Wikipedia:Userbox policy poll/Bare list

The following is the result of a script that strips the usernames from a list of comments. = Successful = valid_username

Support

 * 1) User:StuffOfInterest
 * 2) User:Djr xi
 * 3) User:Jareth
 * 4) User:Gurch
 * 5) User:Phroziac
 * 6) User:avriette
 * 7) User:Nihonjoe
 * 8) User:Ian13
 * 9) User:Cynical
 * 10) User:Pathoschild/s
 * 11) User:Herostratus
 * 12) User:Tom harrison
 * 13) User:Doc glasgow
 * 14) User:Drini
 * 15) User:celestianpower
 * 16) User:Hiding
 * 17) User:Haukurth
 * 18) User:Aaron Brenneman
 * 19) User:Silsor
 * 20) User:Dalbury
 * 21) User:Jeffrey Smith
 * 22) User:JesseW/sig
 * 23) User:Xoloz
 * 24) User:Locke Cole
 * 25) User:BrokenSegue
 * 26) User:GTBacchus
 * 27) User:Garglebutt
 * 28) User:Stifle
 * 29) User:Grue
 * 30) User:FloNight
 * 31) User:Wwwwolf
 * 32) User:JDoorjam
 * 33) User:Proto
 * 34) User:Cedar-Guardian
 * 35) User:Bastique
 * 36) User:Bi
 * 37) User:Junes
 * 38) User:David Gerard
 * 39) User:Bkonrad
 * 40) User:R.D.H. (Ghost In The Machine)
 * 41) User:Thsgrn
 * 42) User:freakofnurture/
 * 43) User:Cohesion
 * 44) User:Misza13
 * 45) User:Ilmari Karonen
 * 46) User:Philwelch
 * 47) User:D-Day/Userboxen
 * 48) User:Dtm142
 * 49) User:Metamagician3000
 * 50) User:Jacoplane
 * 51) User:Physchim62
 * 52) User:CatherineMunro
 * 53) User:Alhutch
 * 54) User:Henrik
 * 55) User:Rx StrangeLove
 * 56) User:Celcius
 * 57) User:Banes
 * 58) User:Mike McGregor (Can)
 * 59) User:Quadell
 * 60) User:Thorri
 * 61) User:Niffweed17
 * 62) User:Mackensen
 * 63) User:Billyjoekoepsel
 * 64) User:RadioKirk
 * 65) User:Wedian
 * 66) User:Pschemp
 * 67) User:Interiot
 * 68) User:Cyde
 * 69) User:JiFish
 * 70) User:BillyH
 * 71) User:TUF-KAT
 * 72) User:LordViD
 * 73) User:Titoxd
 * 74) User:Grenavitar
 * 75) User:Jtrost
 * 76) User:JStewart
 * 77) User:TBC
 * 78) User:Stillnotelf
 * 79) User:Aren't I Obscure?
 * 80) User:The Land
 * 81) User:Sjakkalle
 * 82) User:Bletch
 * 83) User:MartinRe
 * 84) User:PJB
 * 85) User:Josiah Rowe
 * 86) User:Ral315
 * 87) User:Tarret
 * 88) User:donhalcon
 * 89) User:GoodSirJava
 * 90) User:Ummit
 * 91) User:Simetrical
 * 92) User:Pmanderson
 * 93) User:NSLE
 * 94) User:PS2pcGAMER
 * 95) User:Grm_wnr
 * 96) User:Taxman
 * 97) User:Dbiv
 * 98) User:Elkman
 * 99) User:Litefantastic
 * 100) User:SCZenz
 * 101) User:Quiddity
 * 102) User:Zocky/Picture Popups
 * 103) User:Ashibaka
 * 104) User:Rem120
 * 105) User:FelineFanatic13
 * 106) User:(aeropagitica)
 * 107) User:Babajobu
 * 108) User:Bunchofgrapes
 * 109) User:Android79
 * 110) User:Daycd
 * 111) User:Csernica
 * 112) User:Kinneyboy90
 * 113) User:Durova
 * 114) User:Yellow up
 * 115) User:the wub
 * 116) User:Inge-Lyubov
 * 117) User:Ingoolemo
 * 118) User:Prodego
 * 119) User:AlbertR
 * 120) User:EWS23
 * 121) User:Andrew Norman
 * 122) User:Spaully
 * 123) User:Lar
 * 124) User:Choess
 * 125) User:RicDod
 * 126) User:MONGO
 * 127) User:Sumthingweird
 * 128) User:ROGNNTUDJUU!
 * 129) User:TML1988
 * 130) User:Polotet
 * 131) User:Alkivar
 * 132) User:Matatigre36
 * 133) User:Martyman
 * 134) User:RaelImperialAerosolKid
 * 135) User:Noosphere
 * 136) User:Christopher Parham
 * 137) User:Uberpenguin
 * 138) User:Antandrus
 * 139) User:LukasPietsch
 * 140) User:JeffBurdges
 * 141) User:Kelly Martin
 * 142) User:Avenue
 * 143) User:Johnleemk
 * 144) User:Wikimol
 * 145) User:Jkelly
 * 146) User:AmiDaniel
 * 147) User:Viriditas
 * 148) User:Renatta81
 * 149) User:ericg
 * 150) User:ChaTo
 * 151) User:PHenry
 * 152) User:Jtmichcock
 * 153) User:Carnildo
 * 154) User:Constantine Evans
 * 155) User:Omniplex
 * 156) User:EJ
 * 157) User:Dvavasour
 * 158) User:Martinp

