Wikipedia:WikiProject Atheism/Cleanup listing

About this listing
The listing is based on a database snapshot of 2010-03-12. It contains all articles flagged for cleanup which are tagged with WikiProject Atheism on their talk page.

Based on that data, 270 articles are assigned to this project, of which 139, or 51.5%, are flagged for cleanup.

The following quality assessment classes were evaluated for this report:

The following importance assessment classes were evaluated for this report:

Featured articles
The project has 2 featured articles. 1 of them, or 50.0%, is flagged for cleanup.

Good articles
The project has 7 good articles. 1 of them, or 14.3%, is flagged for cleanup.

Top-importance articles
The project has 6 top-importance articles. 4 of them, or 66.7%, are flagged for cleanup.

High-importance articles
The project has 29 high-importance articles. 21 of them, or 72.4%, are flagged for cleanup.

Further entries (summary)
Detail listing is suppressed due to size restrictions.

Accuracy disputes

 * Mr. A (May 2008)
 * Salvador Allende (May 2009)
 * Theodicy (May 2009)

Articles contradicting other articles

 * Madalyn Murray O'Hair

Articles lacking in-text citations

 * Military Association of Atheists & Freethinkers (Jan 2009)
 * The Atheism Tapes (Apr 2009)
 * Sea of Faith (May 2009)

Articles lacking ISBNs

 * Svetozar Marković

Articles lacking reliable references

 * An Intelligent Person's Guide to Atheism (Jul 2007)
 * Terry Sanderson (writer) (Oct 2007)
 * John Hartung (Jun 2008)
 * Hector Avalos (Aug 2008)
 * Philosophy of religion (Oct 2008)
 * Polly Toynbee (Dec 2008)
 * Susan Blackmore (May 2009)
 * Atheist Delusions (Jul 2009)
 * Atomic whirl (Jul 2009)
 * Pat Condell (Sep 2009)
 * Boy Scouts of America membership controversies (Dec 2009)

Articles lacking sources

 * Incompatible-properties argument (Jul 2008)
 * Atheist existentialism (Apr 2009)

Articles needing additional references

 * Holy Lance (Feb 2007)
 * Skepticism (Apr 2007) «High»
 * Nontheism (Jun 2007) «High»
 * Secular ethics (Aug 2007) «High»
 * Annie Besant (Sep 2007)
 * Religion in the Soviet Union (Jan 2008)
 * Ben Klassen (Mar 2008)
 * God is dead (Apr 2008)
 * God in Buddhism (Jul 2008)
 * Mr. A (Aug 2008)
 * Argument from inconsistent revelations (Sep 2008)
 * Svetozar Marković (Oct 2008)
 * Karl Marx (Dec 2008) «High»
 * Peter Joseph (Dec 2008)
 * Theo van Gogh (film director) (Feb 2009)
 * Go God Go XII (Mar 2009)
 * Pol Pot (Mar 2009)
 * Pol Pot (Apr 2009)
 * Agnosticism (Nov 2009) «Top»
 * Metaphysical naturalism (Nov 2009) «High»
 * Society of the Godless (Nov 2009)
 * History of atheism (Jan 2010) «Top»
 * Existence of God (Feb 2010) «Top»
 * History of atheism (Feb 2010) «Top»
 * Percy Bysshe Shelley (Feb 2010)
 * Richard Leakey (Feb 2010)
 * Russell's teapot (Feb 2010)
 * Secularism (Feb 2010) «High»
 * World Pantheist Movement (Feb 2010)
 * Benito Mussolini (Mar 2010)

Articles needing cleanup

 * God Is Not Great (Aug 2007)
 * Argument from free will (Oct 2007)
 * Madalyn Murray O'Hair (Jul 2008)
 * Finngeir Hiorth (Dec 2008)
 * Antony Flew (Mar 2009)
 * Atheist Delusions (Jul 2009)
 * Vladimir Lenin (Nov 2009)
 * Humanism (Mar 2010)

