Wikipedia:WikiProject Baseball/Peer review/Mets–Phillies rivalry

Mets-Phillies rivalry
The article attempts to establish a relatively long history for the Mets-Phillies rivalry. However, many of the items listed as incidents of the rivalry are not supported by reliable sources. For example, the first section is a perfect game thrown by a Philadelphia pitcher against the Mets in 1964. And, while the event is sourced, none of the sources contend that this event was the beginning of a substantial rivalry. Another event listed in the article is the trade of a popular New York pitcher to the Phillies. Again, the event itself is sourced, but none of the sources suggests that this contributed to the two teams disliking each other. I believe that most of the information presented within is the product of revisionist history and original research. A conclusion is being brought forth that the sources do not suggest. Thus I believe the article should be stripped of its "good" status. Thank you.Ultimahero (talk) 07:59, 21 June 2011 (UTC)