ConditionalSupport

 * 1) User:Guðsþegn
 * 2) User:Red Penguin
 * 3) User:Ultimaga
 * 4) User:Fang Aili

Oppose

 * 1) User:AySz88
 * 2) User:T-rex
 * 3) User:Ibaranoff24
 * 4) User:Stevietheman
 * 5) User:Waggers
 * 6) User:Migdejong
 * 7) User:Ytrottier
 * 8) User:AdamJacobMuller
 * 9) User:God_of_War
 * 10) User:Coolgamer
 * 11) User:Recon0
 * 12) User:Andux
 * 13) User:Avalon
 * 14) User:J.smith
 * 15) User:Habsfannova
 * 16) User:Dragon695
 * 17) User:Livajo
 * 18) User:SPUI/SFD
 * 19) User:Kmweber
 * 20) User:Brighterorange
 * 21) User:Shir Khan
 * 22) User:Nightstallion
 * 23) User:Jamesday
 * 24) User:Andrewpayneaqa
 * 25) User:Brian New Zealand
 * 26) User:Robust Physique
 * 27) User:nathanrdotcom
 * 28) User:Ems2
 * 29) User:Dominick
 * 30) User:Cedars
 * 31) User:-Ril-
 * 32) User:Arthur Rubin
 * 33) User:Gmcfoley
 * 34) User:Ynhockey
 * 35) User:DickClarkMises
 * 36) User:Jbamb
 * 37) User:Idont Havaname
 * 38) User:CFIF
 * 39) User:Yeltensic42
 * 40) User:Janizary
 * 41) User:SeraphimXI
 * 42) User:Hayter
 * 43) User:A435(m)
 * 44) User:Horses In The Sky
 * 45) User:Hitchhiker89
 * 46) User:Chairman S.
 * 47) User:Evrik
 * 48) User:Aliceinlampyland
 * 49) User:Pengo
 * 50) User:Sherurcij
 * 51) User:Alexwcovington
 * 52) User:Flamarande
 * 53) User:Reveilled
 * 54) User:Z.Spy
 * 55) User:Richardkselby
 * 56) User:Gilgamesh he
 * 57) User:Alex Law
 * 58) User:Admrboltz
 * 59) User:Nomader
 * 60) User:Guanaco
 * 61) User:Terenceong1992
 * 62) User:Virgil61
 * 63) User:Ansell
 * 64) User:Iamthejabberwock
 * 65) User:Thryduulf
 * 66) User:Kirils
 * 67) User:Bora Nesic
 * 68) User:WesleyPinkham
 * 69) User:tdxiang
 * 70) User:Noisy
 * 71) User:Typos
 * 72) User:Revolución
 * 73) User:Frazzydee
 * 74) User:Leinad-Z
 * 75) User:Sir_Lewk
 * 76) User:John Reid
 * 77) User:5ii
 * 78) User:Homestarmy
 * 79) User:Johnson542
 * 80) User:Matt Yeager
 * 81) User:Kobresia
 * 82) User:Looper5920
 * 83) User:Angr
 * 84) User:Zoz
 * 85) User:Tomothy
 * 86) User:Ugen64
 * 87) User:UKWiki
 * 88) User:Trisreed
 * 89) User:The Kids Aren't Alright
 * 90) User:The Halo
 * 91) User:Srikeit
 * 92) User:Spaceriqui
 * 93) User:Somody
 * 94) User:Solar
 * 95) User:Smeggysmeg
 * 96) User:Username132
 * 97) User:Wikizach
 * 98) User:Willsketch
 * 99) User:Pegship