Articles needing more detailed references

 * Mr. A
 * Pol Pot

Articles that may contain original research

 * An Intelligent Person's Guide to Atheism (Sep 2007)
 * Argument from poor design (Oct 2007)
 * Philosophy of religion (Dec 2007)
 * Philosophy of religion (Jan 2008)
 * Agnosticism (May 2008) «Top»
 * Philosophy of religion (Oct 2008)
 * Isaac Asimov (Dec 2008)
 * Salvador Allende (May 2009)
 * Woody Allen (May 2009)
 * Criticism of religion (Jul 2009) «High»
 * Irreligion (Sep 2009) «High»
 * Theological noncognitivism (Oct 2009)
 * Boy Scouts of America membership controversies (Jan 2010)
 * Indeterminacy (philosophy) (Jan 2010)
 * State atheism (Jan 2010) «High»
 * World Pantheist Movement (Feb 2010)

Articles that need to be wikified

 * Sean Sinjin (Apr 2008)

Articles to be expanded

 * The Atheism Tapes (Jun 2008)
 * Salvador Allende (Jul 2008)
 * Jonathan Miller (Oct 2008)
 * Humanist Union (Dec 2008)
 * Morality without religion (Jan 2009) «High»
 * Criticism of religion (Sep 2009) «High»
 * Christopher Hitchens (Oct 2009)
 * Discrimination against atheists (Jan 2010) «High»
 * Criticism of atheism (Feb 2010) «High»
 * Discrimination against atheists (Feb 2010) «High»
 * Illuminati (Feb 2010)

Articles to be merged

 * Adevism (Jun 2008)
 * Implicit and explicit atheism (Apr 2009)
 * Weak and strong atheism (Sep 2009) «High»
 * Absolute atheism (Jan 2010)
 * Pseudo atheism (Jan 2010)
 * Real atheism (Jan 2010)
 * Theodicy (Feb 2010)
 * Creativity Alliance (Mar 2010)

Articles with dead external links

 * Argument from poor design (Jun 2008)
 * List of nontheists (film, radio, television and theater) (Aug 2008)
 * List of nontheists (surnames R to S) (Aug 2008) «High»
 * Woody Allen (Feb 2009)
 * List of nontheists (authors) (Apr 2009)
 * Joseph Stalin (Jul 2009)
 * Invisible Pink Unicorn (Aug 2009)
 * Boy Scouts of America membership controversies (Sep 2009)
 * Pat Condell (Sep 2009)
 * Criticism of atheism (Oct 2009) «High»
 * Criticism of religion (Oct 2009) «High»
 * Joseph Stalin (Nov 2009)
 * Boy Scouts of America membership controversies (Jan 2010)
 * Brights movement (Jan 2010)
 * Criticism of Christianity (Feb 2010) «High»
 * Geert Wilders (Feb 2010) «GA»
 * Benito Mussolini (Mar 2010)
 * Jean-Paul Sartre (Mar 2010)
 * Joseph Stalin (Mar 2010)

Articles with disputed statements

 * Theodicy (May 2009)
 * Christian atheism (Aug 2009)
 * Weak and strong atheism (Sep 2009) «High»
 * Antony Flew (Nov 2009)
 * Buddhism (Nov 2009)
 * H. L. Mencken (Feb 2010)

Articles with minor POV problems

 * Christopher Hitchens (Mar 2010)

Articles with obsolete information

 * Boy Scouts of America membership controversies

Articles with specifically-marked weasel-worded phrases

 * Joseph Stalin (Jul 2008)
 * Demographics of atheism (Apr 2009) «High»
 * Criticism of religion (Oct 2009) «High»
 * Christian atheism (Nov 2009)
 * Criticism of religion (Nov 2009) «High»
 * Nihilism (Nov 2009) «High»
 * Criticism of atheism (Dec 2009) «High»
 * Criticism of Christianity (Jan 2010) «High»
 * Mao Zedong (Jan 2010)
 * Metaphysical naturalism (Jan 2010) «High»
 * Criticism of Christianity (Feb 2010) «High»

