * Proposed by: 29. November 2010

The Game

 * Name of card: The Game
 * Class: Discord
 * Text: You've just lost a game called The Game. Lose your turn.
 * Proposed by: 30 November 2010

Revert

 * Name of card: Revert
 * Class: Edit
 * Text: Revert one vandalism.
 * User access level: Anonymous
 * Proposed by: 1 December 2010

Captain Jack Sparrow

 * Name of card: REPLACE WITH NAME OF CARD
 * Class: Article (good)
 * Text: Fictional Character
 * Protected: YES OR NO
 * Proposed by:  Canvas  Hat  00:41, 7 December 2010 (UTC)

Mars

 * Name of card: Mars
 * Class: Article (good)
 * Text: Red Planet
 * Protected: semi
 * Proposed by:

New Super Mario Bros.

 * Name of card: New Super Mario Bros.
 * Class: Article (good)
 * Text: First platform game from the mario series playable on nds
 * Protected: no
 * Proposed by:

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time

 * Name of card: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
 * Class: Article (good)
 * Text: Fifth game from the zelda series.
 * Protected: no
 * Proposed by:

Mickey Mouse

 * Name of card: Mickey Mouse
 * Class: Article (good)
 * Text: N/A - Tribute
 * Protected: semi
 * Proposed by:

Drinking water

 * Name of card: Drinking water
 * Class: Article (good)
 * Text: N/A - Tribute
 * Protected: No
 * Proposed by: -- ♫Greatorangepumpkin♫ T 18:28, 9 December 2010 (UTC)

Practical Joke

 * Name of card: Practical Joke
 * Class: Vandalism
 * Text:Show your hand to your opponent, who will choose an edit or instant card and discard it. Oh yeah, and you just lost the Game!
 * Proposed by:  Canvas  Hat  13:30, 28 November 2010 (UTC)

Quote suggestions

Comments

Cards suggested before the rules were written
Note that these may be partly salvageable. Feel free to pull ideas from them.

Wikisloth
cannot click for Actions

Founder
Steward, Bureaucrat There may only be one Founder in play. Click ~ to delete an Editor

Wikignome
You may click ~ to prevent an opponent from deleting a rival's contribution

Broken Link Edit
(-200) Any rival beside you may click an Editor to negate this Edit

Copyvio Edit
(-500) You cannot play Actions after you play ~

Edit War Action
Click an Editor Click one of a rival's Editors

Featured Article Edit
(+500) All rivals beside you add 500 to their Contribution

Off-Wiki Plot Action
Click two Editors Divide your Contribution into two equal parts (edits-wise). Then, trade each half for half the Contributions of the rivals beside you

Oversighter Editor
Administrator Click ~ to remove a card in a Deletion Pile from the game

Canvassing Edit
(-100) You can only use ~ on yourself. You gain half the contributions earned from the next player's turn, to a maximum of 50 edits

Wheel-Warring Action
Delete one of your Administrators Rivals beside you cannot click Administrators on their next turns

Administrative Rampage Action
Administrator Delete all Editors, Founder and Bureaucrat are unaffected

TOR Router Editor
When ~ comes into play, each rival puts an Editor named "~" into play

Arbcom
Nullifies wheel-warring, editwarring and canvassing

Wikibreak Enforcer
Miss a turn.

Open proxy
?

Editing Under the Influence
?

RfB Troller
Prevent an editor from becoming a bureaucrat. but lose a wikisphere, or whatever those wiki logo things are called

Rouge Administrator
Administrator Block all innocent users.

Cabal-screamer
You can place faced down card on field

Huggler
Rollbacker May revert vandalism three times per turn.

ClueBot
You are immune to vandalism until your next turn.

POV-pusher
?

Wikiholism
One of your editors may perform two actions this turn instead of one.

Autoblock
Administrator ?

Wikicar
Move all the following back to deck and draw 5 cards.

Untraceable
(-35) Nullifies the next bot to be played.

Village Stocks
You are blocked for one turn, but can negate one editor card next turn

Deleting the main page
Administrator Temporarily de-sysop up to two administrators. Treat affected administrators as regular editors for one full round.

WikiOtter
If a vandal has deleted/blanked/vandalized a stub or article by a new user, delete that vandal.

Wikipe-tan
Can copy any effect on positive card

Fair Use
One use per card. Allows a user to copyright any card they're holding for 3 turns. If the opposing user then uses the same card within 3 turns, then that opposing user's card is void. After 3 turns, the opposing user's card is no longer void, unless Fair Use is renewed.

Good Article
Make a user an admin.

Inspiration
admin Make a new user

Second Chance
Admin Make a banned vandal a user.

Controversy
vandal remove any merits an article has

Omit
Delete one of your opponents articles.

Practical Joke
Negate the effects of an opponent's click on an editor.

Risk
user Give up a user for a random card from your opponent's hand.

FA-Tan
Make all of your articles featured.

Media Class Project
All players with an editor card in play may play one edit card without clicking an editor.

first edit
user add a user to a project