Abstain/Neutral/Comment

 * 1) User:Jwissick
 * 2) User:TreyHarris
 * 3) User:Megaman Zero
 * 4) User:E. Brown
 * 5) User:Blu Aardvark
 * 6) User:Krash
 * 7) User:Computerjoe
 * 8) User:Kmweber
 * 9) User:Acebrock
 * 10) User:JFred
 * 11) User:ikiroid
 * 12) User:DrIdiot
 * 13) User:Durova
 * 14) User:Rebroad
 * 15) User:JeffBurdges
 * 16) User:Llywrch
 * 17) User:Hipocrite

= Errors = bad_username

Support

 * 1) I think the new proposed policy is wonderful, but holding a straw poll at this stage is not good.  If people have objections to aspects of the new proposal, let us change the proposal to address those objections (it's a wiki!) and not cement the thing in its current form by holding a premature poll. I move that we abandon this poll and just see how things progress over the next few days. -- Tony Sidaway 20: 27, 22 February 2006 (UTC) Setting aside my qualms for now. Let's go with what we've got. -- Tony Sidaway 20: 46, 22 February 2006 (UTC)
 * 2) Support strongly. Just as long as "More Cowbell" can stay ;-) Just zis Guy you know? 19: 48, 23 February 2006 (UTC)
 * 3) Support -  • The Giant Puffin •  21: 10, 26 February 2006 (UTC)
 * 4) Stong support per everyone else. Finally, some progress! -- CJ Marsicano 05: 31, 28 February 2006 (UTC)
 * 5) Me joins the mindless sheep and most likely gets eaten by a Grue, but hey, life's short, so I support. Hey, that rhymed.

Oppose

 * 1) This proposal only opens the door to more bickering, by declaring that all POV, and all political POV and/or advocacy, will be banished from userboxdom. On the other hand idenfitication will be "okay" (so long as it is not a partisan political affiliation). The problem is that identification itself is always going to be a POV decision. That may or may not start out a political matter, but it certainly can be. And it certainly can become political - especially when you don't allow people to just be up front.
 * 2) Oppose. My opposition is based on a few points,
 * 3) Oppose, like some of the alleged supporters probably would, but they're probably being fooled by misleading wording.

Abstain / Neutral / Comment

 * 1) Neutral. In general I think this proposal sort of goes in the right direction and I think we need some sort of policy here.  But I find the proposal muddily formulated and I am unclear about what implications it would have.  See my questions on the talk page for the kind of unclarity I find. --- Charles Stewart (talk) 21: 26, 23 February 2006 (UTC)