Articles with too many examples

 * Religious satire

Articles with topics of unclear notability

 * John Hartung (Jun 2008)
 * Internet Infidels (Oct 2009)
 * List of fictitious atheists and agnostics (Feb 2010)
 * Creativity Alliance

Articles with trivia sections

 * The Match! (Mar 2009)
 * H. L. Mencken (Apr 2009)

Jan 2007

 * Mao Zedong

Feb 2007

 * Atheism and religion «High»
 * Ayaan Hirsi Ali
 * Holy Lance
 * Indeterminacy (philosophy)
 * Michel Onfray
 * Religious satire

Apr 2007

 * Ayaan Hirsi Ali

May 2007

 * Indeterminacy (philosophy)
 * Norwegian Heathen Society

Jul 2007

 * History of atheism «Top»
 * Humanistic Judaism
 * Percy Bysshe Shelley

Aug 2007

 * Mao Zedong
 * Secular ethics «High»
 * The Match!

Sep 2007

 * Khorloogiin Choibalsan

Oct 2007

 * Nadine Gordimer
 * Pol Pot
 * Religious satire
 * Sigmund Freud

Nov 2007

 * Percy Bysshe Shelley

Dec 2007

 * Philosophy of religion
 * Secular humanism «High»

Jan 2008

 * Argument from poor design
 * Holy Lance
 * Humanism
 * Secular humanism «High»

Feb 2008

 * The End of Faith

Mar 2008

 * Ayaan Hirsi Ali
 * Indeterminacy (philosophy)
 * Ontological argument
 * Religion in the Soviet Union

Apr 2008

 * Argument from nonbelief
 * Percy Bysshe Shelley
 * Theodicy
 * The Root of All Evil?

May 2008

 * Indeterminacy (philosophy)

Jun 2008

 * George Burdi
 * George Carlin
 * Implicit and explicit atheism

Jul 2008

 * Bruno Bauer
 * Criticism of Christianity «High»
 * Joseph Stalin
 * Pol Pot

Aug 2008

 * Deconstruction-and-religion
 * Matthew F. Hale

Sep 2008

 * Agnosticism «Top»
 * Criticism of Christianity «High»
 * Joseph Conrad
 * List of nontheists (philosophy)
 * Metaphysical naturalism «High»
 * Religion in the Soviet Union
 * State atheism «High»

Oct 2008

 * God in Buddhism
 * H. L. Mencken
 * Metaphysical naturalism «High»
 * Samora Machel

Nov 2008

 * Agnosticism «Top»
 * Demographics of atheism «High»

Dec 2008

 * History of atheism «Top»
 * Mao Zedong
 * Nontheism «High»
 * Pol Pot
 * Susan Blackmore

Jan 2009

 * Isaac Asimov
 * Pol Pot
 * Secularism «High»

Feb 2009

 * Atheism in Hinduism
 * Criticism of Christianity «High»
 * Criticism of religion «High»
 * Gavrilo Princip
 * Theo van Gogh (film director)

Mar 2009

 * History of atheism «Top»
 * Indeterminacy (philosophy)
 * Karl Marx «High»
 * Matthew F. Hale
 * Nihilism «High»
 * Theodicy

Apr 2009

 * Atheism «FA, Top»
 * Baron d'Holbach
 * Salvador Allende
 * Weak and strong atheism «High»

May 2009

 * God in Buddhism
 * Salvador Allende
 * Theodicy

Jun 2009

 * Demographics of atheism «High»
 * Sigmund Freud

Jul 2009

 * Criticism of atheism «High»
 * God in Buddhism
 * Humanism (life stance)
 * Joseph Stalin
 * Religion in the European Union
 * Woody Allen

Aug 2009

 * God in Buddhism
 * Jean Meslier
 * Mao Zedong
 * Peter Joseph

Sep 2009

 * Boy Scouts of America membership controversies
 * Dan Barker
 * Jonathan Miller
 * Metaphysical naturalism «High»
 * Omnipotence paradox
 * Pat Condell
 * Salvador Allende

Oct 2009

 * Criticism of religion «High»
 * List of nontheists «High»
 * Religion in the European Union

Nov 2009

 * Antony Flew
 * Criticism of religion «High»
 * Humanistic Judaism
 * Mao Zedong
 * Richard Stallman
 * S. Epatha Merkerson
 * Theo van Gogh (film director)

Dec 2009

 * Boy Scouts of America membership controversies
 * Charles Bradlaugh
 * Christopher Hitchens
 * Criticism of atheism «High»
 * Demographics of atheism «High»
 * God in Buddhism
 * Opium of the people
 * Penn Jillette

Jan 2010

 * Boy Scouts of America membership controversies
 * Buddhism
 * Indeterminacy (philosophy)
 * Invisible Pink Unicorn
 * Jonathan Miller
 * Joseph Conrad
 * Karl Marx «High»
 * Mao Zedong
 * Metaphysical naturalism «High»
 * Morality without religion «High»
 * National Secular Society
 * Secular ethics «High»

Feb 2010

 * Buddhism
 * Creativity Alliance
 * Demographics of atheism «High»
 * Discrimination against atheists «High»
 * Joseph Stalin
 * List of fictitious atheists and agnostics
 * Matthew F. Hale
 * Penn & Teller
 * Religion in the European Union

Mar 2010

 * Benito Mussolini
 * Christopher Hitchens

Other

 * Brights movement

Articles with weasel words

 * Christian atheism (Nov 2009)

BLP articles lacking sources

 * Hector Avalos
 * Polly Toynbee
 * Susan Blackmore
 * Terry Sanderson (writer)

NPOV disputes

 * Argument from free will (Dec 2007)
 * Ben Klassen (Mar 2008)
 * Incompatible-properties argument (Jul 2008)
 * Bruno Bauer (Sep 2008)
 * Antitheism (Feb 2009) «High»
 * Humanism (Mar 2009)
 * Criticism of atheism (Jul 2009) «High»
 * Mao Zedong (Jan 2010)
 * Metaphysical naturalism (Jan 2010) «High»
 * Criticism of Christianity (Feb 2010) «High»

Orphaned articles

 * List of Dutch atheists (Feb 2009)
 * Sean Sinjin (Feb 2009)
 * John Hartung (Aug 2009)
 * Hans Kirk (Mar 2010)

Pages with missing references list

 * Humanism

Unreferenced BLPs

 * Finngeir Hiorth (Sep 2009)

Wikipedia articles needing clarification

 * Creativity Alliance (Jun 2009)
 * Joseph Stalin (Jun 2009)
 * Atheist Delusions (Jul 2009)
 * Criticism of religion (Nov 2009) «High»
 * Pseudo atheism (Jan 2010)
 * Mao Zedong (Feb 2010)

Wikipedia articles needing copy edit

 * Peter Joseph (Dec 2009)
 * Geert Wilders «GA»

Wikipedia articles needing factual verification

 * Atheism in Hinduism (May 2008)
 * Criticism of religion (Oct 2008) «High»

Wikipedia articles needing page number citations

 * Antony Flew
 * Benito Mussolini
 * Buddhism
 * Criticism of Christianity «High»
 * Criticism of religion «High»
 * Sam Harris (author)

Wikipedia articles needing rewrite

 * Indeterminacy (philosophy) (Jan 2010)

Wikipedia articles needing style editing

 * Argument from nonbelief (Dec 2007)
 * Atheism and religion (Dec 2007) «High»
 * Annie Besant (Aug 2009)
 * Christian atheism (Aug 2009)

Wikipedia articles with content forks

 * Theodicy

Wikipedia external links cleanup

 * 2010 Global Atheist Convention
 * Annie Besant
 * Antony Flew
 * Humanism (life stance)

Wikipedia references cleanup

 * Skepticism (Apr 2009) «High»
 * Ben Klassen (Sep 2009)

Wikipedia spam cleanup

 * 2010 Global Atheist Convention
 * Annie Besant
 * Antony Flew
 * Humanism (life stance)
 * Uri Avnery